Dynamic Functional Connectivity Better Predicts Disability Than Structural and Static Functional Connectivity in People With Multiple Sclerosis

Ceren Tozlu, Keith Jamison, Susan A. Gauthier, Amy KuceyeskiFrontiers in Neuroscience 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while structural connectivity is best for distinguishing individuals with Multiple Sclerosis (MS) from healthy controls, dynamic functional connectivity is more crucial for predicting disability levels within MS patients. This suggests that the brain's ability to adapt and change its functional connections over time is key to understanding and potentially mitigating MS-related disability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is a complex neurological disease where the severity of brain damage, as seen on imaging, doesn't always correlate with a patient's level of disability. This "clinico-radiological paradox" highlights the need for better ways to understand how brain pathology translates into functional impairment. Researchers use brain connectivity networks – how different brain regions communicate – to map these changes. However, previous studies have largely examined structural connectivity (SC) and static functional connectivity (FC) in isolation. This paper addresses the gap by directly comparing the predictive power of SC, static FC, and dynamic functional connectivity (dFC) in classifying individuals with MS and differentiating between MS patients with and without disability. Understanding which type of connectivity best captures these distinctions could lead to more accurate prognoses and targeted therapeutic strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a machine learning approach, specifically logistic regression with ridge regularization, to classify participants. They extracted three types of brain connectivity data from MRI scans:

  • Structural Connectivity (SC): Derived from diffusion MRI, this represents the physical white matter tracts connecting different brain regions.
  • Static Functional Connectivity (FC): Calculated from resting-state fMRI, this measures the average correlation of brain activity between regions over the entire scan.
  • Dynamic Functional Connectivity (dFC): Also from resting-state fMRI, this approach uses sliding windows to capture how functional connectivity patterns change over time, identifying distinct "brain states."

These connectivity measures, along with demographic and clinical information (age, sex, disease duration, etc.), were fed into the classification models. The performance of each model was evaluated using the Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve (AUC), a standard metric for classification accuracy. To handle imbalanced datasets (e.g., fewer healthy controls than MS patients), they used the Synthetic Minority Over-sampling Technique (SMOTE).

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • 100 individuals with Multiple Sclerosis (pwMS): This group included various subtypes of MS (CIS, RRMS, PPMS, SPMS).
  • 19 Healthy Controls (HC):

The pwMS group was further divided into two subgroups based on the Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS):

  • 67 pwMS with no disability (EDSS < 2)
  • 33 pwMS with evidence of disability (EDSS ≥ 2)

The data was collected from a single center using a 3T Siemens Skyra scanner. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing imaging modalities and classification techniques were applied and compared.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Connectivity is Key for Disability: The most striking finding is that while structural integrity (SC) is crucial for distinguishing between healthy individuals and those with MS, it's the dynamic nature of functional connectivity (dFC) that best predicts the level of disability within the MS population. This suggests that the brain's ability to flexibly reconfigure its communication patterns is more important for functional outcomes than its static structure.
  • Brain's Adaptive Capacity: The results imply that MS patients with higher disability may be struggling with or failing in their compensatory mechanisms. The increased dynamism in certain dFC states might represent the brain's attempt to reroute information or compensate for structural damage, but when this fails, disability emerges.
  • Specific Brain Networks Matter: The study pinpoints specific brain networks that are particularly important. The dorsal attention network, along with subcortical and cerebellar regions, are critical for distinguishing HC from pwMS via SC. For predicting disability, the dorsal attention and visual networks are highlighted by dFC.

