Abstract
Unintentional movement synchronization is often emerging between interacting humans. In the present study, we investigate the extent to which the incongruence of movement trajectories has an influence on unintentional dyadic movement synchronization. During a target-directed tapping task, a participant repetitively moved between two targets in front of another participant who performed the same task in parallel but independently. When the movement path of one participant was changed by placing an obstacle between the targets, the degree of their unintentional movement synchronization was measured. Movement synchronization was observed despite of their substantially different movement trajectories. A deeper investigation of the participant's unintentional behavior shows, that although the actor who cleared the obstacle puts unintentional effort in establishing synchrony by increasing movement velocity—the other actor also unintentionally adjusted his/her behavior by increasing dwell times. Results are discussed in the light of joint action, movement interference and obstacle avoidance behavior.
Introduction
Interpersonal synchronization—such as walking in step or rocking chairs in unison—is a well-documented phenomenon in social psychology and neuroscience. Most research, however, focuses on "congruent" tasks where both individuals perform identical movements. This study explores whether unintentional synchronization still emerges when trajectories are incongruent. Specifically, if one person has a longer, more complex path due to an obstacle while the other has a straight path, will they still fall into rhythm? If so, who adjusts to whom, and what are the underlying motor strategies?
Methods
The researchers recruited 10 dyads (20 participants) for a repetitive tapping task. Participants sat opposite each other at a round table and moved a stylus between two targets.
Experimental Setup
In 50% of the trials, a vertical obstacle was placed in front of one participant (HAMP - hampered), forcing them to lift the stylus higher and travel a longer path. The other participant (FREE) always had a clear path.
The study compared "congruent" (neither has an obstacle) vs. "incongruent" (one has an obstacle) setups. To ensure synchronization wasn't just a byproduct of starting at the same time, three different start triggers were used: simultaneous, quarter-cycle delay, and half-cycle delay.
Data Collection
3D movement was captured at 200 Hz using an infrared tracking system. Key metrics included Path Length (PL), Movement Time (MT), Dwell Time (DT) at targets, Median Velocity (MV), and Relative Phase to measure the degree of synchronization. The dataset comprised 720 total cycles of movement data per dyad.
Key Insights and Results
The study revealed that unintentional synchronization is remarkably robust, emerging even when trajectories were substantially different. The "social" drive to synchronize appears to be a powerful default in human interaction.
The Velocity Paradox and Mutual Adaptation
Typically, avoiding an obstacle slows down movement velocity to ensure accuracy. However, in this dyadic setting, the HAMP actor significantly increased their median velocity ($p < 0.001$) during incongruent trials to cover the extra distance in the same amount of time. They prioritized maintaining the shared rhythm over individual efficiency.
Adaptation was mutual rather than one-sided. The FREE actor unintentionally increased their dwell time—the time spent touching the target ($p = 0.011$ for the forward target). Essentially, they "waited" for their partner at the targets to keep the phase relation stable. The pair settled into a dynamic of a "compensator" (HAMP) and an "accommodator" (FREE).
Synchronization Metrics
Both congruent and incongruent conditions showed clear peaks at 0° (in-phase) and 180° (anti-phase) in relative phase analysis. While synchronization was present in both, the coupling strength (cross-spectral coherence) was slightly lower in the incongruent condition (0.51) compared to the congruent one (0.73), though this difference was not statistically significant.
Discussion and Limitations
The study also noted evidence of "motor contagion": the FREE actor's path length increased slightly when their partner had an obstacle, suggesting that observing a curved trajectory can influence one's own motor execution.
Limitations include the fixed perspective (sitting opposite), which may make trajectory estimation harder than a side-by-side view. Additionally, the task was a simple cyclic action; future research should investigate how these findings scale to more complex, non-cyclic joint actions, such as moving furniture together.
Summary updated