Drivers of desert plant beta diversity on the Qinghai–Tibet plateau

Lu Wen, Kexuan Zhao, Haoyu Sun, Gang Feng, Qiang Sun, Cunzhu Liang, Zhiyong Li, Lixin Wang, Jens‐Christian SvenningEcology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the factors driving plant community diversity across the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau's desert ecosystems. It reveals that environmental conditions, particularly soil properties and temperature, are the primary drivers of taxonomic, phylogenetic, and functional beta diversity, with environmental sorting playing a dominant role. Understanding these drivers is crucial for effective conservation strategies in this unique and vulnerable region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Desert ecosystems, despite covering a significant portion of the Earth's landmass, are often overlooked in biodiversity research. The Qinghai-Tibet Plateau (QTP) presents a particularly unique desert environment due to its high altitude and harsh conditions, harboring many endemic species. However, the mechanisms shaping the diversity of plant communities in this region, specifically how species composition varies across space (beta diversity), remain poorly understood. Beta diversity is a critical component of overall biodiversity, reflecting how species composition changes between different locations. Understanding its drivers is essential for effective conservation planning, especially in the face of global change and anthropogenic pressures. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by dissecting the drivers of taxonomic, phylogenetic, and functional beta diversity in the QTP desert.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze beta diversity. They collected field survey data from 53,100m x 100m plots across the QTP desert. To quantify beta diversity, they utilized the Jaccard similarity coefficient and decomposed it into two components: turnover (species replacement) and nestedness (subsetting of species). This decomposition was applied to three facets of diversity:

  • Taxonomic beta diversity: based on species presence/absence.
  • Phylogenetic beta diversity: incorporating evolutionary relationships between species.
  • Functional beta diversity: considering the traits of species.

To identify the drivers, they calculated environmental distance (differences in climate, soil, and altitude between sites) and geographic distance (spatial separation of sites). Statistical analyses included:

  • Mantel tests: to assess correlations between distance matrices and beta diversity.
  • Variance partitioning analysis (VPA): to quantify the unique and shared contributions of environmental and geographic factors to beta diversity.
  • Distance-based redundancy analysis (db-RDA): to pinpoint specific environmental variables (climate and soil factors) that most strongly influence beta diversity.

Datasets

The study utilized field survey data collected from 53,100m x 100m plots across the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau desert between 2017 and 2019.

  • Environmental data: Climatic data (mean annual precipitation, mean annual temperature, mean temperature of the coldest/warmest month, potential evapotranspiration, relative humidity, wind speed) were obtained from the National Earth System Science Data Sharing Service Platform. Altitude was measured on-site. Soil data (total nitrogen, total phosphorus, total potassium, pH, soil organic carbon, available nitrogen, available phosphorus, available potassium, gravel coverage) were derived from spatial data with a 90m precision.
  • Species data: Plant species names, mean height, and cover of herb and shrub species were recorded in each plot.
  • Phylogenetic data: A phylogenetic tree was constructed using the phylo.maker function in the R package V.PhyloMaker.
  • Functional trait data: Five plant functional traits (height, leaf area, leaf thickness, leaf dry matter content, specific leaf area) were selected. Data for these traits were obtained from the TRY database and published literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Turnover reigns supreme: Across all facets of diversity (taxonomic, phylogenetic, and functional), species turnover was the dominant component of beta diversity. This suggests that the primary driver of community differences is the replacement of species rather than simply the loss or gain of species from a subset.
  • Environment trumps geography: Environmental distance was a far more significant predictor of beta diversity than geographic distance. This highlights the strong influence of local environmental conditions in shaping plant communities in this region.
  • Soil and temperature are key players: Specific environmental factors, particularly soil total potassium content, mean temperature of the coldest month, and soil total phosphorus content, emerged as critical drivers of beta diversity. This underscores the importance of edaphic (soil-related) and climatic conditions in this arid, high-altitude environment.
  • Herbs vs. Shrubs: different sensitivities: The relative importance of environmental and geographic factors differed between herbs and shrubs, with environmental distance being more influential for shrubs. This suggests distinct ecological strategies and sensitivities to environmental gradients between these growth forms.
  • Environmental sorting is the dominant process: The findings strongly support the hypothesis that environmental sorting—the process by which species are filtered by their environmental tolerances—is the predominant mechanism structuring plant communities in the QTP desert.

Key Results

  • Environmental distance explained significantly more variation: Environmental distance uniquely explained 15.2%-22.8% of beta diversity across the three facets, while geographic distance explained only 1.7%-2.4%.
  • Turnover dominates all diversity facets: For the whole community, taxonomic beta diversity was 0.88, with turnover contributing 0.80 and nestedness 0.08. Similar patterns were observed for phylogenetic and functional beta diversity.
  • Soil factors are strong predictors: db-RDA revealed that soil total potassium content had a substantial impact on all three facets of beta diversity. Mean temperature of the coldest month and soil total phosphorus content also significantly impacted taxonomic and functional beta diversity.
  • Herbs showed higher beta diversity: Herbs consistently exhibited higher beta diversity than shrubs, potentially due to their greater sensitivity to environmental gradients.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited functional trait analysis for herbs/shrubs separately: Due to data limitations (e.g., fewer plots with shrubs or herbs, or fewer functional traits than species), the functional beta diversity of herb and shrub layers could not be calculated separately. Future research could aim to collect more comprehensive data to address this.
  • Focus on specific environmental factors: While a range of environmental factors were considered, future work could explore the influence of other factors like soil moisture, nutrient availability, or biotic interactions in more detail.
  • Conservation implications: The study strongly advocates for prioritizing the conservation of diverse environmental conditions in the QTP desert and mitigating anthropogenic degradation. Future work could translate these findings into concrete, spatially explicit conservation plans, potentially incorporating geodiversity mapping. The authors suggest that incorporating geodiversity mapping into conservation planning could be crucial for long-term vegetation protection.

Summary updated

Abstract

The desert ecosystem of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau (QTP) is an important component of China's desert ecosystem. Studying the mechanisms shaping the taxonomic, phylogenetic, and functional beta diversity of plant communities in the QTP desert will help us to promote scientific conservation and management of the region's biodiversity. This study investigated the effects of environmental (including altitude, climate factors, and soil factors) and geographic distances on three facets of beta diversity as well as their turnover and nestedness components based on field survey data. The results showed that turnover components dominate the three facets of beta diversity. However, the turnover contributions to phylogenetic and functional beta diversity were lower than for taxonomic beta diversity. Environmental distance had a greater influence than geographic distance, with the former uniquely explaining 15.2%-22.8% of beta diversity and the latter explaining only 1.7%-2.4%. Additionally, the explanatory power of different factors for beta diversity differed between herbs and shrubs, with environmental distance being more important for the latter. Distance-based redundancy analysis suggested that soil total potassium content had a substantial impact on the beta diversity of three dimensions, with mean temperature of the coldest month and soil total phosphorus content having a substantial impact on taxonomic and functional beta diversity as well. Our results support that environmental sorting plays a predominant role in shaping plant community composition across QTP desert ecosystems. To maintain the plant diversity of this region, it is crucial to prioritize the conservation of its diverse environmental conditions and actively mitigate its degradation by anthropogenic pressures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wen2024drivers,
  author = {Lu Wen and Kexuan Zhao and Haoyu Sun and Gang Feng and Qiang Sun and Cunzhu Liang and Zhiyong Li and Lixin Wang and Jens‐Christian Svenning},
  title = {{Drivers of desert plant beta diversity on the Qinghai–Tibet plateau}},
  booktitle = {Ecology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/ece3.10993},
}
Figure