Introduction
Acute cholecystitis is a common surgical emergency, typically managed with laparoscopic cholecystectomy. However, for a significant subset of patients—particularly the elderly with multiple comorbidities—surgery carries prohibitive risks. Historically, percutaneous cholecystostomy (PC) has been the fallback option, providing external drainage to resolve the acute infection. While effective initially, PC is associated with high long-term morbidity due to the external drainage tube, including dislodgement, infection, and reduced quality of life. This multicenter randomized clinical trial evaluates Endoscopic Ultrasound-Guided Gallbladder Drainage (EUS-GBD) as a superior internal alternative.
Methodology
The study enrolled 80 consecutive high-risk surgical patients with acute cholecystitis across multiple centers between 2014 and 2018. Patients were randomized to receive either EUS-GBD (n=39) or the standard PC (n=40). EUS-GBD involves the internal placement of a stent to create a conduit between the gallbladder and the gastrointestinal tract (stomach or duodenum). The primary objective was to compare complication rates at one year. Secondary measures included technical success, clinical resolution, and hospital stay duration.
Key Findings
The trial revealed that while both procedures are highly effective in the short term, their long-term safety profiles differ drastically.
- Success Rates: Both EUS-GBD and PC achieved excellent technical success (97-100%) and clinical success (over 92%), indicating that both are viable for immediate decompression.
- Complication Rates: The divergence in safety was evident early and widened over time. At 30 days, the complication rate for EUS-GBD was 10.3% compared to 30% for PC (p = 0.048). By the one-year mark, the EUS-GBD group maintained a 10.3% complication rate, while the PC group’s rate climbed to 50% (p < 0.001).
- Risk Analysis: Multivariate analysis identified the percutaneous approach as the sole independent predictor of complications at one year. Patients in the PC group were nearly 10 times more likely to experience adverse events (Relative Risk 9.8; 95% CI 2.8-34.6).
- Procedure Efficiency: Despite the technical complexity of endoscopic ultrasound, the procedure time for EUS-GBD was comparable to PC (22.9 vs. 27.7 minutes), and there was no significant difference in the initial length of hospital stay.
Clinical Implications
The "internalization" of gallbladder drainage via EUS-GBD eliminates the primary source of morbidity associated with PC: the external tube. By avoiding external catheters, patients experience fewer re-hospitalizations and a lower incidence of tube-related complications such as leakage or accidental removal.
However, the study notes that EUS-GBD is a technically demanding procedure requiring specialized training and equipment (interventional endoscopic ultrasound). This may limit its immediate availability in centers without dedicated interventional endoscopy units compared to the more widely available percutaneous drainage performed by interventional radiologists.
Conclusion
This randomized trial provides high-level evidence that EUS-GBD significantly reduces long-term complications compared to percutaneous cholecystostomy in high-risk surgical patients. Its superior safety profile suggests it should be considered the new gold standard for definitive drainage in this vulnerable patient population. Future research should focus on long-term stent patency beyond one year and the broader implementation of interventional EUS training.
Summary updated