Dynamic exergy analysis: From industrial data to exergy flows

Charalampos Michalakakis, Jonathan M. CullenJournal of Industrial Ecology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a dynamic exergy analysis method using real industrial data from an ammonia production plant to pinpoint inefficiencies. By overcoming data challenges and visualizing exergy flows, it provides actionable insights for plant operators to improve performance and reduce resource waste, moving beyond static simulations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As global efforts focus on decarbonizing power and transport sectors, industry is becoming a critical area for emissions reduction. Traditional energy efficiency metrics are insufficient because they don't account for material flows or the "quality" of energy (exergy). While exergy analysis is a powerful tool for this, existing studies predominantly rely on simulated, static data. This approach fails to inform real-time plant operations and identify dynamic inefficiencies. The paper addresses this gap by applying exergy analysis to a real industrial site using dynamic, sensor-generated data, aiming to provide a more accurate and actionable understanding of resource utilization and loss.

Methods

The core of this research lies in developing a methodology to convert raw industrial sensor data into a dynamic exergy analysis. This involved:

  • Data Cleaning and Preprocessing: A significant challenge was handling real-world industrial data, which often suffers from missing values, outliers, corrupted timestamps, and sensor malfunctions. The authors developed robust filtering and cleaning techniques, including imputation strategies (linear regression, local means, forward filling) and timestamp re-indexing, to create a usable dataset. They also aggregated minute-level data to daily levels to reduce computational cost.
  • Exergy Calculations: Standard exergy calculation formulas for material flows (physical and chemical exergy), electrical exergy, and heat exergy were employed. The physical exergy calculation accounts for enthalpy and entropy differences relative to standard conditions, while chemical exergy considers molar fractions and standard chemical exergies.
  • System Boundary and Scale Determination: The analysis was performed at two scales:
  • Plant-scale: Encompassing the entire steam methane reforming (SMR) plant.
  • Process-scale: Breaking down the SMR plant into its constituent processes (primary reformer, secondary reformer, high-temperature shift (HTS) reactor, combustor, heat exchangers) to achieve higher resolution.
  • Efficiency Definitions: Beyond conventional exergy efficiency, the paper utilizes "transit efficiency," which accounts for untransformed exergy flows that can artificially inflate conventional efficiency values. This provides a more realistic assessment of performance.
  • Resource Visualization: Sankey diagrams were used to visually represent both mass and exergy flows, making it easier to identify where exergy is destroyed or lost.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset spanning two years from 311 sensors at a real ammonia production site. This dataset comprised approximately 327 million data points. This is a novel dataset for dynamic exergy analysis, as it represents real-world operational data rather than simulated scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Real Data Reveals Deeper Inefficiencies: The analysis of real industrial data provides a less optimistic, but more realistic, view of plant performance compared to studies using simulated data. This highlights the importance of using actual operational data for accurate assessment.
  • Dynamic Analysis is Crucial: Static exergy analyses can mask significant inefficiencies that occur during operational fluctuations, ramp-downs, or shutdowns. Dynamic analysis captures these variations, offering a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Transit Efficiency Offers a More Realistic Picture: The "transit efficiency" metric, which accounts for exergy that passes through a system without transformation, reveals that conventional efficiency can be misleadingly high. This metric is particularly important for processes with low reaction extents.
  • Sankey Diagrams are Powerful Visual Tools: Beyond traditional engineering diagrams, Sankey diagrams effectively illustrate exergy flows and destruction points, making complex industrial processes more interpretable for operators and decision-makers.
  • Industry 4.0 Enables Advanced Analysis: The increasing availability of sensors and the shift towards Industry 4.0 are key enablers for more granular, real-time exergy analysis, paving the way for continuous performance optimization.

Key Results

  • Overall Plant Efficiency: The plant achieved an average conventional exergy efficiency of 71% and a transit efficiency of 15%.
  • Process-Specific Efficiencies:
    • Primary Reformer: 86% (conventional), 40% (transit)
    • Secondary Reformer: 96% (conventional), 71% (transit)
    • High-Temperature Shift (HTS): 99.7% (conventional), 77% (transit)
    • Combustor: 56% (conventional), 55% (transit)
    • Heat Exchange Section: 85% (conventional), 82% (transit)
  • Major Exergy Losses: The plant experienced overall exergy losses of 80 MW. The primary reformer (35 MW) and the combustor (33 MW) were identified as the processes with the highest exergy losses.
  • Stability of Performance: Plant exergy efficiency was relatively stable, fluctuating between 68-73%, except during production ramp-downs and a significant shutdown in June 2018.
  • Discrepancy in Efficiencies: Transit efficiencies were consistently lower than conventional efficiencies across all processes and the plant, highlighting the impact of untransformed exergy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Resolution and Metering: The resolution of the exergy analysis is limited by the availability and placement of sensors. While the study aimed for process-scale analysis, some areas were grouped due to data limitations, potentially obscuring finer inefficiencies.
  • Data Imputation Assumptions: While sophisticated methods were used, data imputation inherently involves assumptions that can introduce uncertainty. The assumption of constant composition for feed and fuel natural gas is noted as a potential source of error.
  • Advanced Exergy Analysis: The study did not employ advanced exergy analysis methods that split exergy destruction into avoidable and unavoidable components. These methods are more developed for power plants and require further adaptation for chemical processes.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to:
  • Rigorously correlate specific operating parameters and variables with exergy, cost, and environmental performance to inform operators.
  • Investigate whether improved resource efficiency leads to reduced emissions.
  • Explore the potential of real-time monitoring and operator control decisions informed by exergy analysis.
  • Further investigate the application of advanced exergy analysis techniques.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract As the power and transport sectors decarbonize, industrial emissions will become the main focus of decarbonization efforts. Exergy analysis provides a combined material and energy efficiency approach to assess industrial plants, both of which are necessary to tackle industrial emissions. Existing studies typically use simulated, static data that cannot inform real plant operators. This paper performs an exergy analysis on data spanning 2 years from 311 sensors of a real ammonia production site. We develop methods to overcome unique data challenges associated with real industrial data processing, visualize resource flows in Sankey diagrams, and estimate exergy indicators for both the steam methane reforming plant and its constituent processes. We evaluate average conventional and transit exergy efficiencies for the plant (71%, 15%), primary reformer (86%, 40%), secondary reformer (96%, 71%), high‐temperature shift (99.7%, 77%), combustor (56%, 55%), and heat exchange section (85%, 82%). Overall exergy losses are 80 MW; the primary reformer and combustor are the two processes with the highest losses at 35 and 33 MW, respectively. Such an analysis can inform both improvement projects and performance finetuning of a real plant while being applicable to any industrial site. Increased availability of cheap wireless sensors and a shift to Industry 4.0 can enable higher resolution and real‐time performance monitoring.
BibTeX
@article{michalakakis2021dynamic,
  author = {Charalampos Michalakakis and Jonathan M. Cullen},
  title = {{Dynamic exergy analysis: From industrial data to exergy flows}},
  journal = {Journal of Industrial Ecology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1111/jiec.13168},
}
Figure