DrugPattern: a web-based tool for drug set enrichment analysis

Chuanbo Huang, Weili Yang, Junpei Wang, Yuan Zhou, Bin Geng, Georgios Kararigas, Jichun Yang, Qinghua CuibioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces DrugPattern, a novel web-based tool that leverages drug set enrichment analysis to uncover hidden patterns within drug-related data. By analyzing a curated set of 7019 drug categories, DrugPattern can predict potential beneficial effects of compounds, as demonstrated by its surprising prediction that oxidized LDL (oxLDL) might have protective roles in certain diseases, which was subsequently validated experimentally.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of biomedical data analysis has seen tremendous progress with methods like gene set enrichment analysis, which are adept at finding patterns in complex biological datasets. However, there's a notable gap when it comes to inferring similar patterns specifically within drug-related datasets. While existing tools can analyze gene sets or pathways influenced by drugs, a dedicated tool for directly analyzing sets of drugs based on their shared characteristics (like targets, indications, or adverse reactions) was missing. This limitation hinders our ability to discover novel drug relationships and repurpose existing medications effectively.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of DrugPattern, a web-based tool that performs drug set enrichment analysis. The process involves:

  1. Data Curation: The researchers collected and curated a substantial dataset of 7019 drug sets. These sets categorize drugs based on various biomedical properties, including their targets, pathways, chemical classifications, associated diseases, and adverse reactions.
  2. Drug Similarity Identification: To validate DrugPattern, they used oxidized low-density lipoprotein (oxLDL) as a case study. They identified 66 drugs that exhibited gene expression profiles highly similar to oxLDL by comparing gene expression signatures from the Connectivity Map (CMap) database.
  3. Enrichment Analysis: These 66 oxLDL-similar drugs were then input into DrugPattern. The tool performed an enrichment analysis, assessing how significantly these drugs were represented within the 7019 curated drug sets. This analysis aims to identify drug sets that are "enriched" by the input drug list, suggesting shared properties or potential biological roles.
  4. Hypergeometric Test: The statistical significance of the enrichment was calculated using a hypergeometric test, a standard method for determining the probability of drawing a specific number of "successes" (drugs of interest) from a population without replacement.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is a newly curated collection of 7019 drug sets. These sets were derived from various public databases, including:

  • DrugBank: A comprehensive database of drug information.
  • KEGG: A collection of databases on genomes, biological pathways, and diseases.
  • ADReCS: A database for adverse drug reactions.

For identifying oxLDL-similar drugs, the Connectivity Map (CMap) database was utilized, which contains gene expression profiles for thousands of small molecules.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap in Drug Analysis: DrugPattern fills a critical void by providing a dedicated tool for drug set enrichment analysis, enabling researchers to uncover patterns and relationships within drug lists that were previously difficult to discern.
  • Unveiling Unexpected Roles of oxLDL: The most striking insight is the prediction that oxLDL, commonly viewed as a detrimental factor, might actually possess beneficial effects in certain disease contexts. This challenges conventional wisdom and opens new avenues for research.
  • The Multifaceted Nature of Molecules: This study underscores the principle that biological molecules, like oxLDL, can have diverse and context-dependent roles. What is considered harmful in one scenario might be protective in another.
  • Experimental Validation is Key: The study highlights the importance of experimental validation. While DrugPattern's predictions are powerful, they are most impactful when confirmed through rigorous laboratory experiments, as demonstrated with the oxLDL and type 2 diabetes findings.

Key Results

  • DrugPattern was developed and curated 7019 drug sets covering diverse categories.
  • The tool successfully identified 66 oxLDL-similar drugs based on gene expression profiles.
  • DrugPattern predicted that oxLDL has beneficial effects on several diseases, including bacterial infection, type 2 diabetes, cancer, and depression.
  • Literature mining supported most of these predictions, with type 2 diabetes (T2D) being a notable exception where oxLDL was previously considered a risk factor.
  • Animal experiments confirmed the predicted beneficial effects of oxLDL on T2D, showing improvements in fasting blood glucose, glucose intolerance, and insulin sensitivity.
  • The experimental results and literature evidence collectively support DrugPattern's predictions, suggesting that the roles of oxLDL in diseases like T2D may be more complex than previously understood.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope of Drug Sets: While 7019 drug sets are substantial, the authors acknowledge that the coverage might not be exhaustive. Future work could involve expanding the number and diversity of drug sets to capture a broader range of drug-related patterns.
  • Causality Inference: DrugPattern infers patterns and potential relationships. While the study uses oxLDL as an example to explore causality, the tool itself primarily identifies associations. Further development could focus on enhancing the inference of causal relationships.
  • Experimental Validation: The study successfully validated some predictions experimentally. Future work could involve validating more of DrugPattern's predictions across a wider range of diseases and drug classes.
  • Integration with Other Data Types: The current approach relies heavily on gene expression data for drug similarity. Integrating other omics data (e.g., proteomics, metabolomics) could potentially enrich the drug similarity analysis and improve prediction accuracy.
  • Broader Application: The authors suggest that DrugPattern can be used for fast scientific discovery and to facilitate big data-based precision medicine. Future work should focus on making the tool more accessible and demonstrating its utility in various research and clinical settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Set enrichment analysis based methods (e.g. gene set enrichment analysis) have provided great helps in mining patterns in biomedical datasets, however, tools for inferring regular patterns in drug-related datasets are still limited. For the above purpose, here we developed a web-based tool, DrugPattern. DrugPattern first collected and curated 7019 drug sets, including indications, adverse reaction, targets, pathways etc. For a list of interested drugs, DrugPattern then evaluates the significance of the enrichment of these drugs in each of the 7019 drug sets. To validate DrugPattern, we applied it to predict the potential protective roles of oxidized low-density lipoprotein (oxLDL), a widely accepted deleterious factor for the body. We predicted that oxLDL has beneficial effects on some diseases, most of which were supported by literature except type 2 diabetes (T2D), in which oxLDL was previously believed to be a risk factor. Animal experiments further validated that oxLDL indeed has beneficial effects on T2D. These data confirmed the prediction accuracy of our approach and revealed unexpected protective roles for oxLDL in various diseases including T2D. This study provides a tool to infer regular patterns in biomedical datasets based on drug set enrichment analysis.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2017drugpattern,
  author = {Chuanbo Huang and Weili Yang and Junpei Wang and Yuan Zhou and Bin Geng and Georgios Kararigas and Jichun Yang and Qinghua Cui},
  title = {{DrugPattern: a web-based tool for drug set enrichment analysis}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/178632},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure