Earlier Bedtime and Effective Coping Skills Predict a Return to Low-Risk of Depression in Young Adults during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Qingyu Zhao, Ke Wang, Orsolya Kiss, Dilara Yüksel, Massimiliano de Zambotti, Duncan B. Clark, David B. Goldston, Kate B. Nooner, Sandra A. Brown, Susan F. Tapert, Wesley K. Thompson, Bonnie J. Nagel, Adolf Pfefferbaum, Edith V. Sullivan, Kilian M. Pohl, Fiona C. BakerInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study tracked depressive symptom trajectories in young adults throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, revealing diverse responses. Crucially, it found that an earlier bedtime and, for older young adults, better coping skills significantly predicted a return to low-risk depression levels by late 2021. This highlights the potential of simple behavioral interventions for mitigating long-term mental health impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic presented unprecedented challenges to mental health, particularly for young adults who were already navigating significant developmental transitions. While initial studies documented increased depression rates, there was a critical need to understand the long-term trajectories of these symptoms and identify factors that could promote recovery. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of what differentiates young adults who remained at high risk for depression from those who managed to return to lower-risk levels, even amidst the ongoing pandemic. Understanding these protective factors is essential for developing targeted interventions and public health strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a longitudinal design, analyzing data collected from participants before and at multiple points during the COVID-19 pandemic. They used the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D-10) to assess depressive symptom severity, defining a score of 10 or higher as indicative of high-risk for depression.

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Latent Class Analysis (or similar trajectory modeling): To categorize participants into distinct groups based on their depressive symptom trajectories over time (e.g., consistently low-risk, persistently high-risk, early onset high-risk, delayed onset high-risk).
  • Logistic Regression: To identify predictors of returning to a low-risk state for depression among those who had become high-risk during the pandemic. This involved modeling the probability of transitioning from high-risk to low-risk status.
  • Control Variables: The models controlled for demographic factors (age, sex, race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, study site) to isolate the effects of the behavioral and lifestyle predictors.
  • Interaction Terms: The analysis specifically examined age-by-coping interactions to see if coping skills had a differential impact based on age.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the National Consortium on Alcohol and NeuroDevelopment in Adolescence (NCANDA) study. This is an existing, longitudinal dataset that allowed researchers to track participants' mental health and behaviors both before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. The specific subset of participants analyzed (n=399) were those who completed all four COVID-19 surveys.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Divergent Trajectories: The pandemic didn't uniformly impact young adults' mental health; instead, it led to distinct patterns of depressive symptom development and recovery. This highlights the complexity of individual responses to widespread stressors.
  • Sleep as a Protective Factor: An earlier bedtime emerged as a significant predictor of returning to low-risk depression levels. This underscores the fundamental role of sleep hygiene in mental well-being, even in the face of major societal disruptions.
  • Coping Skills Matter (Especially for Older Young Adults): For those in their mid to late twenties, effective coping strategies were associated with a decline in depressive symptoms. This suggests that the ability to adapt and manage stress becomes increasingly crucial as individuals mature.
  • Age-Specific Predictors: The finding that coping skills were predictive for older young adults but not younger ones points to developmental differences in how individuals manage stress and emotional regulation.

Key Results

  • Trajectory Distribution:
    • 38% remained at low-risk throughout the study period.
  • 14% were persistently high-risk before and during the pandemic.
  • 30% became high-risk in June 2020.
  • 18% became high-risk later in the pandemic.
  • Recovery Rates: Of those who became high-risk in June 2020, 51% had returned to a low-risk state by 2021.
  • Predictors of Recovery:
    • Earlier bedtime in June 2020 was significantly associated with returning to low-risk status (p = 0.018).
  • An age-by-coping interaction was significant (p = 0.010). Post-hoc tests revealed that older participants (median age 22.2 years) who returned to low-risk had significantly better coping strategies than their high-risk counterparts (p = 0.047). This effect was not observed in younger participants.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Generalizability: The findings may not be generalizable to all young adults due to the specific demographic makeup of the NCANDA cohort and potential variations in local COVID-19 restrictions across study sites.
  • Self-Report Bias: The reliance on self-report questionnaires for sleep, coping, and depression could introduce biases related to social desirability and recall accuracy.
  • Diagnostic Limitations: The CES-D-10 is a screening tool, not a diagnostic instrument for Major Depressive Disorder (MDD).
  • Unmeasured Factors: Other potential risk factors for depression, such as evening chronotype, were not investigated.

Future work could focus on:

  • Investigating the mechanisms underlying the delayed onset of depressive symptoms in a subset of participants.
  • Exploring the factors that predict recovery for those with delayed onset depression.
  • Examining the impact of specific types of coping strategies.
  • Understanding how varying levels of local restrictions might have influenced trajectories.

Summary updated

Abstract

To determine the persistent effects of the pandemic on mental health in young adults, we categorized depressive symptom trajectories and sought factors that promoted a reduction in depressive symptoms in high-risk individuals. Specifically, longitudinal analysis investigated changes in the risk for depression before and during the pandemic until December 2021 in 399 young adults (57% female; age range: 22.8 ± 2.6 years) in the United States (U.S.) participating in the National Consortium on Alcohol and NeuroDevelopment in Adolescence (NCANDA) study. The Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D-10) was administered multiple times before and during the pandemic. A score ≥10 identified individuals at high-risk for depression. Self-reported sleep behavior, substance use, and coping skills at the start of the pandemic were assessed as predictors for returning to low-risk levels while controlling for demographic factors. The analysis identified four trajectory groups regarding depression risk, with 38% being at low-risk pre-pandemic through 2021, 14% showing persistent high-risk pre-pandemic through 2021, and the remainder converting to high-risk either in June 2020 (30%) or later (18%). Of those who became high-risk in June 2020, 51% were no longer at high-risk in 2021. Logistic regression revealed that earlier bedtime and, for the older participants (mid to late twenties), better coping skills were associated with this declining risk. Results indicate divergence in trajectories of depressive symptoms, with a considerable number of young adults developing persistent depressive symptoms. Healthy sleep behavior and specific coping skills have the potential to promote remittance from depressive symptoms in the context of the pandemic.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2022earlier,
  author = {Qingyu Zhao and Ke Wang and Orsolya Kiss and Dilara Yüksel and Massimiliano de Zambotti and Duncan B. Clark and David B. Goldston and Kate B. Nooner and Sandra A. Brown and Susan F. Tapert and Wesley K. Thompson and Bonnie J. Nagel and Adolf Pfefferbaum and Edith V. Sullivan and Kilian M. Pohl and Fiona C. Baker},
  title = {{Earlier Bedtime and Effective Coping Skills Predict a Return to Low-Risk of Depression in Young Adults during the COVID-19 Pandemic}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph191610300},
}
Figure