Dynamics and heterogeneity of a fate determinant during transition towards cell differentiation

Nicolás Peláez, Arnau Gavalda-Miralles, Bao Wang, Heliodoro Tejedor Navarro, Herman Gudjonson, Ilaria Rebay, Aaron R. Dinner, Aggelos K. Katsaggelos, Luı́s A. Nunes Amaral, Richard W. CartheweLife 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the transcription factor Yan, crucial for cell fate decisions in Drosophila eye development, doesn't operate on a simple "on/off" switch (bistability). Instead, its dynamic fluctuations and transient "noise" are key to guiding cells through differentiation, with EGFR signaling playing a critical role in managing this noise.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cell differentiation, the process by which cells become specialized, is often modeled as a bistable system. This means cells are thought to exist in one of two stable states, with a clear switch between them. In Drosophila eye development, the transcription factors Yan and its antagonist Pnt are central to this process. Previous models suggested that high Yan levels maintain multipotent progenitor cells, and a sharp drop in Yan triggers differentiation. However, experimental observations in the developing eye showed a more complex dynamic for Yan, challenging the simple bistable model and raising questions about how Yan truly regulates cell fate transitions. This paper investigates the precise dynamics and variability of Yan expression during these transitions.

Methods

The researchers employed a systems-level approach using a genetically engineered Drosophila model. They created a fluorescent reporter (Yan-YFP) to track Yan protein levels in live cells. This was combined with high-throughput microscopy and automated image analysis to quantify Yan expression in thousands of individual cells over time. To precisely map cell positions to developmental time, they leveraged the predictable movement of the morphogenetic furrow (MF) in the developing eye disc. They also used genetic manipulations, including creating null mutants for key genes (like EGFR) and overexpressing others, to probe the regulatory mechanisms influencing Yan dynamics. Statistical analysis, including fitting kinetic models (Hill functions, exponential decay) and calculating noise metrics (coefficient of variation, detrended fluctuations), was central to interpreting the data.

Datasets

The study utilized data from developing Drosophila melanogaster eye imaginal discs. They generated and analyzed transgenic fly lines expressing Yan-YFP and His2Av-mRFP (a nuclear marker). Data was collected from thousands of individual cells across different developmental stages and genetic conditions. No specific benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the focus was on generating and analyzing novel experimental data from the Drosophila eye system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Monostability, not Bistability: Contrary to previous models, Yan expression in progenitor cells exhibits a biphasic profile (rise and fall) rather than a stable high state, suggesting a monostable rather than bistable regulatory mechanism.
  • Noise as a Feature, Not a Bug: Yan expression becomes highly heterogeneous (noisy) specifically during the transition to differentiation. This noise is transient and appears to be a crucial part of the process.
  • EGFR Signaling Manages Noise: The EGF Receptor (EGFR) pathway, known to be essential for differentiation, plays a key role in the transient nature of Yan noise. Loss of EGFR signaling leads to sustained high noise, while its activation promotes noise reduction.
  • Cell Fate is Noise-Dependent: The timing of cell fate transitions appears to be less dependent on absolute Yan levels and more on the dynamic fluctuations and noise in its expression.
  • EGFR's Dual Role: EGFR signaling has a complex role, promoting Yan degradation during initial differentiation but also potentially inhibiting its decay later, and critically, controlling the transient nature of Yan noise.

Key Results

  • Yan-YFP expression in progenitor cells shows a rapid inductive phase followed by a slow decay, not a stable high level.
  • Transitions to different differentiated cell types occur over a dynamic range of Yan levels, not a single threshold.
  • Varying Yan gene dosage (and thus absolute Yan levels) did not affect cell fate transitions, reinforcing the idea that concentration is not the primary determinant.
  • Yan expression noise spikes significantly as cells transition to differentiation, with this spike being transient.
  • EGFR signaling is required for the rapid reduction of Yan noise after the spike, not for the elevation of noise itself.
  • Loss of EGFR signaling leads to prolonged Yan noise, hindering proper differentiation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a limitation: their data does not track individual cells over time, making it difficult to definitively distinguish between asynchronous fluctuations within single cells versus a population of cells existing in distinct microstates. Future work should involve real-time single-cell measurements to resolve this. They also pose several questions for future research: what triggers the noise increase? Do other determinants like Pnt also fluctuate? Do cells truly fluctuate over time, or is it a population effect? Finally, they are interested in the cause and function of noise spikes observed at specific developmental time points, such as the R8 formation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Yan is an ETS-domain transcription factor responsible for maintaining Drosophila eye cells in a multipotent state. Yan is at the core of a regulatory network that determines the time and place in which cells transit from multipotency to one of several differentiated lineages. Using a fluorescent reporter for Yan expression, we observed a biphasic distribution of Yan in multipotent cells, with a rapid inductive phase and slow decay phase. Transitions to various differentiated states occurred over the course of this dynamic process, suggesting that Yan expression level does not strongly determine cell potential. Consistent with this conclusion, perturbing Yan expression by varying gene dosage had no effect on cell fate transitions. However, we observed that as cells transited to differentiation, Yan expression became highly heterogeneous and this heterogeneity was transient. Signals received via the EGF Receptor were necessary for the transience in Yan noise since genetic loss caused sustained noise. Since these signals are essential for eye cells to differentiate, we suggest that dynamic heterogeneity of Yan is a necessary element of the transition process, and cell states are stabilized through noise reduction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pelaez2015dynamics,
  author = {Nicolás Peláez and Arnau Gavalda-Miralles and Bao Wang and Heliodoro Tejedor Navarro and Herman Gudjonson and Ilaria Rebay and Aaron R. Dinner and Aggelos K. Katsaggelos and Luı́s A. Nunes Amaral and Richard W. Carthew},
  title = {{Dynamics and heterogeneity of a fate determinant during transition towards cell differentiation}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.08924},
}
Figure