Dual-wavelength Fourier Ptychographic Topography

Yi Shen, Tongyu Li, Hao Wang, Jinyong Kim, Hojun Lee, Wookrae Kim, Jonghyeok Park, Junho Shin, Seungbeam Park, Lei TianBoston University - MyCV 2026 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a dual-wavelength Fourier Ptychographic Topography (FPT) method that significantly extends the measurable height range of FPT without sacrificing lateral resolution. By combining phase information from two different wavelengths and employing a novel unwrapping algorithm, the technique overcomes the limitations of single-wavelength FPT, enabling more accurate and comprehensive surface metrology for demanding industrial applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Surface topography measurement is crucial for fields like semiconductor manufacturing and materials science. Conventional techniques like Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) are slow, while optical methods like interferometry can be limited by environmental disturbances and, importantly, by phase wrapping. Fourier Ptychography (FP), and its extension to topography (FPT), offers a promising computational approach for wide-field-of-view, high-resolution imaging. However, single-wavelength FPT is fundamentally limited by phase wrapping, restricting the unambiguous height measurement to half the illumination wavelength (λ/2). This severely limits its applicability for measuring taller structures. While dual-wavelength approaches exist, they often suffer from amplified noise and can still be challenged by complex geometries. This paper tackles the problem of extending the height measurement range of FPT while maintaining high resolution and robustness, particularly for challenging, high-aspect-ratio structures.

Methods

The core innovation lies in a dual-wavelength FPT framework that addresses both phase wrapping and chromatic aberrations.

  • Dual-Wavelength Illumination: The system uses two distinct illumination wavelengths (red and green LEDs) to capture intensity images.
  • Single-Wavelength FPT Reconstruction: For each wavelength, a modified single-wavelength FPT algorithm is used. This includes:
  • Wrapped-Phase TV Regularization: To suppress phase retrieval artifacts and improve stability.
  • Digital Refocusing: An angular spectrum method is employed to correct for axial focal-plane mismatch caused by chromatic aberrations between the two wavelengths, ensuring accurate cross-wavelength alignment without mechanical adjustments.
  • Dual-Wavelength Phase Unwrapping Algorithm: This is a two-stage process:
  • Pixel-wise Wrapped-Number Search: This novel step enforces cross-wavelength height consistency. Instead of directly differencing phases (which amplifies noise), it searches for integer pairs that minimize the discrepancy between candidate heights derived from each wavelength. This is crucial for mitigating noise amplification.
  • Global Refinement: A TV-regularized optimization with soft bounds is applied to further improve noise robustness, enforce piecewise-smoothness, and preserve true height discontinuities.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention datasets used for training. However, the method is validated using:

  • Rigorous Numerical Simulations: Based on a Modified Born Series (MBS) forward model.
  • Experimental Measurements: Performed on structured silicon samples with varying topography, including trenches with different widths and depths.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Exploiting Phase Difference: The fundamental idea is that the phase difference between two wavelengths creates a synthetic wavelength, significantly extending the unambiguous height range.
  • Noise Robustness is Key: Direct phase differencing in dual-wavelength approaches amplifies noise. The paper's core contribution is a noise-robust unwrapping strategy that avoids this amplification.
  • Chromatic Aberration is a Practical Hurdle: The paper highlights and solves the problem of axial misalignment due to chromatic differences between wavelengths using digital refocusing.
  • Aspect Ratio (AR) is a Critical Limiting Factor: Beyond a certain AR (around 0.5-0.75 in their system), the underlying surface-based forward model of FPT breaks down due to geometric occlusion and 3D scattering, limiting reconstruction fidelity regardless of the unwrapping method.
  • Ph-MTF as a Diagnostic Tool: The Phase Modulation Transfer Function (ph-MTF) is introduced as a valuable metric to understand how lateral frequencies are transferred in the reconstructed phase, revealing that limitations are often due to physical constraints rather than just phase wrapping.

Key Results

  • Extended Height Range: The dual-wavelength FPT method successfully recovers heights beyond the λ/2 limit of single-wavelength FPT, demonstrating accurate height recovery for features up to ~1 µm.
  • Maintained Lateral Resolution: The method preserves the lateral resolution dictated by the synthetic numerical aperture (NA) of the system.
  • Robustness to Noise: The proposed unwrapping algorithm shows significantly lower noise sensitivity compared to baseline methods.
  • Accurate Reconstruction of High-AR Structures: The method provides reliable topography for quasi-2D structures with aspect ratios up to approximately AR ≈ 0.75.
  • Computational Efficiency: The proposed method is computationally efficient, achieving performance comparable to state-of-the-art methods like PUMA but at a fraction of the computational cost.
  • Validation: The approach is validated through both simulations and experiments on structured silicon samples, showing excellent agreement with reference measurements (Zygo interferometer) for features within the reliable AR range.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Aspect Ratio Limit: The primary limitation is the inherent assumption of a surface-like (quasi-2D) forward model. For structures with very high aspect ratios (AR > ~0.75 in their system), geometric occlusion, 3D scattering, and model inaccuracies lead to phase-transfer breakdown, limiting reconstruction fidelity. This limit is dictated by the physics of light interaction with the structure, not solely by the unwrapping algorithm.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest integrating dual-/multi-wavelength strategies into full 3D reflection-mode diffraction tomography to address higher AR and more complex microstructures, which would require more sophisticated models to handle volumetric scattering. They also propose that the AR-based analysis can serve as practical guidelines for choosing between FPT and 3D models in future metrology systems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{shen2026dual,
  author = {Yi Shen and Tongyu Li and Hao Wang and Jinyong Kim and Hojun Lee and Wookrae Kim and Jonghyeok Park and Junho Shin and Seungbeam Park and Lei Tian},
  title = {{Dual-wavelength Fourier Ptychographic Topography}},
  booktitle = {Boston University - MyCV},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=dD6Fs1tYNC},
}
Figure