Dual signaling via interferon and DNA damage response elicits entrapment by giant PML nuclear bodies

Myriam Scherer, Clarissa Read, Gregor Neusser, Christine Kranz, Regina Müller, Florian Full, Sonja Wörz, Anna Reichel, Eva-Maria Schilling, Paul Walther, Thomas StammingerbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract: PML nuclear bodies (PML-NBs) are dynamic interchromosomal macromolecular complexes implicated in epigenetic regulation as well as antiviral defense. During herpesvirus infection, PML-NBs induce epigenetic silencing of viral genomes, however, this defense is antagonized by viral regulatory proteins such as IE1 of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV). Here, we show that PML-NBs undergo a drastic rearrangement into highly enlarged PML cages upon infection with IE1-deficient HCMV. Importantly, our results demonstrate that dual signaling by interferon and DNA damage response is required to elicit giant PML-NBs. DNA labeling revealed that invading HCMV genomes are entrapped inside PML-NBs and remain stably associated with PML cages in a transcriptionally repressed state. Intriguingly, by correlative light and transmission electron microscopy (EM), we observed that PML cages also entrap newly assembled viral capsids demonstrating a second defense layer in cells with incomplete first line response. Further characterization by 3D EM showed that hundreds of viral capsids are tightly packed into several layers of fibrous PML. Overall, our data indicate that giant PML-NBs arise via combined interferon and DNA damage signaling which triggers entrapment of both nucleic acids and proteinaceous components. This represents a multilayered defense strategy to act in a cytoprotective manner and to combat viral infections.

Introduction: The Molecular Cage-Match

Cells possess an "intrinsic" immune system—a front-line defense that is always active and ready to block viral replication. A central player in this defense is the PML nuclear body (PML-NB), a protein complex that typically silences viral genomes through epigenetic modification. However, Human Cytomegalovirus (HCMV) has evolved a powerful counter-measure: the viral protein IE1. Within hours of infection, IE1 effectively shatters PML-NBs, neutralizing the cell's primary defense.

Because IE1 is so efficient, observing a successful PML-NB defense in action has been challenging. Scherer et al. addressed this by utilizing an IE1-deficient version of HCMV, allowing the cell's defenses to proceed unhindered. Their findings reveal a sophisticated, two-layered defense mechanism where PML-NBs transform into giant protein "cages" to physically sequester the invader.

Visualizing the Defense Architecture

In the absence of IE1, PML-NBs do not disperse. Instead, they undergo a dramatic morphological shift, expanding into highly enlarged structures that the researchers termed "PML cages." Advanced imaging techniques, including Correlative Light and Electron Microscopy (CLEM) and 3D Focused Ion Beam-Scanning Electron Microscopy (FIB-SEM), allowed the team to visualize these structures at nanometer resolution.

Comparison of PML-NB morphology during infection with wild-type (HCMV) and IE1-deficient viruses. Note the formation of giant PML cages and the 3D orthogonal views (xy, yz, xz) demonstrating physical entrapment.

As shown in the figure above, while wild-type HCMV causes PML to disperse throughout the nucleus, the IE1-deficient mutants (HCMVΔIE1 and IE1-L174P) trigger the formation of massive, hollow PML structures. These cages are not static; they evolve over the course of the infection.

Temporal Progression and the Dual-Signal Trigger

The formation of these giant cages is a time-dependent process. By tracking the infection from 8 to 72 hours post-infection (hpi), the researchers observed the gradual enlargement of PML structures as they began to associate with viral replication markers like UL44.

Temporal progression of PML-NB rearrangement into enlarged structures over 72 hours of infection with IE1-deficient HCMV.

A key discovery was the requirement for a dual-signal trigger. Neither interferon (the cell's primary alarm signal) nor the DNA damage response (DDR) could induce cage formation independently. Instead, the incoming viral DNA likely triggers a DDR signal which, when combined with interferon-boosted protein levels, drives the assembly of these massive structures.

A Multi-Layered Defense Strategy

The study identifies two distinct layers of defense provided by these PML cages:

  1. Layer 1: Genome Sequestration. Using Click Chemistry DNA labeling, the team found that approximately 70% of invading viral genomes were successfully trapped within PML structures. This physical entrapment keeps the viral DNA condensed and transcriptionally silent.
  2. Layer 2: Capsid Entrapment. If the virus manages to replicate, the cages act as a backup. 3D reconstruction revealed that a single PML cage can sequester hundreds of newly formed viral capsids—one example showed 366 capsids packed at a density of roughly 1180 capsids/µm³—preventing them from exiting the nucleus to infect other cells.

Significance and Future Directions

This research highlights a powerful intrinsic immune strategy where the cell uses physical sequestration to combat persistent DNA viruses. The defense is robust but saturable; at high doses of virus, the cell's caging capacity is overwhelmed, explaining why high-titer infections can bypass intrinsic immunity.

Future work will focus on identifying the specific molecular sensor that detects viral DNA to trigger the DDR component of the signal. Additionally, researchers aim to determine if this "caging" mechanism is a universal defense against other DNA viruses, which could open new avenues for broad-spectrum antiviral therapies.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT PML nuclear bodies (PML-NBs) are dynamic interchromosomal macromolecular complexes implicated in epigenetic regulation as well as antiviral defense. During herpesvirus infection, PML-NBs induce epigenetic silencing of viral genomes, however, this defense is antagonized by viral regulatory proteins such as IE1 of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV). Here, we show that PML-NBs undergo a drastic rearrangement into highly enlarged PML cages upon infection with IE1-deficient HCMV. Importantly, our results demonstrate that dual signaling by interferon and DNA damage response is required to elicit giant PML-NBs. DNA labeling revealed that invading HCMV genomes are entrapped inside PML-NBs and remain stably associated with PML cages in a transcriptionally repressed state. Intriguingly, by correlative light and transmission electron microscopy (EM), we observed that PML cages also entrap newly assembled viral capsids demonstrating a second defense layer in cells with incomplete first line response. Further characterization by 3D EM showed that hundreds of viral capsids are tightly packed into several layers of fibrous PML. Overall, our data indicate that giant PML-NBs arise via combined interferon and DNA damage signaling which triggers entrapment of both nucleic acids and proteinaceous components. This represents a multilayered defense strategy to act in a cytoprotective manner and to combat viral infections.
BibTeX
@misc{scherer2021dual,
  author = {Myriam Scherer and Clarissa Read and Gregor Neusser and Christine Kranz and Regina Müller and Florian Full and Sonja Wörz and Anna Reichel and Eva-Maria Schilling and Paul Walther and Thomas Stamminger},
  title = {{Dual signaling via interferon and DNA damage response elicits entrapment by giant PML nuclear bodies}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.08.24.457524},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure