Dynamics in a Mandarin lesson in a British secondary school: Asymmetric power and teacher-student rapport management

Qing Li, Fotini Diamantidaki, Katharine CarruthersJournal of Applied Learning & Teaching 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the conversation between a teacher and a group of students in a Mandarin lesson at a secondary school in London. The specific task for that lesson was to nominate a team leader for the presentation of a Chinese city. By applying conversation analysis, this study reveals the asymmetric power between the teacher and students and how the teacher managed the teacher-student rapport in the class. This study also presents the dynamics in the class and the linguistic features of the conversation; the teacher eventually exerted reward, coercive, expert and legitimate power during the lesson. The study focuses on how the teacher-student rapport was challenged concerning students’ identities, educational goals, sociality right and obligations. Furthermore, this study reveals that the teacher’s questions were more referential than initial and presents how an experienced teacher managed the class and achieved the educational goal.

Introduction: The Challenge of Classroom Authority

While classroom discourse is traditionally viewed as an inherently asymmetrical power relationship—with the teacher as the authority and students as subordinates—modern classrooms are often chaotic sites of "self-selection." In these environments, students frequently challenge established hierarchies, making classroom management a complex relational task.

This research addresses a specific gap in the literature regarding Mandarin as a Second Language (MSL) instruction in British secondary schools. It explores the "relational ups and downs" of classroom management, specifically asking how a teacher can maintain authority and achieve institutional goals (such as selecting a team leader) without permanently damaging the teacher-student rapport when students become uncooperative or vague.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers employed Conversation Analysis (CA), a qualitative approach that treats talk as a social project. The study utilized the Atkinson and Heritage (1984) transcription system to capture micro-details like pauses (timed to the tenth of a second), pitch changes, and overlapping speech.

Spencer-Oatey’s Rapport Management Theory framework.

The analysis is grounded in Helen Spencer-Oatey’s Rapport Management Theory, which examines how individuals manage social relations through three main lenses: face sensitivities (self-worth), interactional goals, and sociality rights and obligations. To understand the exercise of authority, the researchers also mapped the interaction against French and Raven’s taxonomy of power bases: reward, coercive, expert, legitimate, and referent.

Strategic Power and Classroom Dynamics

The study analyzed a 5-minute "conflict conversation" involving one teacher and a group of five students. Several key linguistic and social strategies emerged:

  • The "We" Shield: Students frequently used the first-person plural pronoun ("we") as a linguistic tool to claim in-group membership and avoid individual accountability. The teacher identified this ambiguity as a barrier to the institutional goal and used targeted questioning to "deconstruct" the collective "we."
  • Referential vs. Display Questions: While most classroom questions are "display" questions (testing known answers), the teacher here shifted to referential questions (seeking genuine information). This forced students to produce more complex, authentic linguistic output as they explained their group's internal decision-making process.
  • Strategic Coercion: When the group interaction fell into chaos, the teacher utilized "coercive power" not as a sign of failed management, but as a necessary "reset."
Transcription excerpt illustrating the teacher's deployment of coercive power.

As shown in the transcription excerpt above, the teacher used high-volume directives (e.g., "QUIET," "YOU MUST") to re-establish the sociality rights and obligations of the classroom. This "harsh" tone was later reframed by the teacher as a simulation of "real-world" pressures, successfully transitioning from a coercive figure back to a mentor.

Results: The Rapport Arc and Goal Achievement

The interaction followed a U-shaped rapport curve. It began with neutral inquiry, dipped into high-intensity conflict and rapport-threatening directives, and concluded with "rapport enhancement" through compliments and shared goals.

By the end of the five-minute interaction, the teacher had successfully executed four types of power:

  1. Coercive: To regain control during chaos.
  2. Legitimate: To enforce the specific task requirements.
  3. Expert: To guide the discussion toward a resolution.
  4. Reward: To praise the final "democratic" result achieved by the students.

Ultimately, the group successfully identified two leaders and articulated their selection process, meeting both the pedagogical and social objectives of the lesson.

Limitations and Future Work

As a qualitative case study, this research has limitations. The reliance on audio recordings meant that visual cues—such as facial expressions and gestures—could not be analyzed, though they are critical to rapport. Furthermore, the single-case study of one 5-minute excerpt is not broadly generalizable. Future research should investigate how student demographics (gender, nationality) influence these dynamics and expand the scope to analyze how these power shifts affect long-term language acquisition in the MSL context.

Reference: Li, Q., Diamantidaki, F., & Carruthers, K. (2020). Dynamics in a Mandarin lesson in a British secondary school: Asymmetric power and teacher-student rapport management. Journal of Applied Learning & Teaching, 3(2).

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the conversation between a teacher and a group of students in a Mandarin lesson at a secondary school in London. The specific task for that lesson was to nominate a team leader for the presentation of a Chinese city. By applying conversation analysis, this study reveals the asymmetric power between the teacher and students and how the teacher managed the teacher-student rapport in the class. This study also presents the dynamics in the class and the linguistic features of the conversation; the teacher eventually exerted reward, coercive, expert and legitimate power during the lesson. The study focuses on how the teacher-student rapport was challenged concerning students’ identities, educational goals, sociality right and obligations. Furthermore, this study reveals that the teacher’s questions were more referential than initial and presents how an experienced teacher managed the class and achieved the educational goal.
BibTeX
@article{li2020dynamics,
  author = {Qing Li and Fotini Diamantidaki and Katharine Carruthers},
  title = {{Dynamics in a Mandarin lesson in a British secondary school: Asymmetric power and teacher-student rapport management}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Learning \& Teaching},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.37074/jalt.2020.3.2.25},
}
Figure