Dynamic and thermodynamic stability of relativistic, perfect fluid stars

Stephen Green, Joshua Schiffrin, Robert M. WaldClassical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This study investigates the stability of perfect fluid stars within the framework of general relativity. By characterizing stars through particle number density and entropy per particle, we establish that thermodynamic equilibrium in a stationary, axisymmetric solution requires the constancy of angular velocity, redshifted temperature, and redshifted chemical potential. We utilize a Lagrangian framework to define canonical energy as a criterion for stability. Our findings demonstrate that for axisymmetric perturbations, positivity of canonical energy on a specific subspace of perturbations is a necessary and sufficient condition for mode stability. Furthermore, we establish a formal link between the stability of fluid stars and the thermodynamic laws of black holes, showing that the canonical energy relates directly to second-order changes in mass and angular momentum.

Introduction

In relativistic astrophysics, determining the stability of a rotating star is a complex challenge. A star may be in a state of dynamic equilibrium—a stationary solution to the Einstein-fluid equations—yet remain susceptible to various forms of instability. These instabilities are generally categorized into two types: dynamic instabilities, which lead to rapid collapse or explosion, and thermodynamic (or secular) instabilities, which drive the system toward a different state over longer timescales through dissipative processes like viscosity or heat conduction.

While previous research, notably by Friedman, identified that all rotating stars are technically unstable to non-axisymmetric perturbations (the Chandrasekhar-Friedman-Schutz or CFS instability), the specific conditions governing axisymmetric stability remained less rigorously defined. This paper provides a unified framework to address these gaps, drawing significant parallels between the stability of fluid stars and the stability of black holes.

Thermodynamic Equilibrium Conditions

A central result of this work is the rigorous definition of thermodynamic equilibrium for a relativistic star. For a star in dynamic equilibrium, the authors prove that the necessary and sufficient conditions for it to also be in thermodynamic equilibrium (representing an extremum of total entropy $S$) are the global uniformity of three key quantities:

  1. Angular Velocity ($\Omega$): The star must rotate rigidly.
  2. Redshifted Temperature ($\tilde{T}$): The temperature adjusted for the gravitational redshift.
  3. Redshifted Chemical Potential ($\tilde{\mu}$): The chemical potential adjusted for the gravitational redshift.

If any of these quantities vary across the fluid, the star cannot be in a state of maximum entropy, implying that dissipative forces will eventually drive the system toward a state where these values are uniform.

The Lagrangian Framework and Canonical Energy

To analyze stability, the authors employ a Lagrangian displacement framework. By mapping the fluid to a "fiducial" reference manifold, they can track the evolution of individual fluid elements via a displacement vector field $\xi^a$. This approach allows for the definition of a canonical energy ($E$), a quadratic form on the space of perturbations.

The stability of the star is then linked to the positivity of this canonical energy. Specifically:

  • Dynamic Stability: A star exhibits mode stability against axisymmetric perturbations if $E$ is positive on a restricted subspace $V$ of perturbations. These perturbations are characterized by having no Lagrangian change in angular momentum density.
  • Thermodynamic Stability: For a star in thermodynamic equilibrium, the canonical energy in the rotating frame ($E_r$) is related to the second-order variations of the ADM mass ($M$) and angular momentum ($J$) by the relation: $E_r = \delta^2 M - \Omega \delta^2 J$. Positivity of $E_r$ for perturbations where $\delta J = 0$ is a necessary condition for the star to be a local maximum of entropy.

Parallels to Black Hole Physics

One of the most theoretically significant aspects of this research is the alignment with the Hollands-Wald framework for black hole stability. The derivation of a "First Law" for relativistic stars—$\delta M = \tilde{T} \delta S + \tilde{\mu} \delta N + \Omega \delta J$—mirrors the First Law of Black Hole Mechanics. This suggests that the underlying principles of stability in general relativity are universal, applying equally to fluid bodies and the horizons of black holes.

Conclusion and Limitations

This paper provides a rigorous mathematical foundation for the stability of relativistic stars. By focusing on axisymmetric perturbations—the primary regime where a rotating star can be considered stable—the authors establish canonical energy as the definitive metric for both dynamic and thermodynamic integrity.

However, the study is restricted to linear stability (small perturbations). While linear instability usually implies non-linear instability, the reverse is not always guaranteed. Furthermore, while the thermodynamic approach identifies if a star is unstable, it does not predict the growth rate of such instabilities, which depends on the specific microphysics of dissipation. Future work extending these findings to specific dissipative models (such as neutrino transport) would provide a more granular understanding of stellar evolution.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider perfect fluid bodies (stars) in general relativity, characterized by particle number density and entropy per particle. A star is said to be in dynamic equilibrium if it is a stationary, axisymmetric solution to the Einstein-fluid equations with circular flow. We prove that for a star in dynamic equilibrium, the necessary and sufficient condition for thermodynamic equilibrium (extremum of total entropy S) is constancy of angular velocity (\Omega), redshifted temperature, and redshifted chemical potential. Friedman previously identified positivity of canonical energy, E, as a criterion for dynamic stability and argued that all rotating stars are dynamically unstable to sufficiently nonaxisymmetric perturbations (the CFS instability), so our main focus is on axisymmetric stability. We show that for a star in dynamic equilibrium, mode stability holds with respect to all axisymmetric perturbations if E is positive on a certain subspace, V, of axisymmetric Lagrangian perturbations that, in particular, have no Lagrangian change in angular momentum density. Conversely, if E fails to be positive on V, then there exist perturbations that can't become asymptotically stationary at late times. We further show that for a star in thermodynamic equilibrium, the canonical energy in the rotating frame, E_r, is related to second order changes in ADM mass, M, and angular momentum, J, by E_r = \delta^2 M - \Omega \delta^2 J. Thus, positivity of E_r for perturbations with \delta J = 0 is a necessary condition for thermodynamic stability (local maximum of S). For axisymmetric perturbations we have E = E_r, so a necessary condition for thermodynamic stability with respect to axisymmetric perturbations is positivity of E on all perturbations with \delta J = 0, not merely on the perturbations in V. Many of our results are in close parallel to results of Hollands and Wald for the theory of black holes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{green2014dynamic,
  author = {Stephen Green and Joshua Schiffrin and Robert M. Wald},
  title = {{Dynamic and thermodynamic stability of relativistic, perfect fluid stars}},
  booktitle = {Classical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1088/0264-9381/31/3/035023},
}
Figure