TL;DR
This paper investigates the dynamic evolution and regional convergence of China's fishery ecological efficiency from 2006 to 2021. It reveals a generally improving but still low overall efficiency, significant regional disparities, and a trend of "catching up" where less efficient regions are closing the gap with more efficient ones, leading to a stabilizing pattern.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The global fishery sector is crucial for economic development, food security, and employment. However, it faces increasing pressure from climate change, resource depletion, and pollution, leading to concerns about its sustainability and ecological efficiency. While many studies have examined fishery economic efficiency or carbon emissions separately, there's a need to understand the ecological efficiency of fisheries, which considers both economic output and environmental impact, especially under carbon emission constraints. This paper addresses this by analyzing the dynamic changes and regional differences in China's fishery ecological efficiency, aiming to identify development patterns and potential convergence among provinces.
Methods
The study employs a two-pronged methodological approach:
- Superefficiency Super-SBM Model: To measure fishery ecological efficiency, the researchers utilize a non-radial Super-SBM (Slacks-Based Measure) model. This advanced Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) technique is chosen because it can handle "undesirable outputs" (like carbon emissions and disaster losses) and distinguish between decision-making units (DMUs) that achieve maximum efficiency (efficiency value of 1). This allows for a more nuanced assessment of ecological efficiency by incorporating environmental costs.
- Convergence Analysis: To understand how fishery ecological efficiency evolves across regions over time, two types of convergence are analyzed:
- σ-convergence: This measures the decrease in the dispersion of efficiency values across regions over time. A decreasing coefficient of variation (CV) indicates that the gap between regions is narrowing.
- β-convergence: This examines whether regions with lower initial efficiency tend to grow faster and catch up with regions with higher efficiency. Both absolute (without controlling for other factors) and conditional (controlling for economic factors like openness and development level) β-convergence are assessed.
Datasets
The study uses data from 30 provinces and cities in China for the period 2006–2021. The primary data sources include:
- China Fisheries Statistical Yearbook (2006-2021)
- China Statistical Yearbook (2006-2021)
- China Energy Statistical Yearbook (2006-2021)
Missing data were handled using linear interpolation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Ecological Efficiency is a Multifaceted Metric: The paper highlights the importance of looking beyond pure economic output to include environmental impacts (like carbon emissions and disaster losses) when assessing the sustainability of fisheries.
- "Catching Up" Dynamics: The finding that less efficient regions are indeed improving and closing the gap with more efficient ones is a crucial insight, suggesting that policy interventions or inherent development trends are working.
- Regional Polarization: While overall convergence is observed, the paper points to a "polarization" phenomenon, where some regions are rapidly improving while others lag, creating distinct clusters of efficiency.
- COVID-19 Impact: The study identifies 2019 as a turning point, with significant fluctuations and declines in ecological efficiency between 2019 and 2021, largely attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic's disruption of the fishery sector.
Key Results
- Overall Trend: China's fishery ecological efficiency shows a wavelike upward trend with significant fluctuations, but the overall efficiency level remains relatively low, fluctuating around 0.8.
- Regional Disparities: Significant differences exist, with the eastern (average 0.96) and northeastern (average 0.94) regions exhibiting higher ecological efficiency than the central (0.72) and western (0.61) regions. A "decreasing from east to west" spatial gradient is observed.
- σ-Convergence:
- Nationally, the gap between provinces is large but gradually decreasing.
- The western and northeastern regions show a downward trend in variation, indicating narrowing gaps.
- The eastern and central regions show more dynamic changes and disharmony, with no clear σ-convergence.
- β-Convergence:
- Absolute β-convergence is confirmed at both the national and regional levels, indicating that less efficient regions are catching up.
- Conditional β-convergence is also observed, suggesting that even when controlling for economic factors, regions tend to converge to their steady-state levels.
- The convergence speed is highest in the eastern region (0.081) for absolute convergence and in the central region (0.044) for conditional convergence.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Data Availability: Some indicators may have been excluded due to data unavailability, potentially affecting the accuracy of the empirical results.
- Spatial Analysis Depth: The study notes a "weak analysis of the spatial agglomeration and influencing factors" and suggests further exploration of the driving mechanisms behind coordinated regional development.
- Qualitative and Statistical Methods: Future research could incorporate qualitative approaches or different statistical methods to study the impact of carbon emissions on fishery ecological efficiency globally and to develop corresponding policies.
The paper suggests that future work should focus on understanding the spatial dynamics and driving forces of regional fishery ecological efficiency more deeply.
Summary updated