Dual-Level Resource-Constrained Multi-Project Scheduling Framework for Prefabrication in Construction

Jing LiuUniversity 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel dual-level scheduling framework for prefabrication projects in construction. It tackles the challenge of frequent resource transfers and disconnected planning by integrating resource allocation and activity scheduling, leading to more robust schedules and better synchronization across management functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Construction prefabrication projects, especially those involving large, heavy components, often operate in a multi-project environment with limited space. This leads to a critical issue: frequent resource transfers between projects are not only inefficient but also disrupt workflow, reduce productivity, and increase management complexity. Existing scheduling methods often treat projects independently or create overly complex "super-projects," failing to adequately address these inter-project dependencies. Furthermore, there's a disconnect between high-level project planning and on-the-ground operational realities, meaning changes like material logistics delays aren't effectively incorporated into schedules, impacting cost and timelines.

Methods

The core of this research is a dual-level resource-constrained multi-project scheduling framework. This framework operates on two interconnected levels:

  • Upper Level (Resource Allocation): This level focuses on allocating resources to entire projects (or "macro-activities" representing aggregated project phases). It aims to balance resource demands across multiple concurrent projects, effectively resolving resource conflicts and determining project-level milestones.
  • Lower Level (Activity Scheduling): This level takes the resource allocations and milestones from the upper level and schedules individual activities within each project. It incorporates project-specific constraints like material logistics and design readiness.

The framework utilizes constraint programming for optimization at both levels. A key innovation is the introduction of macro-activities, which aggregate detailed tasks to simplify resource allocation and reduce inter-project transfers. The paper also defines a new metric, "resource use robustness," to quantitatively measure the impact of inter-project resource dependencies on schedule stability.

Datasets

The paper utilizes data from:

  • Two literature case studies: These are adapted from previous research to illustrate the framework's capabilities.
  • Two actual case studies: These involve bridge girder fabrication projects from a partner company in Edmonton, Canada. This real-world data is crucial for demonstrating the framework's practical applicability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decomposing complexity: The dual-level approach effectively breaks down the complex multi-project scheduling problem into manageable upper and lower levels, mirroring real-world project management structures.
  • Macro-activities as a bridge: Aggregating detailed activities into macro-activities is a clever way to simplify resource allocation at the project level while still allowing for detailed scheduling at the operational level.
  • Quantifying schedule robustness: The "resource use robustness" indicator provides a much-needed metric to assess how susceptible a schedule is to disruptions caused by shared resources, moving beyond traditional cost and duration metrics.
  • Bridging planning and execution: By linking upper-level resource allocation with lower-level activity scheduling, the framework aims to align project planning with operational realities, making schedules more realistic and adaptable.

Key Results

The research demonstrates that the proposed dual-level framework:

  • Reduces inter-project resource transfers: Case studies showed a significant reduction in resource transfers compared to traditional single-project methods, leading to higher resource use robustness (e.g., 90.5% for the proposed method vs. 34.3% for a single-project method in one scenario).
  • Improves schedule synchronization: The framework enables the creation of interconnected program, project, and operation schedules, facilitating better communication and decision-making.
  • Analyzes material logistics impact: The lower-level model can effectively simulate the impact of material delivery uncertainties on project cost and schedule, providing crucial decision support for practitioners. For instance, it can identify budget-constrained delivery time windows.
  • Achieves practical feasibility: The framework was validated through real-world bridge girder fabrication projects, with expert confirmation of its practical applicability and potential for cost and time savings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Deterministic framework: The current research primarily uses a deterministic framework. Future work could extend this by incorporating stochastic models to account for uncertainties like rework, change orders, and variations in activity durations and resource requirements.
  • Dynamic feedback loop: The authors suggest developing a closed feedback loop where dynamic changes at the lower level (operational progress) continuously inform and update decisions at the upper level (resource allocation), leading to more dynamic project control.
  • Resource transfer costs: Further research could explore quantifying setup costs, material handling costs, and labor productivity losses due to unlearning curves to better integrate resource transfer costs into the optimization objective.
  • Scalability: While demonstrated on projects with over 2,000 activities, the scalability of the models for even larger and more complex project networks warrants further investigation through systematic simulation tests.
  • Additional constraints: The framework could be enhanced by incorporating more scheduling constraints, such as engineering drawing availability and limited workspace, to analyze their impact on project schedule performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Construction prefabrication projects, where engineered systems or components of large size and heavy weight are fabricated with limited workplace and storage areas, typically are executed in a multi-project environment. So, frequent inter-project resource transfers are not feasible and should be mitigated. Nonetheless, existing multi-project scheduling approaches give rise to extensive resource links among projects, thereby negatively impacting the stability and feasibility of resultant project schedules and increasing management difficulties in processing each project. Furthermore, the project planning and the workface operation realities are separated from each other in current practice. As a result, it is common that the project planning overestimates the actual construction productivity, while changes and variations (e.g., material logistics) during operations cannot be timely reflected to the project or general managers and present their impacts on the project’s and program’s schedule and cost. This research explores a systematic dual-level resource planning framework for addressing these issues identified in conventional resource planning and project scheduling methods for multiple concurrent projects. A dual-level resource-constrained multi-project scheduling framework is proposed to provide achievable resource allocation decisions for program planning and activity scheduling for projects and operations for prefabrication projects in construction. The proposed framework is capable of (1) generating robust resource use plans for multiple concurring projects, (2) interconnecting and synchronizing schedules for various management functions, and (3) analytically evaluating the impact of inherent material logistics uncertainties on individual project schedules and costs. These advantages are illustrated and demonstrated through two literature case studies and two actual case studies of bridge girder fabrication projects from a partner company in Edmonton, Canada. The academic contributions of this research are identified as (1) advancement of conventional multi-project scheduling approaches by proposing a generic dual-level scheduling framework, which generates more robust schedules and integrates schedules for various management functions; (2) development of an integrated scheduling optimization model which incorporates material supplies as constraints for resource-constrained project scheduling so as to analyze the impact of material logistics uncertainties on project schedule and cost performances; and (3) the provision and definition of a new indicator (i.e., resource use robustness) for evaluating construction schedule performance. In terms of practical contributions, the outcomes of this research would (1) provide production managers with reliable and feasible work plans at a fabrication facility, which ensure crew work continuity on individual projects, enhance resource utilization efficiency, and improve communication efficiency among project management teams; (2) create reliable program schedule, project schedule, and operation schedules, which are dynamically interconnected with each other, thereby, facilitating schedule maintenance and updating, saving the efforts for progress report among management personnel, and guiding various management functions such as evaluation of remaining fabrication capacities, prediction of project delivery performances, and execution of daily fabrication work within fabrication facilities; and (3) provide crucial decision support for practitioners to determine allowable time windows of certain critical material deliveries so as to keep the total project cost under pre-set limits and provide alternative plans in coping with disruptions and changes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2018dual,
  author = {Jing Liu},
  title = {{Dual-Level Resource-Constrained Multi-Project Scheduling Framework for Prefabrication in Construction}},
  booktitle = {University},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7939/r3v98074t},
}
Figure