Driving towards ecotechnologies

Devora Najjar, Avery M Normandin, Elizabeth A. Strait, Kevin M. EsveltPathogens 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that the successful deployment of gene drive technologies for ecological engineering hinges not just on technical feasibility but critically on public perception and community engagement. It proposes a "Responsive Science" model, emphasizing local involvement and transparency, as the most ethical and effective path to overcome social, economic, and diplomatic barriers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the significant challenge of translating promising gene drive technologies from the lab to real-world applications for public health and ecological benefit. While gene drives offer powerful tools to combat diseases like malaria or control invasive species, their potential to spread through wild populations raises profound concerns about unintended consequences, public acceptance, and international governance. The authors highlight the risk of public skepticism and media scrutiny derailing even well-intentioned projects, leading to economic and diplomatic repercussions, such as trade barriers. They aim to bridge the gap between the technical potential of gene drives and the social and political realities of their implementation.

Methods

The paper doesn't present novel experimental methods but rather synthesizes existing knowledge and proposes a framework for responsible development. The "Responsive Science" model is the core methodological contribution. This approach emphasizes:

  • Early and Extensive Community Involvement: Engaging local citizens from the project's inception to guide decision-making.
  • Public Perception Focus: Prioritizing technologies that are "favorably perceived" and address obvious local issues.
  • Scalability: Starting with small, local interventions before considering broader applications.
  • Transparency and Openness: Fostering community understanding and trust through open research and communication.

The authors review past and current ecological engineering attempts, including gene drive applications, to illustrate the successes and failures of different approaches to public engagement and technology deployment.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Public perception is paramount: Technical efficacy alone is insufficient; societal acceptance is a critical determinant of success. The starkly different public reactions to MosquitoMate (Wolbachia) and Oxitec (transgenic mosquitoes) highlight how perceived "naturalness" can influence acceptance, even when outcomes are similar.
  • "Responsive Science" is the way forward: A model that prioritizes community governance, transparency, and local input is more likely to overcome resistance and ensure equitable benefits. This contrasts with traditional top-down regulatory approaches.
  • Self-propagating gene drives face the highest hurdles: Technologies that spread indefinitely are most likely to encounter international resistance and trade barriers, necessitating extreme caution and robust community buy-in.
  • Local, reversible, or self-exhausting drives offer more manageable entry points: These types of gene drives, or non-driving alternatives, can serve as valuable tools for initial testing and community engagement, building trust and gathering data before considering more potent interventions.
  • Ecological engineering is inherently a civic governance issue: Decisions about technologies that impact shared environments should involve broader community participation, not just market forces or regulatory bodies.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results from new experiments. Instead, it offers qualitative insights derived from case studies:

  • MosquitoMate's success: The Wolbachia-based sterile male mosquito approach has seen relatively smooth public acceptance and governmental approval in the US, attributed to its perceived "naturalness."
  • Oxitec's challenges: The transgenic mosquito approach faced significant public opposition in Florida, despite successful deployments elsewhere, illustrating the impact of local sentiment and pre-existing skepticism towards genetic engineering.
  • Eliminate Dengue's community engagement: This project successfully engaged local communities in Australia, leading to widespread support and active participation in mosquito releases, demonstrating the power of door-to-door outreach and town hall meetings.
  • Mice Against Ticks' community governance: This project is actively governed by local steering committees, with citizens involved in decision-making, leading to a notable lack of outright opposition despite the novel nature of the intervention.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the "Responsive Science" approach is not a panacea and faces challenges:

  • Translating to higher-risk environments: While successful in developed nations with educated populations and strong local governance (e.g., Australia, US islands), applying this model in regions with less infrastructure or different governance structures will be more complex.
  • Defining "obvious benefit": Ensuring that the benefits of an intervention are truly clear and compelling to the general public, not just to scientists or policymakers, remains a challenge.
  • The inherent difficulty of "controlled" field trials: For self-propagating gene drives, the risk of accidental or deliberate spread makes true containment extremely difficult, underscoring the need for careful consideration of alternatives.

Future work should focus on refining the "Responsive Science" model, developing robust methods for community engagement, and exploring the potential of less controversial gene drive types or non-driving alternatives as stepping stones to more ambitious ecological engineering goals. The paper implicitly calls for continued research into the social and ethical dimensions of these technologies, alongside technical advancements.

Summary updated

Abstract

The prospect of using genetic methods to target vector, parasite, and reservoir species offers tremendous potential benefits to public health, but the use of genome editing to alter the shared environment will require special attention to public perception and community governance in order to benefit the world. Public skepticism combined with the media scrutiny of gene drive systems could easily derail unpopular projects entirely, especially given the potential for trade barriers to be raised against countries that employ self-propagating gene drives. Hence, open and community-guided development of thoughtfully chosen applications is not only the most ethical approach, but also the most likely to overcome the economic, social, and diplomatic barriers. Here we review current and past attempts to alter ecosystems using biological methods, identify key determinants of social acceptance, and chart a stepwise path for developers towards safe and widely supported use.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{najjar2017driving,
  author = {Devora Najjar and Avery M Normandin and Elizabeth A. Strait and Kevin M. Esvelt},
  title = {{Driving towards ecotechnologies}},
  booktitle = {Pathogens},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1080/20477724.2018.1452844},
}
Figure