Dynamics and control of clustered tensegrity systems

Shuo Ma, Muhao Chen, Robert E. SkeltonarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a comprehensive framework for analyzing the dynamics and control of clustered tensegrity systems (CTS). It presents novel nonlinear and linearized dynamic models, along with a general shape control law, enabling more robust and efficient design of these adaptable structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tensegrity structures, known for their lightweight and deployable nature, are inspired by biological systems and have applications ranging from robotics to aerospace. However, traditional tensegrity systems (TTS) often require numerous actuators and sensors. Clustered tensegrity systems (CTS) aim to reduce this complexity by grouping individual strings into "clustered strings" that run over pulleys. While the benefits of CTS are recognized, a unified and general analytical framework for their nonlinear dynamics, linearized dynamics, and control has been lacking. This paper addresses this gap by providing a systematic approach to model and control any CTS, regardless of its specific configuration or constraints.

Methods

The authors leverage the Lagrangian method and finite element method (FEM) to derive the dynamics of CTS. Key methodological contributions include:

  • General Nonlinear Dynamics Formulation: Derivation of nonlinear dynamics equations for CTS, accounting for elastic and plastic deformations, and including gravitational and damping forces. This formulation is shown to encompass TTS as a special case.
  • Equilibrium and Compatibility Equations: Development of equilibrium equations in three standard forms (nodal coordinate, force density, and force vector) and compatibility equations, crucial for static analysis and linearization.
  • Linearized Dynamics and Modal Analysis: Derivation of linearized dynamics equations and modal analysis for CTS, with and without boundary constraints, facilitating stability analysis and control design.
  • Nonlinear Shape Control Law: A novel control law is presented that formulates shape control as a linear algebra problem in terms of force densities. This approach simplifies the control design for achieving desired configurations.
  • Clustering Matrix (S): A mathematical tool introduced to represent the connectivity of clustered strings, allowing for a unified treatment of both TTS and CTS.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical simulations using material properties provided in Table 1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework: The paper successfully unifies the analysis of traditional and clustered tensegrity systems under a single mathematical framework, simplifying future research and design.
  • Clustering Benefits: The introduction of clustered strings, managed through the clustering matrix, demonstrably reduces the complexity of the system while maintaining or enhancing its functionality.
  • Actuation Speed Matters: Dynamic responses of CTS can deviate significantly from quasi-static predictions, especially at higher actuation speeds, highlighting the importance of dynamic modeling for real-world applications.
  • Control as Linear Algebra: The nonlinear shape control problem is elegantly transformed into a linear algebra problem, making it more tractable for implementation.
  • Integration of Structure and Control: The work emphasizes the integration of structural analysis and control design, paving the way for more sophisticated and adaptive tensegrity structures.

Key Results

The paper presents a comprehensive set of equations for the statics, dynamics, and control of CTS. The effectiveness of the proposed methods is demonstrated through three numerical examples:

  • Planar Clustered T-Bar: The analysis shows that the use of pulleys and clustered strings can decrease the structure's stiffness, as evidenced by lower natural frequencies. Dynamic responses were shown to differ from quasi-static results with increasing actuation speed. A closed-loop control strategy successfully moved the structure to a desired shape.
  • Two-Stage Clustered Tensegrity Tower: Modal analysis revealed various vibration modes, including rotations and bending. Dynamic responses again showed divergence from quasi-static predictions at faster actuation speeds. The shape control objective of folding the tower was achieved smoothly.
  • Deployable Cable Dome: This complex example demonstrated the framework's ability to handle intricate structures. The static analysis provided insights into prestress modes and deployment trajectories. Dynamic analysis highlighted the impact of actuation speed on deployment. Shape control was successfully implemented to achieve a smooth deployment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Material Models: While the paper allows for elastic and plastic deformations, it primarily uses a general stress-strain curve. Further work could explore more complex material behaviors.
  • Experimental Validation: The paper relies on numerical simulations. Experimental validation of the derived models and control strategies would be a valuable next step.
  • Actuator Dynamics: The control law assumes ideal actuators. Incorporating realistic actuator dynamics and limitations would enhance practical applicability.
  • Real-time Implementation: While the control law is presented as a linear algebra problem, its real-time implementation on hardware would require further investigation.
  • Optimization: The paper focuses on achieving specific shapes. Future work could explore optimal design and control for performance metrics like energy efficiency or robustness.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents the formulations of nonlinear and linearized statics, dynamics, and control for any clustered tensegrity system (CTS). Based on the Lagrangian method and FEM assumptions, the nonlinear clustered tensegrity dynamics with and without constraints are first derived. It is shown that the traditional tensegrity system (TTS), whose node to node strings are individual ones, yield to be a special case of the CTS. Then, equilibrium equations of the CTS in three standard forms (in terms of nodal coordinate, force density, and force vector) and the compatibility equation are given. Moreover, the linearized dynamics and modal analysis of the CTS with and without constraints are also derived. We also present a nonlinear shape control law for the control of any CTS. The control turns out to be a linear algebra problem in terms of the control variable, which is the force densities in the strings. The statics, dynamics, and control examples are carefully selected to demonstrate the developed principles. The presented approaches can boost the comprehensive studies of the statics, dynamics, and control for any CTS, as well as promoting the integration of structure and control design.
BibTeX
@misc{ma2021dynamics,
  author = {Shuo Ma and Muhao Chen and Robert E. Skelton},
  title = {{Dynamics and control of clustered tensegrity systems}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2110.09898},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.09898},
}
Figure