Dynamical susceptibility of glass formers: Contrasting the predictions of theoretical scenarios

Cristina Toninelli, Matthieu Wyart, Ludovic Berthier, Giulio Biroli, Jean–Philippe BouchaudPhysical 2005 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We compute analytically and numerically the four-point correlation function that characterizes nontrivial cooperative dynamics in glassy systems within several models of glasses: elastoplastic deformations, mode-coupling theory (MCT), collectively rearranging regions (CRR's), diffusing defects, and kinetically constrained models (KCM's). Some features of the four-point susceptibility $\chi_4(t)$ are expected to be universal: at short times we expect a power-law increase in time as $t^4$ due to ballistic motion ($t^2$ if the dynamics is Brownian) followed by an elastic regime (most relevant deep in the glass phase) characterized by a $t$ or $\sqrt{t}$ growth, depending on whether phonons are propagative or diffusive. We find in both the beta and early alpha regime that $\chi_4 \approx t^\mu$, where $\mu$ is directly related to the mechanism responsible for relaxation. This regime ends when a maximum of $\chi_4$ is reached at a time $t= t^*$ of the order of the relaxation time of the system. This maximum is followed by a fast decay to zero at large times. The height of the maximum also follows a power law $\chi_4(t^*) \approx (t^*)^\lambda$. The value of the exponents $\mu$ and $\lambda$ allows one to distinguish between different mechanisms. For example, freely diffusing defects in $d=3$ lead to $\mu=2$ and $\lambda=1$, whereas the CRR scenario rather predicts either $\mu=1$ or a logarithmic behavior depending on the nature of the nucleation events and a logarithmic behavior of $\chi_4(t^*)$. MCT leads to $\mu=b$ and $\lambda=1/\gamma$, where $b$ and $\gamma$ are the standard MCT exponents. We compare our theoretical results with numerical simulations on a Lennard-Jones and a soft-sphere system. Within the limited time scales accessible to numerical simulations, we find that the exponent $\mu$ is rather small, $\mu<1$, with a value in reasonable agreement with the MCT predictions, but not with the prediction of simple diffusive defect models, KCM's with noncooperative defects, and CRR's. Experimental and numerical determination of $\chi_4(t)$ for longer time scales and lower temperatures would yield highly valuable information on the glass formation mechanism.

The Challenge of Glassy Dynamics

When a liquid cools into a glass, its viscosity increases by 15 orders of magnitude, yet its static structure barely changes. Physicists suspect this dramatic "slowing down" is caused by a growing cooperative length scale—regions of the liquid must move together to relax. Standard two-point correlation functions, which monitor how a single point's density changes over time, fail to capture this spatial cooperation. To observe it, researchers utilize a four-point correlation function, $G_4(r, t)$, and its volume integral, the dynamical susceptibility $\chi_4(t)$. While $\chi_4(t)$ is known to peak at the system's relaxation time, the specific "shape" of its rise and the scaling of its peak provide a theoretical "fingerprint" that can distinguish between competing theories of the glass transition.

Theoretical Fingerprints of $\chi_4(t)$

By deriving the functional form of $\chi_4(t)$ across several frameworks—including Elasticity Theory, Mode-Coupling Theory (MCT), Collectively Rearranging Regions (CRR), and Defect Models—we can identify distinct temporal regimes.

Schematic evolution of the dynamical susceptibility $\chi_4(t)$ across different temporal regimes.

As illustrated in the figure, the evolution of $\chi_4(t)$ follows a predictable sequence:

  1. Ballistic and Elastic Regimes: At extremely short time scales, $\chi_4(t) \sim t^4$ for Newtonian dynamics. This is followed by an elastic regime where the signal is dominated by phonons, growing as $\sqrt{t}$ (diffusive) or $t$ (propagative).
  2. The Power-Law Rise ($\mu$): Before reaching its peak, $\chi_4(t)$ grows as $t^\mu$. The value of $\mu$ is a "smoking gun" for the underlying physics. For example, simple diffusing defects in 3D predict $\mu = 2$, while MCT predicts $\mu = b$ (where $b \approx 0.6$ for Lennard-Jones liquids).
  3. The Peak Scaling ($\lambda$): The height of the peak scales with the relaxation time as $(t^*)^\lambda$. Different theories yield different $\lambda$ values, such as $\lambda = 1$ for defects versus $\lambda = 1/\gamma$ for MCT.

