Drawing Boundaries: Architectural Images in Qing China (review)
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
Reviewed by: Drawing Boundaries: Architectural Images in Qing China Minghui Hu (bio) Anita Chung . Drawing Boundaries: Architectural Images in Qing China. Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press, 2004. 210 pp. Hardcover $45.00, ISBN 0-8248-2663-9. In this new book Anita Chung has identified a relatively little-researched topic: jiehua painting, a style of painting from eighteenth-century China devoted to the graphic representation of space in the Qing imperial court and the urban spaces of the elite society of the lower Yangzi basin. Although the term literally means "boundary drawing," Chung renders it as "architectural painting." The structure of her book is straightforward. Chapter 1 delineates the domestic pedigrees and foreign influences of what later became known as jiehua. Chapter 2 describes major jiehua painters and their patrons at the imperial court and in Yangzhou. The main body of the book, chapters 3 to 6, details the styles in which jiehua painters portrayed the magnificence of the imperial institution and its ideals as well as the urban affluence of the lower Yangzi basin, especially in Yangzhou. The major contribution of the volume, I feel, is the way that it traces the native development of graphic representations of the imperial and urban spaces as an art form that was created for luxury consumption. This development was, of course, influenced by the expansion of the Qing empire and the commercialization of the lower Yangzi basin. Court painters appropriated some techniques taught by the Jesuits, but jiehua paintings nonetheless exhibit a continuity in terms of the accuracy and perspective in their depiction of architectural forms. The first question that came to my mind on reading this book concerned the origins of architectural painting in China. Chung says that architectural painters understood the structural framework of Chinese buildings and gradually developed various ways of representing them pictorially. Since painters of architecture shared the same low status as most other artisans and craftsmen of the times, one wonders how the later, more elite art forms evolved out of the artisan tradition. The obscure boundary between early craft and later art from the eleventh century onward hides the humble origins of the genre. Moreover, the function of architectural painting as decorative art in the Ming period also calls for explication, but Chung does not pursue this question, preferring instead to examine how the elite painters "elevate this type of work from a mere decorative function" and to analyze the aesthetic quality of their architectural paintings. This predisposition inevitably leads Chung to examine only the works of elite painters and their critics. The scope of Chung's analysis is of course not the subject of this review; it is the proper context of elite painters and their literati critics that is my concern here. Chung follows most art historians and identifies the network of court patronage as the context of architectural painting production. Although she does provide [End Page 392] a descriptive chapter that identifies court painters and their patrons, the mutual enhancement between the networks of court patronage among the urban elite and the development of the aesthetics of architectural painting perhaps require a more nuanced analysis. The patronage of architectural painting, in any case, corroborates the pattern of a two-way elite migration between the lower Yangzi delta and the Qing court. By the end of the seventeenth century, the court began to recruit all kinds of talent to staff the newly consolidated bureaucracy. This state-building process continued vigorously through the first half of the eighteenth century and facilitated travel by generations of cultural elites back and forth between the court and the urban enclaves in the lower Yangzi. Chung traces the evolving styles and techniques of architectural painting and identifies a pattern of elite migration similar to that found by other historians of the Qing. Her analysis also shows that the self-contained contours of the world of the affluent elite were distinctly located in the North China and lower Yangzi regions, whereas cultural elites in other regions did not seem to share a similar level of affluence and material display. Architectural paintings from the Qing court captured the details of rituals performed by the Qing rulers, the magnificence of...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2005drawing,
author = {Minghui Hu},
title = {{Drawing Boundaries: Architectural Images in Qing China (review)}},
booktitle = {China},
year = {2005},
doi = {10.1353/cri.2006.0021},
}Loading related content...