Dynamic Reliability Analysis of DCS in HTR-PM Considering Fault Self-Check Rate Based on Petri Net

Wen Guo, Chao Guo, Shuqiao Zhou, Fan Chen, Xiaojin Huang, S Kabir, Y Papadopoulos, J Shah, D Sukheja, P Bhatnagar, A Jain, M Walker, S Junga, J Yoo, Y.-j Leeb, H Cheng, H Sheng, Y Jun, Z Bowen, Y Ming, A Deser, J Kuhne, S Lee, W Jung, J.-e Yang, J Purba, D Tjahyani, S Widodo, A Ekariansyah, T Aldemir, M Zeinalnezhad, A Chofreh, F Goni, L Hashemi, J Kleme, L Fierroa, R Canoa, J Garc Aa, J Zhou, G Reniers, N Chahrour, M Nasr, -m Tacnet, C B Renguer, C Lindemann, Z Rochdia, B Drissb, T Mohamedc, W HongzhouProceedings of WCSE 2022 Spring Event: 2022 9th International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Applications 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a dynamic reliability model for nuclear power plant control systems using Petri Nets to account for modern hardware's "self-check" capabilities. Their findings reveal a critical threshold: once a system’s fault self-check rate exceeds 40%, its unavailability drops by an entire order of magnitude, offering a powerful lever for improving plant safety and economics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the high-stakes environment of a Nuclear Power Plant (NPP), the Distributed Control System (DCS) is the "brain" that monitors and manages operations. Ensuring this brain doesn't fail is paramount. Traditionally, engineers have used tools like Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) or Markov models to predict reliability.

However, these methods have aging pains. FTA is "static"—it struggles to model maintenance loops or systems that change state over time. Markov models, while dynamic, suffer from "state space explosion"; as you add more components, the math becomes exponentially more complex and eventually unmanageable.

Crucially, modern digital DCS hardware has a feature older analog systems lacked: online self-checking. The system can often detect its own internal faults before they cause a failure. Traditional models don't have a straightforward way to quantify how this "self-awareness" impacts overall plant reliability. This paper fills that gap by focusing on the High Temperature Gas-Cooled Reactor - Pebble bed Module (HTR-PM).

Methods

The authors employ Petri Nets, a mathematical modeling language ideal for describing distributed, concurrent, and dynamic systems.

  • The Model: A Petri Net uses "Places" (representing system states), "Transitions" (events like failures or repairs), "Arcs" (the flow between states), and "Tokens" (representing the current status).
  • Dynamic Modeling: Unlike static trees, Petri Nets easily incorporate feedback loops—such as a component failing, being detected by a self-check, and then being repaired.
  • Monte Carlo Simulation: Because the system is complex, the authors used Monte Carlo methods, running the simulation over 1 million times for a 2,000-hour window to calculate instantaneous availability and unavailability.
  • System Architecture: They modeled the specific architecture of the HTR-PM DCS, including redundant Human-Machine Interfaces (HMI), double-looped networks, and various control stations.

Datasets

As this is an engineering reliability study rather than a machine learning paper, it does not use a "dataset" in the traditional sense. Instead, it utilizes a set of reliability parameters (failure rates $\lambda$ and maintenance times $\tau$) for ten key DCS components, such as CPU modules, I/O boards, and power supplies. These parameters (detailed in Table 1 of the paper) are derived from a combination of engineering specifications and expert opinions relevant to the HTR-PM reactor.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Self-Detection: The core "aha moment" is the quantification of the Fault Self-Check Rate ($r_s$). If a fault is detected automatically, the repair process starts immediately. If not, the system stays broken until a manual inspection (which happens much less frequently) finds it.
  • The 40% Tipping Point: The relationship between self-check rates and reliability isn't just linear. The researchers found that once the self-check rate crosses 40%, the system enters a new tier of reliability, reducing unavailability by a factor of ten.
  • Redundancy vs. Series Weakness: The simulation vividly illustrates that while redundant subsystems (like the 1-out-of-4 HMI setup) are highly resilient, non-redundant "series" components (like specific I/O boards) are the primary drivers of system-wide drops in availability.

Key Results

  • Baseline Performance: Under normal conditions, the DCS maintains a very high availability of approximately 0.9999.
  • Impact of $r_s$: When the self-check rate is low (e.g., $r_s = 0.1$), availability fluctuates significantly and drops more rapidly over time.
  • Order of Magnitude Improvement: The most significant finding is that increasing the self-check rate beyond 40% reduces the unavailability of the DCS by an order of magnitude (e.g., from $10^{-3}$ toward $10^{-4}$).
  • Maintenance Efficiency: Higher self-check rates directly correlate to shorter "average time to repair" because the detection phase of the maintenance cycle is nearly instantaneous.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few areas for further refinement:

  • Parameter Sensitivity: The model relies heavily on failure rate data which, for a specialized reactor like the HTR-PM, is often based on expert estimates. Real-world operational data would further validate these findings.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: While higher self-check rates are better for reliability, they often require more expensive hardware and complex software. The paper doesn't explore the economic "sweet spot" where the cost of increasing the self-check rate outweighs the reliability gains.
  • Integration: Future work could involve integrating this Petri Net approach into broader Probabilistic Risk Assessments (PRA) for the entire nuclear power plant, rather than just the DCS.

Summary updated

Abstract

Digital distributed control system (DCS) is the most important monitoring and control platform in a nuclear power plant (NPP). The reliability and availability modeling and analysis of digital DCS are of great significance to ensure the stable and reliable operation of NPPs and to improve the economy of NPPs. With the continuous development of control system technology, the fault self-check rate of DCS equipment is getting higher and higher. It is necessary to consider the influence of this factor in the DCS reliability model and improve the model architecture. In this paper, a dynamic reliability model of DCS based on Petri Net is proposed by considering the factor of fault self-check rate. The DCS of High Temperature Gas-Cooled Reactor -Pebble bed Module (HTR-PM) was adopted for model verification, and the reliability of the DCS was calculated by Monte Carlo method. The calculation results show that the higher the fault self-check rate, the lower the unavailability of the DCS. When the fault self-check rate exceeds 40%, the unavailability of DCS will be reduced by an order of magnitude. This conclusion has important engineering practical significance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2022dynamic,
  author = {Wen Guo and Chao Guo and Shuqiao Zhou and Fan Chen and Xiaojin Huang and S Kabir and Y Papadopoulos and J Shah and D Sukheja and P Bhatnagar and A Jain and M Walker and Y Papadopoulos and S Junga and J Yoo and Y.-J Leeb and H Cheng and H Sheng and Y Jun and Z Bowen and Y Ming and A Deser and J Kuhne and S Lee and W Jung and J.-E Yang and J Purba and D Tjahyani and S Widodo and A Ekariansyah and T Aldemir and M Zeinalnezhad and A Chofreh and F Goni and L Hashemi and J Kleme and L Fierroa and R Canoa and J Garc Aa and J Zhou and G Reniers and N Chahrour and M Nasr and -M Tacnet and C B Renguer and C Lindemann and Z Rochdia and B Drissb and T Mohamedc and C Lindemann and W Hongzhou},
  title = {{Dynamic Reliability Analysis of DCS in HTR-PM Considering Fault Self-Check Rate Based on Petri Net}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of WCSE 2022 Spring Event: 2022 9th International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Applications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.18178/wcse.2022.04.193},
}
Figure