Key Results

  • HC vs. pwMS Classification: The regional SC model achieved the highest performance, with a median AUC of 0.89. This indicates that structural connectivity is a strong indicator of whether someone has MS.
  • pwMS Disability Classification: For classifying pwMS by disability status, regional dFC and dFC metrics models significantly outperformed others, achieving median AUCs of 0.65 and 0.61, respectively. This underscores the importance of dynamic connectivity for understanding disability.
  • Feature Importance:
    • For HC vs. pwMS: Regional SC in the dorsal attention, subcortical, and cerebellar networks were the most important features.
  • For pwMS disability: Increased regional dFC in dorsal attention and visual networks (in certain states) was associated with disability. Conversely, decreased dFC in frontoparietal and cerebellar networks was also linked to disability.
  • Dwell Time in State 1: A specific dFC metric, "dwell time in state 1" (characterized by more negative FC from the ventral attention network), was the most important predictor for disability. pwMS with evidence of disability spent significantly more time in this state.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional Design: The study is cross-sectional, meaning it captures a single point in time. This limits the ability to predict future disability progression.
  • Sample Size: The number of pwMS with evidence of disability (n=33) and the number of controls (n=19) were relatively small, which could affect the robustness of the models for novel data.
  • EDSS Specificity: The EDSS primarily measures physical disability. Future studies could incorporate measures of cognitive disability to gain a more comprehensive understanding.
  • MRI Acquisition: While good, the MRI acquisition parameters could be improved (e.g., higher resolution, longer scan times) for even more detailed analysis.
  • dFC Windowing: The use of fixed window lengths for dFC analysis is a limitation; future work could explore wavelet transforms for more flexible frequency band analysis.

Future work should focus on larger, longitudinal datasets to validate these findings and develop predictive models for future disability. Exploring how dFC changes over time in response to disease progression and treatment could also be highly valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Advanced imaging techniques such as diffusion and functional MRI can be used to identify pathology-related changes to the brain's structural and functional connectivity (SC and FC) networks and mapping of these changes to disability and compensatory mechanisms in people with multiple sclerosis (pwMS). No study to date performed a comparison study to investigate which connectivity type (SC, static or dynamic FC) better distinguishes healthy controls (HC) from pwMS and/or classifies pwMS by disability status. <b>Aims:</b> We aim to compare the performance of SC, static FC, and dynamic FC (dFC) in classifying (a) HC vs. pwMS and (b) pwMS who have no disability vs. with disability. The secondary objective of the study is to identify which brain regions' connectome measures contribute most to the classification tasks. <b>Materials and Methods:</b> One hundred pwMS and 19 HC were included. Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) was used to assess disability, where 67 pwMS who had EDSS<2 were considered as not having disability. Diffusion and resting-state functional MRI were used to compute the SC and FC matrices, respectively. Logistic regression with ridge regularization was performed, where the models included demographics/clinical information and either pairwise entries or regional summaries from one of the following matrices: SC, FC, and dFC. The performance of the models was assessed using the area under the receiver operating curve (AUC). <b>Results:</b> In classifying HC vs. pwMS, the regional SC model significantly outperformed others with a median AUC of 0.89 (<i>p</i> <0.05). In classifying pwMS by disability status, the regional dFC and dFC metrics models significantly outperformed others with a median AUC of 0.65 and 0.61 (<i>p</i> < 0.05). Regional SC in the dorsal attention, subcortical and cerebellar networks were the most important variables in the HC vs. pwMS classification task. Increased regional dFC in dorsal attention and visual networks and decreased regional dFC in frontoparietal and cerebellar networks in certain dFC states was associated with being in the group of pwMS with evidence of disability. <b>Discussion:</b> Damage to SCs is a hallmark of MS and, unsurprisingly, the most accurate connectomic measure in classifying patients and controls. On the other hand, dynamic FC metrics were most important for determining disability level in pwMS, and could represent functional compensation in response to white matter pathology in pwMS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tozlu2021dynamic,
  author = {Ceren Tozlu and Keith Jamison and Susan A. Gauthier and Amy Kuceyeski},
  title = {{Dynamic Functional Connectivity Better Predicts Disability Than Structural and Static Functional Connectivity in People With Multiple Sclerosis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2021.763966},
}
Figure