Dynactin Is Required for Coordinated Bidirectional Motility, but Not for Dynein Membrane Attachment

Marjan Haghnia, Valeria Cavalli, Sameer B. Shah, Kristina Schimmelpfeng, Richard G. Brusch, Ge Yang, Cheryl Herrera, Aaron D. Pilling, Lawrence S.b. GoldsteinMolecular 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This study challenges the long-held belief that dynactin is essential for attaching the motor protein dynein to cellular membranes. Using Drosophila, researchers found that dynein still binds to membranes even when dynactin is absent, but bidirectional organelle transport is severely disrupted, suggesting dynactin's primary role is in coordinating motor activity rather than attachment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intracellular transport relies heavily on molecular motors like dynein, which move cargo along microtubules towards the cell's minus end. Dynactin, a large protein complex, has been widely assumed to be the crucial intermediary that tethers dynein to the membrane-bound cargo it transports. This assumption is supported by various in vitro studies and the observation that dynactin mutations can lead to neurodegenerative diseases. However, definitive in vivo evidence for dynactin's role in dynein-membrane attachment has been lacking. This paper aims to rigorously test this hypothesis by investigating the consequences of disrupting dynactin function in a living organism.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach using Drosophila melanogaster:

  • Genetic Mutants and RNA Interference (RNAi): They generated Drosophila mutants and used RNAi to specifically reduce the levels of Arp1, a key subunit of the dynactin complex. This allowed them to study the effects of dynactin deficiency in both whole organisms and cultured cells.
  • Immunostaining and Western Blotting: Antibodies were used to detect and quantify the levels of various motor proteins (dynein, kinesin) and dynactin subunits (p150Glued, p50/dynamitin) in both wild-type and mutant/RNAi samples. This helped assess the overall integrity of the motor complexes.
  • Sucrose Density Gradient Sedimentation: This technique was used to analyze the assembly state of dynactin complexes. By separating cellular components based on size and density, they could determine if dynactin subunits remained associated in the absence of Arp1.
  • Membrane Flotation Assays: These experiments were designed to specifically assess how much dynein was associated with cellular membranes. By separating soluble and membrane-bound fractions, they could determine if dynactin disruption affected dynein's membrane binding.
  • Live Imaging of Organelle Transport: Using fluorescently tagged cargo (APP-YFP for vesicles, GFP-tagged cytochrome oxidase for mitochondria) and advanced microscopy, they directly observed and quantified the movement of organelles within neuronal axons. This allowed for detailed analysis of velocity, pause frequency, and reversal frequency.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from Drosophila models and cell cultures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynactin is not essential for dynein-membrane attachment: This is the central and most surprising finding, directly contradicting a widely accepted model.
  • Dynactin is crucial for coordinated bidirectional motility: While attachment is unaffected, the movement of cargo is severely impaired, suggesting dynactin's role is in regulating the process of transport.
  • Dynactin impacts both anterograde and retrograde transport: The disruption affects movement in both directions, hinting at a broader regulatory role beyond just dynein-mediated retrograde transport.
  • Dynactin may coordinate opposing motors: The data suggests dynactin might be involved in ensuring smooth cooperation between anterograde (kinesin) and retrograde (dynein) motors.
  • Dynactin disruption leads to cargo accumulation: Similar to other axonal transport mutants, loss of dynactin causes vesicles and organelles to build up in axons, indicating a breakdown in transport.

Key Results

  • Normal dynein levels on membranes: In arp1 mutant larvae and arp1 dsRNA-treated S2 cells, dynein heavy chain (DHC) levels associated with membrane fractions remained comparable to controls.
  • Dynactin complex disassembly: Loss of Arp1 led to a significant reduction in other dynactin subunits (p150Glued, p50/dynamitin) and a shift in their sedimentation profile, indicating a disrupted complex.
  • Severely impaired organelle motility: In arp1 mutant axons, APP-containing vesicles and mitochondria exhibited significantly reduced net velocities, segment velocities, and increased pause frequencies.
  • Reduced anterograde and retrograde runs: Dynactin-deficient axons showed a dramatic decrease in the length of both anterograde and retrograde transport runs.
  • Potential role in kinesin regulation: The study hints at a possible role for dynactin in regulating anterograde transport, as KHC levels on membranes were slightly reduced in arp1 mutants.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subtle KHC reduction: While a slight reduction in KHC on membranes was observed, its functional significance requires further investigation.
  • Mechanism of coordination: The exact molecular mechanisms by which dynactin coordinates opposing motors remain to be elucidated.
  • Dynein-membrane interaction details: While attachment is not dependent on dynactin, the precise nature of dynein's interaction with membranes in the absence of dynactin needs further exploration.
  • Investigating anterograde roles: The authors suggest further research into dynactin's potential direct role in kinesin recruitment and regulation.
  • Understanding disease links: The findings have implications for understanding neurodegenerative diseases linked to dynactin mutations, suggesting that the motility defects, rather than just attachment issues, might be key.

Summary updated

Abstract

Transport of cellular and neuronal vesicles, organelles, and other particles along microtubules requires the molecular motor protein dynein (Mallik and Gross, 2004). Critical to dynein function is dynactin, a multiprotein complex commonly thought to be required for dynein attachment to membrane compartments (Karki and Holzbaur, 1999). Recent work also has found that mutations in dynactin can cause the human motor neuron disease amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (Puls et al., 2003). Thus, it is essential to understand the in vivo function of dynactin. To test directly and rigorously the hypothesis that dynactin is required to attach dynein to membranes, we used both a Drosophila mutant and RNA interference to generate organisms and cells lacking the critical dynactin subunit, actin-related protein 1. Contrary to expectation, we found that apparently normal amounts of dynein associate with membrane compartments in the absence of a fully assembled dynactin complex. In addition, anterograde and retrograde organelle movement in dynactin deficient axons was completely disrupted, resulting in substantial changes in vesicle kinematic properties. Although effects on retrograde transport are predicted by the proposed function of dynactin as a regulator of dynein processivity, the additional effects we observed on anterograde transport also suggest potential roles for dynactin in mediating kinesin-driven transport and in coordinating the activity of opposing motors (King and Schroer, 2000).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{haghnia2007dynactin,
  author = {Marjan Haghnia and Valeria Cavalli and Sameer B. Shah and Kristina Schimmelpfeng and Richard G. Brusch and Ge Yang and Cheryl Herrera and Aaron D. Pilling and Lawrence S.B. Goldstein},
  title = {{Dynactin Is Required for Coordinated Bidirectional Motility, but Not for Dynein Membrane Attachment}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1091/mbc.e06-08-0695},
}
Figure