Dynamics of Paddy Field Patterns in Response to Urbanization: A Case Study of the Hang-Jia-Hu Plain

Jie Song, Dongyan Cai, Jinsong Deng, Ke Wang, Zhangquan ShenSustainability 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how rapid urbanization in China's Hang-Jia-Hu Plain has impacted valuable paddy fields, finding that 88% of new urban land development occurred on these agricultural areas. The research highlights that different urban expansion patterns (autonomous vs. passive) have distinct effects on paddy field loss, with future urbanization likely to further threaten these critical agricultural lands.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China has experienced unprecedented urban growth since the late 1970s, leading to significant land-use changes. While urban expansion is well-documented, there's a critical need to understand its specific impacts on agricultural land, particularly high-quality paddy fields, which are vital for food security and ecosystem services. The Hang-Jia-Hu Plain, a major rice-producing region, is a prime example of this challenge. This paper aims to fill the gap in understanding the diverse patterns of urban expansion and their differential effects on paddy fields at a regional scale, providing insights for sustainable land-use planning.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining Geographic Information Systems (GIS), gradient analysis, and landscape metrics.

  • GIS Spatial Analysis: Used to map and analyze land-use changes over time.
  • Gradient Paradigm: Ten concentric buffer zones were created around urban centers to analyze how urbanization intensity and landscape patterns change with distance from the city core. This helps differentiate between urban cores, transition zones, and urban fringes.
  • Urbanization Intensity Index (UII): Quantifies the rate of urban expansion within each buffer zone over specific periods.
  • Urban Landscape Shape Index (ULSI): Measures the complexity and irregularity of urban patch shapes, indicating the nature of urban sprawl.
  • Paddy Field Landscape Percentage (PLAND): Assesses the proportion of paddy fields within each buffer zone.
  • Paddy Field Landscape Shape Index (PLSI): Measures the complexity and irregularity of paddy field shapes, reflecting fragmentation due to development.

These metrics were used to compare different urban expansion modes (autonomous vs. passive) and their impacts on paddy fields across various time periods.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Digital Land-Use Maps: Provided by the Chinese Ministry of Environmental Protection for the years 1980, 1990, 2000, and 2010. These maps were derived from remote sensing and field surveys with over 90% accuracy.
  • Digital Map of Farmland Quality Grade: A 1:500,000 scale map from the Ministry of Land and Resources of China (MLR), used to categorize paddy fields into three quality levels (Level I, II, and III).
  • Demographic and Socio-economic Data: Collected from local statistical bureaus for the years 1980, 1990, 2000, and 2010.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Paddy Fields as Primary Targets: The study reveals a stark reality: new urban development overwhelmingly encroaches on existing paddy fields, particularly high-quality ones. This highlights a direct conflict between agricultural land preservation and urban expansion.
  • Distinct Urban Expansion Styles: The research clearly differentiates between "autonomous" (regular, compact growth) and "passive" (irregular, sprawling growth) urban expansion. This distinction is crucial because these patterns have different consequences for surrounding paddy fields.
  • Urban Fringe Vulnerability: Passive expansion, often driven by economic development zones, leads to irregular sprawl that disproportionately impacts paddy fields in the urban fringe, creating complex and fragmented landscapes.
  • Future Urbanization Trends: The "urbanization curve" suggests that future growth will increasingly occur in passive expansion cities, implying that paddy fields in these areas will continue to face significant risks.
  • Loss of Ecosystem Services: The destruction of paddy fields means the loss of their valuable ecosystem services, such as climate regulation and flood control, impacting the overall sustainability of the region.

Key Results

  • Massive Urban Expansion: Between 1980 and 2010, urban land in the Hang-Jia-Hu Plain increased nearly fourfold, from 435.46 km² to 1616.22 km².
  • Paddy Field Conversion: A staggering 88% of this new urban land was developed on paddy fields.
  • High-Quality Paddy Fields Affected: Level I paddy fields, representing the highest quality and accounting for 96% of the total paddy area in the study region, were significantly impacted.
  • Autonomous Expansion: In autonomous expansion cities, urban sprawl primarily occupied paddy fields in the urban core.
  • Passive Expansion: In passive expansion cities, irregular sprawl encroached on paddy fields in the more complex urban fringe.
  • Significant Decline in PLAND: Both types of expansion led to a decrease in the percentage of paddy fields (PLAND) as urban areas grew.
  • Increased Fragmentation (PLSI): The study observed an increase in the Paddy Field Landscape Shape Index (PLSI) in passive expansion cities, indicating greater fragmentation of remaining paddy fields.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study acknowledges that while policies exist, their implementation and public awareness regarding paddy field protection are insufficient, leading to continued losses. The "occupied paddy, supplemented paddy" policy is noted as having issues with supplemental paddy quality.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future studies should focus on:
  • The ecological consequences of urbanization on paddy fields.
  • The impact of landscape pattern changes on ecosystem services.
  • The relationships between socioeconomic development, paddy landscape patterns, and ecosystem service valuation.
  • Decision-makers need to engage in planning activities for regional sustainable development, incorporating these findings.

The paper strongly advocates for stricter land-use planning, including restricting urban development boundaries, promoting compact development, delimiting permanent paddy reserves, and implementing ecologically oriented management systems to ensure the sustainable development of the Hang-Jia-Hu Plain.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban land has increasingly expanded and encroached upon a significant number of paddy fields in Hang-Jia-Hu Plain, due to the rapid socio-economic development and agro-pedoclimatic conditions favorable to rice cultivation and human settlement. Although many studies have analyzed the characteristics of urban land expansion, relatively less attention has been paid to exploring the various urban expansion patterns and the impact of different urban expansion patterns on paddy field at a regional scale. This paper characterized the changing patterns of paddy fields in response to various urban expansion patterns in the Hang-Jia-Hu Plain integrating geographic information systems, gradient analyses and landscape metrics. Our results demonstrate that the amount of urban land expanded to nearly four times that of the initial area during 1980–2010 and that 88% of new urban land was developed on paddy fields. Of the total area of paddy fields, paddy fields of level I accounted for 96%. Moreover, various urban expansion styles differentially influenced the patterns of paddy fields. In autonomous expansion cities, sprawled urban land mainly occupied paddy fields in urban centers. However, the irregular expansion of passive expansion cities encroached on a number of paddy fields in the urban fringe where the landscape of urban patches and paddy fields was more complex and irregular in shape. Furthermore, the urbanization curve implies that future urbanization efforts will focus on the passive expansion cities, indicating that paddy fields still face the risk of disruption. We suggest that the boundary of urban development should be restricted, permanent paddy reserves should be delimited, and ecologically oriented management systems that target paddy field protection should be implemented to ensure the sustainable development of this region. This work improved the understanding of the urbanization process that governed paddy fields dynamics, and provides a scientific basis for decision-making processes to achieve regional sustainability.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2015dynamics,
  author = {Jie Song and Dongyan Cai and Jinsong Deng and Ke Wang and Zhangquan Shen},
  title = {{Dynamics of Paddy Field Patterns in Response to Urbanization: A Case Study of the Hang-Jia-Hu Plain}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/su71013813},
}
Figure