Abstract
Currently, there are no in-situ methods to quantify drilling-vibration response characteristics of different lithologies. Here, we quantified the vibration responses of four lithologies (limestone, sandstone, coal, and mudstone) using a combination of theoretical deduction and numerical simulation. First, a drilling-vibration model of a particular rock was established, and the differential equations of motion and vibration responses to rock/drill bit interactions with the formation were derived. Next, finite-element simulation was adopted to simulate the rock/drill-bit interactions of the four lithologies. Finally, the Hilbert–Huang transform (HHT) was applied to extract characteristic waveforms, frequency bands, peak frequencies, and marginal spectra of vibration signals. Simulations revealed that the highest and lowest vibration responses were observed in limestone and mudstone, respectively. Vibration acceleration was proportional to the Young's modulus of rocks, whereas vibration displacement and velocity were inversely proportional to Young's modulus, compressive strength, and density. Based on the HHT results, among the four lithologies, vibration responses had the largest characteristic frequency segments and peak frequencies in limestone (28.1–34.6 kHz and 33.4 kHz, respectively), whereas those of mudstone were the smallest (15.6–21.3 kHz and 19.6 kHz, respectively). The results of this study provide a theoretical basis for establishing an identification method and expert knowledge database of lithology based on drilling-vibration responses.
Introduction
In petroleum and mining engineering, real-time identification of the rock type (lithology) being penetrated is critical for optimizing drilling parameters, such as weight-on-bit and RPM, preventing geological accidents, and reducing operational costs. While existing methods like acoustic logging or monitoring drill-string vibrations are available, they often suffer from significant noise interference from the drilling rig, fluid circulation, and torsional vibrations. Consequently, there is a lack of reliable, in-situ methods to isolate and quantify the specific vibration response of the rock itself. This study addresses this gap by establishing a theoretical and numerical framework to characterize the unique vibration "fingerprints" of different lithologies when broken by a drill bit.
Methodology
The research followed a structured three-step approach to isolate and analyze rock-specific vibration signals.
Theoretical Modeling
The bit-rock interaction was simplified into a single-degree-of-freedom forced vibration system under impact loading. Differential equations of motion were derived to describe the response of the system.
Numerical Simulation
Using ABAQUS finite-element software, the researchers simulated a Polycrystalline Diamond Compact (PDC) bit interacting with four lithologies: limestone, sandstone, coal, and mudstone. The Hill yield function and Drucker–Prager criterion were employed to model rock failure and spalling accurately. The simulation utilized standardized petrophysical parameters (uniaxial compressive strength, density, elastic modulus, and Poisson’s ratio) for each rock type.
Signal Processing via HHT
To analyze the complex, non-stationary vibration signals generated during simulation, the Hilbert–Huang transform (HHT) was applied. Unlike traditional Fourier transforms, HHT utilizes Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) to break signals down into Intrinsic Mode Functions (IMFs). This allows for a precise analysis of how frequency and energy evolve over time, which is essential for non-linear drilling vibrations.
Key Results and Insights
The study revealed strong correlations between a rock's mechanical properties and its vibration response.
- Mechanical Correlations: Vibration acceleration was found to be directly proportional to the rock's Young's modulus. In contrast, vibration displacement and velocity were inversely proportional to Young's modulus, compressive strength, and density. Harder, denser rocks exhibit faster "snap-back" but smaller overall movement.
- Frequency Fingerprints: Each lithology produced a distinct frequency band and peak frequency. Limestone exhibited the highest characteristic frequencies, while mudstone exhibited the lowest.
- Limestone: 28.1–34.6 kHz (Peak: 33.4 kHz)
- Sandstone: 23.6–30.3 kHz (Peak: 28.8 kHz)
- Coal: 20.5–26.3 kHz (Peak: 23.9 kHz)
- Mudstone: 15.6–21.3 kHz (Peak: 19.6 kHz)
- HHT Superiority: The HHT method proved superior to standard Fourier analysis for these non-stationary signals. EMD revealed that the most critical vibration information is contained within the first six components (IMF1–6), with higher-order components representing negligible low-frequency noise.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This research provides a theoretical foundation for real-time lithology identification. While the current model assumes isotropic materials and ignores environmental factors like confining pressure and drilling mud dampening, it successfully demonstrates that different rocks have unique vibration signatures. Future work will focus on incorporating these findings into an "expert knowledge database" to enable automated systems that can adjust drilling parameters in real-time based on the detected vibration "fingerprint" at the surface or downhole.
Summary updated