Dynamic trade-offs between biomass accumulation and division determine bacterial cell size and proteome in fluctuating nutrient environments

Josiah C. Kratz, Shiladitya BanerjeebioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a computational model that explains how bacteria dynamically adjust their cell size and growth rate in response to fluctuating nutrient environments. The model reveals that bacteria strategically prioritize either building biomass or preparing for division, leading to surprising behaviors like temporarily slowing population growth during nutrient abundance and a "memory" of past conditions that aids rapid adaptation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bacteria are masters of survival, constantly adapting to their ever-changing environments. While we understand a lot about how they grow and maintain a consistent cell size under stable conditions (steady-state exponential growth), how they manage these processes when nutrients fluctuate is less clear. This is a critical question because bacteria in nature rarely experience perfectly stable conditions. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a quantitative model that explains the dynamic trade-offs bacteria make in allocating their cellular resources (their "proteome") between accumulating biomass and preparing for cell division when nutrient levels change.

Methods

The core of this research is a "dynamic coarse-grained proteome sector model." Instead of tracking every single protein, they simplify the bacterial proteome into four key "sectors":

  • Ribosomal: Responsible for protein synthesis (biomass accumulation).
  • Metabolic: Involved in nutrient uptake and processing.
  • Division: Machinery needed for cell division.
  • Housekeeping: Proteins with functions independent of growth rate.

The model links the availability of nutrients to the cell's ability to produce proteins in these sectors. It incorporates rules for how cells decide when to divide, based on accumulating a certain amount of division proteins. Crucially, the model simulates the dynamics of these processes, meaning how they change over time in response to environmental shifts. They also introduce stochasticity (randomness) to simulate single-cell behavior, reflecting the inherent variability in biological systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a computational model and compares its predictions to existing experimental data from other published studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strategic Trade-offs: Bacteria don't just grow as fast as possible all the time. They make conscious decisions to prioritize either building more cellular material (biomass accumulation via ribosome production) or getting ready to split (division machinery).
  • Upshift Surprise: When nutrients become abundant, bacteria temporarily prioritize making more ribosomes (for biomass) over division machinery. This leads to cells growing larger before they divide, causing an overshoot in added cell volume and interdivision time.
  • Downshift Surprise: Counterintuitively, when nutrients become scarce, bacteria temporarily prioritize division over growth. This means they ramp up the costly division machinery even when resources are low, leading to a rapid decrease in cell size.
  • Phenotypic Memory: In fluctuating environments, bacteria exhibit a "memory" of their previous state. This isn't a conscious memory, but a consequence of the slow process of reallocating their proteome. This memory allows them to adapt more quickly when returning to a previously experienced environment.
  • Size Control is Dynamic: Cell size isn't just a passive outcome of growth rate; it's actively managed through these dynamic trade-offs in resource allocation.

Key Results

  • The model successfully reproduces experimentally observed cell size and growth rate dynamics during nutrient upshifts and downshifts in both exponential and stationary phases.
  • It predicts a transient overshoot in added cell volume and interdivision time during nutrient upshifts, consistent with experimental findings.
  • It predicts a temporary prioritization of division machinery during nutrient downshifts, leading to a rapid decrease in cell size.
  • Simulations show that bacteria retain a "phenotypic memory" of previous nutrient conditions, with recovery times increasing with the duration of nutrient pulses, suggesting a mechanism for faster adaptation to recurring environmental changes.
  • The model also captures size control dynamics during exit from stationary phase, showing a shift towards "sizer-like" behavior where added volume is negatively correlated with birth volume.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The model uses a "coarse-grained" approach, simplifying the complex bacterial proteome into four sectors. While this is necessary for tractability, it means that specific molecular details are abstracted away.
  • Experimental Validation: While the model is validated against existing experimental data, direct experimental testing of some of the model's specific predictions (e.g., the precise dynamics of proteome reallocation during downshifts) would be valuable.
  • Broader Environments: The study focuses on nutrient fluctuations. Future work could explore how these dynamics play out under other environmental stresses (e.g., temperature, pH) or in more complex microbial communities.
  • Fitness Advantage: The paper suggests that these dynamic strategies confer a fitness advantage, but quantifying this advantage directly in terms of survival and reproduction in fluctuating environments would be a significant next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Bacteria dynamically regulate cell size and growth rate to thrive in changing environments. While much work has been done to characterize bacterial growth physiology and cell size control during steady-state exponential growth, a quantitative understanding of how bacteria dynamically regulate cell size and growth in time-varying nutrient environments is lacking. Here we develop a dynamic coarse-grained proteome sector model which connects growth rate and division control to proteome allocation in time-varying environments in both exponential and stationary phase. In such environments, growth rate and size control is governed by trade-offs between prioritization of biomass accumulation or division, and results in the uncoupling of single-cell growth rate from population growth rate out of steady-state. Specifically, our model predicts that cells transiently prioritize ribosome production, and thus biomass accumulation, over production of division machinery during nutrient upshift, explaining experimentally-observed size control behaviors. Strikingly, our model predicts the opposite behavior during downshift, namely that bacteria temporarily prioritize division over growth, despite needing to upregulate costly division machinery and increasing population size when nutrients are scarce. Importantly, when bacteria are subjected to pulsatile nutrient concentration, we find that cells exhibit a transient memory of the previous metabolic state due to the slow dynamics of proteome reallocation. This phenotypic memory allows for faster adaptation back to previously-seen environments when nutrient fluctuations are short-lived.
BibTeX
@misc{kratz2022dynamic,
  author = {Josiah C. Kratz and Shiladitya Banerjee},
  title = {{Dynamic trade-offs between biomass accumulation and division determine bacterial cell size and proteome in fluctuating nutrient environments}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.10.03.510720},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure