Early Habitability and Crustal Decarbonation of a Stagnant‐Lid Venus

Dennis Höning, Philipp Baumeister, John Lee Grenfell, Nicola Tosi, M. J. WayJournal of Geophysical Research Planets 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a model suggesting that early Venus, even without plate tectonics, could have maintained a habitable climate with liquid water for up to 900 million years thanks to a weathering feedback. This mechanism also predicts a "bimodal" atmospheric CO2 distribution for stagnant-lid exoplanets, offering a potential observational signature for habitability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Venus today is a hellish world with a runaway greenhouse effect and an atmosphere dominated by CO2. However, its similarity in size and bulk composition to Earth has led to speculation about its early history. A key question is whether Venus ever had a habitable period with liquid water, and if so, what mechanisms could have sustained it, especially given the absence of plate tectonics, which is thought to be crucial for Earth's long-term climate regulation via the carbonate-silicate cycle. This paper investigates the potential for habitability on an early, stagnant-lid Venus by modeling its interior and atmospheric evolution, focusing on the role of crustal decarbonation and weathering.

Methods

The authors employ a coupled interior-atmosphere evolution model. This model simulates:

  • Mantle Convection: A parameterized model of mantle convection for stagnant-lid planets.
  • Carbon Outgassing: CO2 release from the mantle via volcanic activity.
  • Weathering: The process where atmospheric CO2 is converted into carbonates on the surface, dependent on the presence of liquid water and atmospheric CO2 levels.
  • Carbonate Burial: Burial of these carbonates within the crust by ongoing volcanic activity.
  • Crustal Decarbonation: Heating of buried carbonates at depth, leading to their breakdown and release of CO2 back into the atmosphere.
  • Atmospheric Climate: A simplified two-stream radiative grey atmospheric box model to calculate surface temperature, considering CO2 and water vapor as greenhouse gases.

They specifically test scenarios with and without weathering to understand its impact on habitability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and parameterizations derived from existing literature and observational constraints for Venus.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Weathering as a Habitability Extender: The most significant finding is that silicate weathering, even on a stagnant-lid planet, can significantly extend the habitable period by keeping atmospheric CO2 levels low enough for liquid water to persist.
  • The Decarbonation Feedback Loop: When weathering ceases (due to water evaporation), a positive feedback loop kicks in: volcanism continues to degas CO2, and buried carbonates become unstable and release their own CO2. This rapid decarbonation, coupled with the lack of weathering, leads to a runaway greenhouse.
  • Bimodal CO2 Distribution for Exoplanets: The model predicts that stagnant-lid exoplanets will exhibit a bimodal distribution of atmospheric CO2. Planets with active weathering will have low CO2 and potentially habitable conditions, while those that have undergone a runaway greenhouse will have much higher CO2. This offers a potential observational signature for habitability.
  • Plate Tectonics Not Strictly Necessary for Early Habitability: While plate tectonics likely enhances habitability, this study suggests it's not a prerequisite for an extended habitable period on early Venus.

Key Results

  • Extended Habitable Period for Venus: Including weathering, the model suggests early Venus could have remained habitable for up to 900 million years (Myr), a significant extension compared to approximately 400 Myr in scenarios without weathering.
  • Reference Model Parameters: A reference model scenario with an initial mantle temperature of 1900 K and an oxygen fugacity at the iron-wüstite (IW) buffer yields an atmospheric CO2 abundance consistent with present-day Venus.
  • CO2 Threshold for Runaway Greenhouse: For a planet at Venus' distance, an initial atmosphere of 5x10¹⁹ mol CO2 allows for climate regulation and liquid water, while 1x10²⁰ mol CO2 directly triggers ocean evaporation.
  • Bimodal Distribution Difference: The difference in atmospheric CO2 between planets with and without weathering is at least one order of magnitude.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Climate Model Simplification: The use of a simple two-stream radiative grey atmospheric box model is a simplification. While it reproduces some results from more complex 3D climate models, its reliability is limited when atmospheric CO2 and water vapor changes are large, particularly after ocean evaporation.
  • Weathering Parameterization: The dependence of weathering on CO2 is a simplification. Additional dependencies on surface temperature or ocean pH, and the exact mineralogy of Venus (basaltic vs. felsic), could affect the habitable time span.
  • Mantle Water Content: The model assumes a dry mantle, neglecting the potential influence of water on mantle viscosity, convection, and degassing.
  • Initial CO2 Abundance: While the study explores initial CO2-rich atmospheres, the exact initial conditions are uncertain.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that a better understanding of Venus' mineralogy and crustal production history is needed. Further work could explore the impact of topography shifts, thermodynamic limits to weathering, and the role of water in the mantle. The VERITAS mission is highlighted as a potential step towards determining Venus' surface mineralogy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Little is known about the early evolution of Venus and a potential habitable period during the first 1 billion years. In particular, it remains unclear whether or not plate tectonics and an active carbonate‐silicate cycle were present. In the presence of liquid water but without plate tectonics, weathering would have been limited to freshly produced basaltic crust, with an early carbon cycle restricted to the crust and atmosphere. With the evaporation of surface water, weathering would cease. With ongoing volcanism, carbonate sediments would be buried and sink downwards. Thereby, carbonates would heat up until they become unstable and the crust would become depleted in carbonates. With supply to the atmosphere the surface temperature rises further, the depth below which decarbonation occurs decreases, causing the release of even more . We assess the habitable period of an early stagnant‐lid Venus by employing a coupled interior‐atmosphere evolution model accounting for degassing, weathering, carbonate burial, and crustal decarbonation. We find that if initial surface conditions allow for liquid water, weathering can keep the planet habitable for up to 900 Myr, followed by evaporation of water and rapid crustal carbonate depletion. For the atmospheric of stagnant‐lid exoplanets, we predict a bimodal distribution, depending on whether or not these planets experienced a runaway greenhouse in their history. Planets with high atmospheric could be associated with crustal carbonate depletion as a consequence of a runaway greenhouse, whereas planets with low atmospheric would indicate active silicate weathering and thereby a habitable climate.
BibTeX
@article{honing2021early,
  author = {Dennis Höning and Philipp Baumeister and John Lee Grenfell and Nicola Tosi and M. J. Way},
  title = {{Early Habitability and Crustal Decarbonation of a Stagnant‐Lid Venus}},
  journal = {Journal of Geophysical Research Planets},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1029/2021je006895},
}
Figure