Dosimetry of nasal uptake of water-soluble and reactive gases: A first study of interhuman variability

Guilherme J. M. Garcia, Jeffry D. Schroeter, Rebecca Segal, John Stanek, Gary L. Foureman, Julia S. KimbellInhalation 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to model how reactive, water-soluble gases are absorbed in the human nose, revealing significant inter-individual variability in uptake patterns due to nasal anatomy and breathing rates. Surprisingly, the researchers found that children and adults exhibit similar nasal gas uptake patterns, suggesting current risk assessment factors might be adequate for this specific exposure scenario.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When we inhale toxic gases, especially those that are water-soluble and reactive, our nasal passages are the first line of defense. These gases can be absorbed by the nasal lining, potentially causing damage. In laboratory animals, lesions often appear in areas with the highest gas absorption. However, extrapolating these findings to humans is challenging because human nasal anatomy and breathing patterns vary considerably due to factors like age, body size, and gender. This variability can influence how gases are distributed and absorbed, potentially making certain individuals or age groups more vulnerable to toxic effects. Current risk assessment methods often assume uniform gas uptake, which may not accurately reflect the reality of localized absorption hotspots and inter-individual differences. This paper aims to quantify this interhuman variability in nasal gas uptake for reactive gases and investigate potential differences between children and adults.

Methods

The researchers employed computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to simulate airflow and gas uptake in the nasal passages. They created detailed 3D models of the nasal cavities for five adults and two children (aged 7 and 8) using MRI and CT scans. These models were then used to simulate inspiratory airflow at resting breathing rates, scaled allometrically based on body mass.

Two gas uptake scenarios were simulated:

  1. Maximum uptake: This assumes an infinitely fast reaction between the inhaled gas and the nasal lining, effectively setting the gas concentration at the airway walls to zero.
  2. Moderate uptake: This simulates a finite reaction rate, where gas absorption is proportional to the gas concentration at the airway wall.

The simulations focused on the main nasal chamber, excluding the nasopharynx due to reconstruction limitations in some models. The key output was the "wall flux," representing the rate of gas absorption per unit surface area of the nasal lining.

Datasets

The study utilized anatomical data from:

  • Five adult subjects: Nasal geometries were derived from existing MRI scans (adults 1-4) and newly acquired CT scans (adult 5).
  • Two child subjects: Nasal geometries were reconstructed from CT scans.

Anthropological data, including gender, age, ethnicity, body mass, and allometrically scaled minute volumes (breathing rates), were collected or estimated for all seven subjects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-uniform absorption is the norm: Gas absorption in the nasal passages is not uniform. The simulations consistently showed that most of the inhaled reactive gas is absorbed in the anterior portion of the nose, creating "hotspots" of high absorption.
  • Anatomy dictates distribution: Differences in individual nasal anatomy significantly influence airflow patterns and, consequently, the spatial distribution of gas absorption.
  • Children and adults are surprisingly similar: Despite differences in nasal size and breathing rates, the patterns of gas uptake and the dose per unit surface area were remarkably similar between the adult and child subjects. This challenges the common assumption that children are inherently at higher risk for nasal effects from inhaled gases due to their smaller airways.
  • Interhuman variability exists, but might be manageable: While there is variability in nasal dose due to anatomy and ventilation, the study found it to be relatively limited (a 1.6-fold difference in whole-nose dose among the 7 subjects). This suggests that the current tenfold uncertainty factor used in risk assessments for interhuman variability might be sufficient for this type of exposure.

Key Results

  • Total nasal uptake: Under maximum uptake conditions, total nasal extraction was high, ranging from 88.2% to 93.5% in adults and 88.2% to 92.0% in children. For moderate uptake, it ranged from 77.4% to 81.4% in adults and 73.3% to 77.2% in children.
  • Spatial distribution: Gas concentration dropped significantly within the anterior nasal passages. For example, at the point where the nasal cavities merge, gas concentration was reduced to ~13% (maximum uptake) or ~29% (moderate uptake) of the initial concentration.
  • Interhuman variability in dose: The predicted interhuman variability in whole-nose dose (mass per time per nasal surface area) due to anatomical and ventilation differences was found to be approximately 1.6-fold among the seven individuals studied.
  • Children vs. Adults: Children and adults showed very similar patterns of nasal gas uptake, with no significant differences noted between the two age groups in terms of uptake patterns or dose per unit surface area.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Generic gas model: The simulations represent a generic reactive, water-soluble gas and do not account for specific chemical reactions with different epithelial types, enzymes, or glands, which could lead to greater interhuman variability.
  • Small sample size: The study included only seven subjects, which was insufficient for statistical analysis of age or gender differences.
  • Rigid nasal geometry: The models assumed rigid nasal structures, whereas the nasal mucosa is dynamic and can change in response to stimuli.
  • Limited age range for children: Only 7- and 8-year-olds were studied, leaving younger children unexamined.

Future work should focus on:

  • Larger cohorts: Including more individuals, especially children of various ages and those with anatomical abnormalities (e.g., septal perforations), is crucial.
  • Specific gas modeling: Incorporating toxicodynamic factors (epithelial type, enzyme activity) for specific gases to better understand localized effects.
  • Dynamic nasal models: Developing models that account for the dynamic nature of the nasal mucosa.
  • Investigating toxicodynamics: Exploring how inter-individual differences in biological responses can influence gas uptake and toxicity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Certain inhaled chemicals, such as reactive, water-soluble gases, are readily absorbed by the nasal mucosa upon inhalation and may cause damage to the nasal epithelium. Comparisons of the spatial distribution of nasal lesions in laboratory animals exposed to formaldehyde with gas uptake rates predicted by computational models reveal that lesions usually occur in regions of the susceptible epithelium where gas absorption is highest. Since the uptake patterns are influenced by air currents in the nose, interindividual variability in nasal anatomy and ventilation rates due to age, body size, and gender will affect the patterns of gas absorption in humans, potentially putting some age groups at higher risk when exposed to toxic gases. In this study, interhuman variability in the nasal dosimetry of reactive, water-soluble gases was investigated by means of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models in 5 adults and 2 children, aged 7 and 8 years old. