Dynamics and Failure Analysis on Rigid–Flexible Coupling Structure to Bucket Wheel Stacker Reclaimer

Xiaonan Wang, Yixiao Qin, Lin ChenMachines 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a rigid-flexible coupling dynamic model of a bucket wheel stacker reclaimer to analyze its stability and failure modes. By simulating various operating conditions and counterweight masses, the study identifies an optimal counterweight of 170 tons for stable operation and reduced stress, crucial for enhancing equipment reliability and lifespan.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bucket wheel stacker reclaimers are massive, heavy-duty machines essential for large-scale material handling in industries like ports and mining. A critical aspect of their operation is the precise adjustment of counterweights to maintain load-bearing capacity, vibration control, and overall stability. Incorrect counterweight settings can lead to instability, potential collapse, and increased maintenance costs. This paper addresses the challenge of optimizing counterweight settings to ensure operational reliability, safety, and longevity by understanding the complex dynamic behavior of the machine, particularly its rigid and flexible structural components.

Methods

The researchers developed a sophisticated rigid-flexible coupling model of the bucket wheel stacker reclaimer. This approach combines the strengths of finite element analysis (FEA) for modeling the flexible components (specifically the column, which is prone to deformation) and multibody dynamics (MBD) for simulating the overall system's motion.

Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • 3D Modeling: A detailed 3D model of the reclaimer was created using SOLIDWORKS.
  • Rigid-Flexible Coupling: The column, identified as a critical flexible component due to its structure and susceptibility to stress, was modeled using FEA. Other components were treated as rigid bodies.
  • Modal Analysis: Free modal analysis was performed on the flexible column to understand its deformation modes.
  • Constraint Definition: Appropriate constraints were defined in ADAMS (a multibody dynamics software) to connect the rigid and flexible bodies, simulating how they interact.
  • Dynamic Simulation: The model was used to simulate various working conditions, including full-load rotary reclaiming and no-load pitching.
  • Parameter Variation: The study systematically varied excavation forces (NDF and LDF) and counterweight masses to analyze their impact on system dynamics and stress levels.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulations based on the developed model and parameters derived from the machine's design and material properties.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Startup Instability is Normal: The initial startup phase of the reclaimer, regardless of working conditions, exhibits significant fluctuations in system parameters (speed, forces, etc.) due to inertia. However, these stabilize within approximately 40 seconds as damping takes effect.
  • Counterweight is King for Stability: The counterweight mass is a dominant factor influencing the stress distribution and dynamic response of the reclaimer. Small changes in counterweight can lead to significant shifts in stress levels and stability.
  • V-Shape Stress Response: Under rotary working conditions, the maximum stress exhibits a V-shaped relationship with counterweight mass. Stress decreases as counterweight increases up to an optimal point (around 170-180 tons), after which it rises again, indicating a potential failure zone.
  • Resonance Risk is Real: As the counterweight mass increases, the system's natural frequency decreases. This can bring the excavation force frequency closer to the natural frequency, increasing the risk of resonance, especially when the frequency ratio (β) exceeds 0.7. A counterweight of 210 tons pushes the system into a resonant-sensitive area.
  • Pitching vs. Slewing Dynamics Differ: The pitching motion (tilting) involves distinct force dynamics, with the pitch cylinder bearing a larger dynamic load and showing more pronounced initial vibrations compared to the gantry, which exhibits more stable force variations.

Key Results

  • Optimal Counterweight: For full-load rotary reclaiming, an optimal counterweight of 170 tons was identified, minimizing maximum stress and ensuring system stability.
  • Failure Range: For pitching conditions, the failure range was identified as below 120 tons or above 190 tons of counterweight.
  • Excavation Force Impact: Under rotary conditions, an 8.3% increase in excavation force (from 31,755 N to 63,510 N) led to a critical counterweight value increase from 120 t to 130 t.
  • Stress Reduction: With a counterweight of 170 t, the maximum stress during rotary operation was found to be 108.89 MPa, with fluctuations stabilizing around 61.79 MPa.
  • Resonance Threshold: A counterweight of 210 tons results in a frequency ratio (β) of 0.712, exceeding the safety threshold and indicating a resonant-sensitive area.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: While the model is sophisticated, it's still a representation. The paper focuses on the column as the primary flexible component; other flexible elements might influence dynamics.
  • Material Properties: The accuracy of the simulation relies on the precise material properties used.
  • External Factors: The study primarily focuses on internal dynamics and excavation forces. External factors like wind loads, ground conditions, and wear and tear are not explicitly detailed in this analysis.

The authors suggest that their work provides a theoretical basis for optimizing counterweight adjustments, guiding operational practices, and extending the equipment's service life. Future work could involve validating these simulation results with extensive field testing and exploring the impact of other environmental factors on the reclaimer's dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The adjustment of counterweights in bucket wheel stacker reclaimers is crucial for the equipment’s load-bearing capacity, vibration, and overall stability. To enhance operational reliability and safety while reducing failure rates and maintenance costs, this study employs finite element analysis (FEA) software and multibody dynamics (MBD) software to develop a rigid–flexible coupling model of the bucket wheel stacker reclaimer. By simulating the excavation forces generated by different materials, the dynamic response of the equipment during operation was analyzed. The results indicate that during the initial startup phase, significant fluctuations in the system’s parameters occur due to vibrations, but these stabilize after 40 s of damping. Comparative analysis of four excavation forces and various counterweight values during the reclaiming process identifies the optimal counterweight as 170 t. The study further reveals that under rotary working conditions, as the excavation force increases, the failure counterweight value increases by 8.3%. This research provides a theoretical basis for optimizing the adjustment of counterweights in bucket wheel stacker reclaimers, guiding operational practices under actual working conditions, ensuring efficient operation across different scenarios, and extending the equipment’s service life.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025dynamics,
  author = {Xiaonan Wang and Yixiao Qin and Lin Chen},
  title = {{Dynamics and Failure Analysis on Rigid–Flexible Coupling Structure to Bucket Wheel Stacker Reclaimer}},
  booktitle = {Machines},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/machines13030209},
}
Figure