Dynamic cause of marginal lithospheric thinning and implications for craton destruction: a comparison of the North China, Superior, and Yilgarn cratons

Xu Wang, Peimin Zhu, Timothy Kusky, Na Zhao, Xiaoyong Li, Zhensheng WangCanadian 2015 · DOI

Abstract

This study presents a comparative tectonic analysis of the North China Craton (NCC), which has experienced significant lithospheric thinning, alongside the Yilgarn and Superior cratons, which have largely preserved their deep roots. By synthesizing geophysical, geological, and geochemical data, the research identifies that while marginal lithospheric thinning is a common result of plate convergence, wholesale craton destruction is a rarer phenomenon. It occurs primarily when cratons are subjected to multi-sided subduction and collision. A key finding is the role of subduction polarity: plates dipping beneath a craton release water that "hydroweakens" the mantle, facilitating delamination or erosion of the sub-continental lithospheric mantle (SCLM). Conversely, stable cratons are often shielded by peripheral "weak zones" (mobile belts) that absorb tectonic stress.

Introduction: The Mystery of the Disappearing Roots

Cratons represent the ancient, stable cores of the Earth's continents. They are typically defined by thick, cold, and buoyant "roots" known as Sub-Continental Lithospheric Mantle (SCLM), which can extend hundreds of kilometers into the mantle. While most cratons have remained geologically quiescent for over a billion years, the eastern portion of the North China Craton (NCC) underwent a dramatic transformation during the Mesozoic. It lost its deep root, transitioning from a stable landmass into a tectonically active region characterized by a thinned crust and increased seismicity.

The central question in lithospheric geodynamics is why the NCC suffered this "destruction" while other major Archean cratons, such as the Superior Craton in Canada or the Yilgarn Craton in Australia, maintained their structural integrity. This paper investigates the underlying mechanisms by comparing the tectonic histories and geophysical structures of these three regions.

Methodology and Data Sources

The authors utilize a comparative tectonic analysis, integrating multiple lines of evidence:

  • Geophysical Mapping: S-wave seismic tomography is used to visualize the thickness and thermal state of the lithosphere, identifying variations in seismic velocity that correspond to lithospheric roots.
  • Geochemical Analysis: The study examines mantle xenoliths—fragments of the deep mantle transported to the surface by volcanic activity. These provide direct evidence of the age, composition, and hydration state of the SCLM.
  • Tectonic Reconstruction: A comprehensive review of the billion-year history of plate movements, subduction events, and orogenic cycles surrounding each craton provides the context for their current states.

Data sources include established seismic tomography models (e.g., Jiang et al., 2013; Fishwick and Reading, 2008) and extensive geochemical databases for the NCC, Superior, and Yilgarn regions.

Mechanisms of Lithospheric Evolution

The study identifies several critical factors that determine whether a craton remains stable or undergoes destruction:

1. Subduction Polarity and Hydroweakening

The direction of subduction (polarity) is the most decisive factor. When a tectonic plate subducts directly underneath a craton, it releases aqueous fluids into the overlying SCLM. This process, termed "hydroweakening," significantly reduces the mantle's viscosity and lowers its melting point. This weakened root becomes susceptible to being "delaminated" (peeled away) or eroded by the underlying asthenosphere. In the NCC, subduction occurred from multiple directions (e.g., the Paleo-Pacific and Tethyan plates), effectively "soaking" the root. In contrast, subduction around the Superior and Yilgarn cratons predominantly dipped away from the craton interiors, preserving their dry, rigid state.

2. The Protective Role of "Weak Zones"

Stable cratons are typically surrounded by younger mobile belts or orogens. These "weak zones" act as tectonic buffers, similar to a vehicle's crumple zone. They absorb the mechanical stress of plate collisions, preventing deformation from reaching the craton's interior. The Ordos Block (the Western Block of the NCC) remained stable precisely because it was shielded by such peripheral rifts and weak zones, even as the Eastern Block was destroyed.

3. Thinning vs. Destruction

The authors distinguish between marginal thinning and wholesale destruction. Marginal thinning is a common feature at the edges of all cratons due to localized tectonic interactions. However, destruction—the loss of the interior root—requires the combination of hydroweakening and multi-sided tectonic assault.

Comparative Results

  • North China Craton (NCC): Geophysical data confirms that the eastern NCC lithosphere thinned from an estimated 180–200 km in the Paleozoic to a mere 80–100 km today. The loss of the root coincided with intense volcanic activity and crustal deformation.
  • Superior and Yilgarn Cratons: These cratons maintain deep roots exceeding 200 km (reaching up to 300 km in parts of the Superior). While their margins show evidence of thinning where they meet younger orogenic belts, their interiors remain thick and buoyant.
  • The Ordos Exception: Within the NCC, the Ordos Block serves as a control case. Its preservation highlights that without the specific combination of hydroweakening and direct tectonic stress, even a craton within a broader "destruction zone" can remain stable if shielded by weak peripheral zones.

Discussion and Future Outlook

While the role of subduction polarity and hydroweakening provides a compelling framework for understanding craton destruction, some questions remain. The study relies on the resolution of current seismic tomography, which can be limited at extreme depths. Furthermore, the precise volume of fluid flux required to trigger delamination is difficult to quantify through observation alone.

Future research should focus on high-resolution numerical geodynamic modeling. Such models could simulate the interaction between "wet" mantle compositions and the complex, multi-sided tectonic pressures observed in the North China Craton, providing a more granular understanding of the tipping points for cratonic stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a comparative tectonic analysis of the North China Craton (NCC), which has lost parts of its root, with the Yilgarn and Superior cratons, which preserve their roots. We compare the geophysical structure and tectonic histories of these cratons to search for reasons why some cratons lose their roots, while others retain them. Based on the comparison and analysis of geological, geophysical, and geochemical data, it is clear that the lithospheric thinning beneath craton margins is a common phenomenon, which may be caused by convergence between plates. However, craton destruction is not always accompanied by lithospheric thinning, except for cratons that suffered subduction and collision from multiple sides. The Western Block (also known as the Ordos Block) of the NCC, Yilgarn and Superior cratons have not experienced craton destruction; the common ground among them is that they are surrounded by weak zones (e.g., mobile belts or orogens) that sheltered the cratons from deformation, which contributes greatly to the long-term stability of the craton. Subduction polarity controlled the water released by the subducting plate, and if subducting plates dip underneath the craton, they release water that hydroweakens the overlying mantle, and makes it easy for delamination or sub-continental lithospheric mantle erosion to take place in the interior of the craton. Thus, subduction polarity during convergence events is an important element in determing whether a craton retains or loses its root.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2015dynamic,
  author = {Xu Wang and Peimin Zhu and Timothy Kusky and Na Zhao and Xiaoyong Li and Zhensheng Wang},
  title = {{Dynamic cause of marginal lithospheric thinning and implications for craton destruction: a comparison of the North China, Superior, and Yilgarn cratons}},
  booktitle = {Canadian},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1139/cjes-2015-0110},
}
Figure