Comparative Analysis and Simulation Results

To test these predictions, we performed Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations on standard computational benchmarks: binary Lennard-Jones (LJ) mixtures and soft-sphere binary mixtures. Additionally, Kinetically Constrained Models (KCMs) like the Fredrickson-Andersen and East models were used to isolate defect-mediated scenarios.

Our results indicate that in the temperature and time regimes accessible to current simulations, atomistic liquids show a rise exponent $\mu < 1$. This is in good agreement with MCT predictions but strongly contradicts simple defect models or the CRR scenario. However, the analytical predictions for defect models were confirmed in the KCM simulations, proving the theoretical framework is sound for systems where defects are indeed the primary drivers of motion.

The "Time-Scale Gap" and Future Outlook

The primary limitation of current findings is the numerical "time-scale gap." Simulations can only reach temperatures slightly above the Mode-Coupling temperature ($T_c$). Experimental glasses exist at much lower temperatures where "activated" processes, such as those described by the CRR or Adam-Gibbs picture, are expected to dominate.

While MCT fits current data well, it may fail as the system becomes more deeply supercooled. Future experimental and numerical determination of $\chi_4(t)$ for longer time scales will be vital to determine if the physical mechanism driving the glass transition shifts from MCT-like behavior to defect or nucleation-driven processes at lower temperatures.

Summary updated

Abstract

We compute analytically and numerically the four-point correlation function that characterizes nontrivial cooperative dynamics in glassy systems within several models of glasses: elastoplastic deformations, mode-coupling theory (MCT), collectively rearranging regions (CRR's), diffusing defects, and kinetically constrained models (KCM's). Some features of the four-point susceptibility chi(4) (t) are expected to be universal: at short times we expect a power-law increase in time as t(4) due to ballistic motion (t(2) if the dynamics is Brownian) followed by an elastic regime (most relevant deep in the glass phase) characterized by a t or sqrt[t] growth, depending on whether phonons are propagative or diffusive. We find in both the beta and early alpha regime that chi(4) approximately t(mu), where mu is directly related to the mechanism responsible for relaxation. This regime ends when a maximum of chi(4) is reached at a time t= t(*) of the order of the relaxation time of the system. This maximum is followed by a fast decay to zero at large times. The height of the maximum also follows a power law chi(4) (t(*)) approximately t(*lambda). The value of the exponents mu and lambda allows one to distinguish between different mechanisms. For example, freely diffusing defects in d=3 lead to mu=2 and lambda=1 , whereas the CRR scenario rather predicts either mu=1 or a logarithmic behavior depending on the nature of the nucleation events and a logarithmic behavior of chi(4) (t(*)) . MCT leads to mu=b and lambda=1/gamma , where b and gamma are the standard MCT exponents. We compare our theoretical results with numerical simulations on a Lennard-Jones and a soft-sphere system. Within the limited time scales accessible to numerical simulations, we find that the exponent mu is rather small, mu<1 , with a value in reasonable agreement with the MCT predictions, but not with the prediction of simple diffusive defect models, KCM's with noncooperative defects, and CRR's. Experimental and numerical determination of chi(4) (t) for longer time scales and lower temperatures would yield highly valuable information on the glass formation mechanism.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{toninelli2005dynamical,
  author = {Cristina Toninelli and Matthieu Wyart and Ludovic Berthier and Giulio Biroli and Jean–Philippe Bouchaud},
  title = {{Dynamical susceptibility of glass formers: Contrasting the predictions of theoretical scenarios}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.71.041505},
}
Figure