Dynamic landscape change during the late Early to early Middle Pleistocene: evidence from East Anglia, UK

Jonathan Lee, James Rose, Ian CandyNERC 2015

Introduction

The period spanning the late Early to early Middle Pleistocene (approximately 0.9 to 0.48 million years ago) represents one of the most transformative intervals in Quaternary history. This era, often referred to as the Mid-Pleistocene Transition (MPT), is characterized by a fundamental shift in Earth's climate system, moving from 41,000-year (obliquity-forced) cycles to the more pronounced 100,000-year (eccentricity-forced) cycles. In the United Kingdom, East Anglia provides the most comprehensive—though fragmented—onshore record of these environmental shifts, situated at the western margins of the ancient North Sea Basin.

The Challenge of Chronostratigraphy

Despite the richness of the East Anglian record, establishing a robust chronostratigraphic framework has remained a persistent challenge for geologists. Traditional approaches often rely on correlating terrestrial evidence—such as river terrace sequences, biostratigraphy, and amino acid geochronology—directly with the Marine Isotope Stage (MIS) records derived from deep-sea cores.

However, this "top-down" correlation often leads to controversy. Different dating methods frequently yield conflicting timelines, and the practice of forcing fragmented terrestrial sequences into global marine stages can obscure the nuances of local environmental responses. Crucially, these methods may underestimate the speed at which physical landscapes react to climatic shifts, smoothing over high-frequency changes in favor of fitting a pre-defined orbital model.

A "Back-to-Basics" Methodology

To address these discrepancies, this research advocates for a "back-to-basics" approach that prioritizes the physical sedimentary "building blocks" of the geological record. Rather than beginning with a chronological model, the study focuses on the inherent architecture of the deposits:

  • Large-scale Geometry Analysis: Analyzing the spatial distribution and thickness of sedimentary units to reconstruct how the basin was filled and modified over time.
  • Discrete Sedimentary Markers: Identifying specific indicators of change, including ancient soil horizons (paleosols), the first appearance of specific rock types (lithologies) indicating new sediment sources, and variations in sedimentary facies (the physical and biological characteristics of a unit).
  • Process Analogues: Utilizing modern geological processes as analogues to estimate the potential rates of landscape evolution in the past.

Insights: The "Hair-Trigger" Landscape

The primary finding of this sedimentological focus is that the North Sea Basin was remarkably sensitive to climate forcing. The evidence suggests that major changes in palaeogeography and geological processes occurred at "sub-Milankovitch" timescales. This means the landscape was capable of transforming much more rapidly than the 41,000 or 100,000-year orbital cycles would suggest.

This "hair-trigger" sensitivity implies that the transition of coastlines, the redirection of river systems, and the advance or retreat of ice sheets were high-frequency events. By focusing on the physical geometry of sedimentary units, researchers can visualize a much more dynamic and rapidly shifting environment than the "smoothed" versions of history produced by rigid MIS correlation. The study successfully demonstrates that East Anglia and the North Sea Basin were highly sensitive to climate-forcing that drove major changes at speeds previously underestimated by traditional models.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The research highlights a critical methodological shift: by examining the physical building blocks of the geological record, we gain a more nuanced understanding of the speed of landscape evolution. While the East Anglian record remains "highly fragmented," this approach provides a clearer picture of the region's high-frequency response to climate change during the MPT.

Future research will likely focus on applying this "building-block" perspective to other margins of the North Sea Basin to determine if this high-frequency sensitivity is a regional phenomenon. Reconciling these rapid physical changes with existing biological and chemical dating methods remains a priority for developing a truly integrated, high-resolution model of the Pleistocene landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

The late Early to early Middle Pleistocene (0.9-0.48 Ma) is one of the most dynamic periods of Quaternary-time, coinciding with the transition from obliquity- to eccentricity-forced climate. East Anglia possesses Britain’s most complete (albeit highly-fragmented) onshore record of environmental change during this time-interval and was situated within the western margins of the North Sea Basin of the time. The geological record from the region offers an important insight into the complex patterns of climatic and palaeogeographic variability that occurred. However, attempts to apply a robust chronostratigraphic framework to this part of the Quaternary sequence have proven challenging and in some instances controversial. Difficulties have arisen due to contrasting chronological interpretations based upon different types of utilised geological evidence (e.g. river terrace chronologies, biostratigraphy and amino acid chronologies) and the tendency to attempt to correlate assemblages directly with marine isotope stages. A significant problem with these approaches is that they can underestimate the temporal responses of physical systems to change. Within this presentation, we attempt to go back-to-basics by examining the late Early to early Middle Pleistocene record of environmental change in East Anglia from the perspective of the main sedimentary building-blocks. In particular we focus upon the large-scale geometry of units and more discrete evidence (soils, first appearance lithologies, sedimentary facies variability) for palaeogeographic change and attempt to demonstrate the speed of landscape change relative to modern and other geological analogues. The findings of this approach suggest that East Anglia and the North Sea Basin were highly-sensitive to climate-forcing that acted to drive major changes in palaeogeography and geological processes that occurred at sub-Milankovitch time-scales.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2015dynamic,
  author = {Jonathan Lee and James Rose and Ian Candy},
  title = {{Dynamic landscape change during the late Early to early Middle Pleistocene: evidence from East Anglia, UK}},
  booktitle = {NERC},
  year = {2015},
}
Figure