Dynamic Evolution, Regional Differences, and Spatial Spillover Effects of Urban Ecological Welfare Performance in China from the Perspective of Ecological Value

Jun Wang, Guixiang ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the "Ecological Welfare Performance" (EWP) of Chinese cities, a crucial metric for balancing economic growth with social well-being and environmental health. Using advanced spatial econometrics and decomposition models, the research reveals dynamic trends, significant regional disparities, and spatial spillover effects of EWP across China, offering insights for more sustainable urban development strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving sustainable development requires a delicate balance between economic growth, social welfare, and environmental protection. This is particularly challenging in rapidly developing economies like China, where traditional growth models often lead to ecological degradation and resource depletion. "Ecological Welfare Performance" (EWP) is proposed as a key indicator to measure how efficiently a region converts ecological resources into economic benefits and social well-being. However, understanding the complex dynamics of EWP, especially its regional variations and how EWP in one city affects its neighbors, is crucial for effective policy-making. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive analysis of urban EWP in China, focusing on its evolution over time, spatial differences between regions, and the mechanisms driving these patterns, including how EWP in one city influences others.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted methodological approach:

  • Super-SBM-DEA Model: This advanced data envelopment analysis technique was used to construct a comprehensive EWP indicator system. It accounts for both desired (e.g., resident health, economic capacity) and non-desired (e.g., pollution emissions) outputs, and incorporates ecological capital as an input, offering a more nuanced evaluation than previous methods.
  • Dagum Gini Coefficient Decomposition: This method was used to analyze regional differences in EWP. It breaks down overall differences into contributions from within regions (intra-regional), between regions (inter-regional), and from supervariable density, helping to pinpoint the primary sources of disparity.
  • Kernel Density Estimation: This technique was employed to visualize the distribution of EWP and its absolute differences over time, revealing trends like polarization and shifts in the overall EWP landscape.
  • Convergence Analysis (σ and β): The study examined whether EWP levels tend to converge across cities over time. This included both absolute and conditional β-convergence, and importantly, spatial β-convergence to account for spatial dependencies.
  • Spatial Durbin Model (SDM): This econometric model was used to analyze the influential mechanisms of various factors on EWP, crucially incorporating spatial spillover effects. This allows researchers to understand not only how factors affect EWP locally but also how they influence EWP in neighboring cities.

Datasets

The study utilized dynamic equilibrium panel data for 287 Chinese cities from 2000 to 2020. The data were sourced from various official statistical yearbooks, including:

  • China City Statistical Yearbook
  • China Energy Statistical Yearbook
  • China Environmental Statistical Yearbook
  • China Health Statistical Yearbook
  • Annual government work reports of cities

Economic indicators were deflated to a 2010 base year to account for inflation. Foreign investment data was converted using exchange rates and then deflated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "U-shaped" Evolution: A recurring theme is the "decrease then increase" trend in urban EWP, both nationally and in many regions. This suggests that initial industrialization phases may negatively impact EWP, but with policy interventions and a shift towards sustainable practices, performance can improve.
  • East-West Strength, Central Weakness: A distinct spatial pattern emerges: EWP is generally higher in the eastern and western regions of China, while the central region lags behind. This highlights the uneven development landscape and the need for targeted strategies.
  • Supervariable Density Drives Differences: The analysis of regional differences reveals that "supervariable density" (likely referring to the variability and randomness of EWP distribution) is the largest contributor to overall disparities, more so than differences between regions or within regions.
  • Polarization is Real: Absolute differences in EWP show a significant "polarization effect," meaning that cities are increasingly diverging into high-EWP and low-EWP groups, rather than clustering around an average.
  • Spatial Interdependence Matters: The study strongly emphasizes that EWP is not an isolated phenomenon. Factors influencing EWP in one city have demonstrable effects on its neighbors, underscoring the need for coordinated regional policies.

Key Results

  • Temporal Trends: Urban EWP generally showed a decreasing trend from 2000 to 2019, with a significant increase in 2020. Regional trends varied, with eastern and western regions showing a "decrease then increase" pattern, while the central region exhibited fluctuating development followed by gradual improvement.
  • Regional Averages: The western region showed the highest average EWP (1.004), followed by the east (0.959), and then the central region (0.831).
  • Convergence: Urban EWP does not exhibit σ-convergence (meaning the dispersion of EWP levels doesn't consistently decrease). However, it does show spatial absolute β-convergence and spatial conditional β-convergence, indicating that cities are moving towards a common EWP level, especially when spatial factors and control variables are considered.
  • Influential Factors:
    • Negative Direct Effects: Industrial structure, foreign investment, urbanization, government intervention, and environmental regulation generally had negative direct effects on EWP.
  • Positive Direct Effects: Science and technology progress and finance development showed positive direct effects.
  • Spatial Spillover Effects: Industrial structure, urbanization, government intervention, finance development, and environmental regulation had positive spatial spillover effects, meaning they improved EWP in neighboring regions. Science and technology progress and foreign investment had negative spatial spillover effects.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Granularity for "Ecological Capital": The "ecological capital" indicator was measured using only two aspects: ecological service supply and municipal facilities. The market value of ecological resources was not fully captured, suggesting a need for more comprehensive data collection in the future.
  • Limited Regional Division: The study analyzed EWP across national, eastern, central, and western dimensions. A more detailed sub-regional division could provide finer-grained insights and more targeted policy recommendations.

Future work could involve:

  • Improving the EWP index system by incorporating more detailed data on ecological resources and their market values.
  • Selecting smaller research regions based on government development strategies to analyze spatial differences and influencing factors more precisely.
  • Developing differentiated upgrading strategies for regions based on their specific EWP characteristics and spatial relationships.
  • Focusing on inter-regional communication and cooperation in areas like technology, talent, and capital to promote coordinated development and break down local protectionism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ecological welfare performance (EWP) is a necessary condition for achieving sustainable economic development and is a crucial initiative for resolving the dilemma of balancing economic development, social welfare, ecology, and the environment. This paper constructs and enhances a comprehensive evaluation system of ecological welfare performance (EWP) from an ecological value viewpoint for the purpose of making the results of the evaluation both comprehensive and objective. In the meantime, the Dagum Gini decomposition, kernel density, and the spatial Durbin model were initiated to measure and analyze urban EWP, which supplies new empirical results for studies on the dynamic evolution, regional differences and driving factors of urban EWP. The findings indicate the following: (1) In each spatial dimension, the urban EWP roughly demonstrates first a decreased and then an increased trend. There is a discrepancy in the east-central-west distribution of urban EWP in space, in which urban EWP in the east and west is larger than that in the central area. (2) For relative differences, intra-regional and inter-regional differences in urban EWP are significantly spatially uneven. Supervariable density is the main source of regional differences. For absolute differences, the EWP demonstrates a significant polarization effect. (3) The urban EWP does not have σ-convergence; nonetheless, it has spatial absolute <i>β</i>-convergence and spatial conditional <i>β</i>-convergence. (4) The urban EWP has a significant spatial correlation. Industrial structure, science and technology innovation, foreign investment, urbanization, government intervention, finance development, and environmental regulations all have influence effects and spatial effects on urban EWP; notwithstanding, the direction and magnitude of the effects vary across the different spatial dimensions.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022dynamic,
  author = {Jun Wang and Guixiang Zhang},
  title = {{Dynamic Evolution, Regional Differences, and Spatial Spillover Effects of Urban Ecological Welfare Performance in China from the Perspective of Ecological Value}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192316271},
}
Figure