Dual-mode Switching Fault Ride-through Control Strategy for Self-synchronous Wind Turbines

Xinshou Tian, Yongning Chi, Cheng Peng, Wei He, Yunpeng Zhou, Jianzhu HuJournal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

As power grids move toward 100% renewables, self-synchronous wind turbines (SSWTs) are essential for providing grid inertia, yet they are notoriously fragile during sudden voltage drops. This paper proposes a dual-mode switching strategy that protects these turbines by temporarily "borrowing" robust vector control techniques during deep faults and using direct potential calculations for minor ones. The result is a turbine that survives grid disturbances without the massive current spikes or oscillations that typically plague self-synchronous systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional power grids rely on massive, spinning synchronous generators to maintain stability. As we replace these with wind and solar, we lose that natural "inertia." Self-synchronous control (SSC) allows wind turbines to mimic these traditional generators, making the grid more resilient.

However, there is a catch: SSC has a "slow" internal dynamic. When a grid fault occurs (like a short circuit), the grid voltage changes almost instantly, but the turbine’s internal virtual rotor cannot keep up. This mismatch creates a massive surge in current (overcurrent) and voltage (overvoltage) that can damage power electronics or trip the turbine offline. Furthermore, the transition back to normal operation often triggers "multifrequency oscillations"—unstable wobbles in power that can crash the local grid.

Methods

The authors developed a hybrid control architecture that changes its behavior based on the severity of the grid fault:

  1. Minor Fault Mode: If the voltage drop is small, the controller doesn't switch modes. Instead, it directly calculates the necessary amplitude and phase of the internal potential to match the new grid state, bypassing the slow "virtual rotor" math.
  2. Deep Fault Mode (Three-Stage Strategy):
    • Stage 1 (During Fault): The turbine switches to Vector Control. This is the industry standard for current limiting. It ignores the "self-synchronous" behavior to prioritize keeping currents within safe limits.
  3. Stage 2 (Recovery): Once the fault is cleared, the turbine stays in Vector Control to smoothly ramp active power back up, avoiding the "voltage jump" that causes spikes.
  4. Stage 3 (Post-Fault): Once active power reaches a safe threshold (defined by a hysteresis loop to prevent "chattering"), the controller switches back to Self-Synchronous Control to provide long-term grid stability.

Datasets

The study does not use a traditional "dataset" but rather a rigorous simulation environment:

  • Platform: MATLAB/Simulink.
  • Model: A multi-machine power system consisting of four synchronous generators and a wind farm (using Doubly-Fed Induction Generators, or DFIGs).
  • Parameters: Detailed electrical parameters for the generators, turbines, and transmission lines are provided in Tables I, II, and III, serving as a benchmark for others in the field to replicate the study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Physical Mechanism of Failure: The authors pinpoint the "aha moment"—the overcurrent isn't just a random spike; it's a direct result of the slow dynamic response of the virtual rotor motion equation. The turbine is essentially trying to act like a heavy flywheel that can't stop or change direction fast enough when the grid "hits a wall."
  • Damping the Wobble: Vector control is great at limiting current but bad at high frequencies (due to Phase-Locked Loop delays). SSC is the opposite. By switching from Vector Control back to SSC at the right moment, the system naturally damps out high-frequency oscillations that would otherwise persist.
  • Active Power as a Trigger: Using the recovery of active power as the signal to switch back to SSC is a robust way to ensure the system is truly stable before returning to its "inertia-providing" state.

Key Results

  • Oscillation Suppression: In simulations, the proposed strategy successfully suppressed a ~5 Hz oscillation that occurred during the recovery phase of standard controllers.
  • Current Protection: The dual-mode strategy kept the short-circuit current ($I'$) strictly below the maximum allowed current ($I_{max}$), preventing converter damage.
  • Stability Across Scenarios: The strategy was tested in both "Low Transmitted Power" (247 MW) and "High Transmitted Power" (620 MW) cases. In both, the system stabilized significantly faster than with single-mode controls.
  • Reduced "Slip": The variation in speed (slip) between the different generators on the grid was minimized, indicating better overall grid synchronization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Implementation: Switching between two entirely different control philosophies (Vector vs. SSC) in milliseconds requires highly reliable fault detection and seamless integration to avoid "switching transients."
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The "active power margin" ($k$) used to trigger the switch-back needs to be tuned. If $k$ is too small, the system might switch back too early and become unstable.
  • Real-world Validation: While the simulations are detailed, the authors note that experimental hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) testing or field trials would be the next step to prove the strategy's viability in unpredictable real-world grid conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The installed capacity of renewable energy generation has continued to grow rapidly in recent years along with the global energy transition towards a 100% renewable-based power system. At the same time, the grid-connected large-scale renewable energy brings significant challenges to the safe and stable operation of the power system due to the loss of synchronous machines. Therefore, self-synchronous wind turbines have attracted wide attention from both academia and industry. However, the understanding of the physical operation mechanisms of self-synchronous wind turbines is not clear. In particular, the transient characteristics and dynamic processes of wind turbines are fuzzy in the presence of grid disturbances. Furthermore, it is difficult to design an adaptive fault ride-through (FRT) control strategy. Thus, a dual-mode switching FRT control strategy for self-synchronous wind turbines is developed. Two FRT control strategies are used. In one strategy, the amplitude and phase of the internal potential are directly calculated according to the voltage drop when a minor grid fault occurs. The other dual-mode switching control strategy in the presence of a deep grid fault includes three parts: vector control during the grid fault, fault recovery vector control, and self-synchronous control. The proposed control strategy can significantly mitigate transient overvoltage, overcurrent, and multifrequency oscillation, thereby resulting in enhanced transient stability. Finally, simulation results are provided to validate the proposed control strategy.
BibTeX
@article{tian2023dual,
  author = {Xinshou Tian and Yongning Chi and Cheng Peng and Wei He and Yunpeng Zhou and Jianzhu Hu},
  title = {{Dual-mode Switching Fault Ride-through Control Strategy for Self-synchronous Wind Turbines}},
  journal = {Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.35833/mpce.2021.000434},
}
Figure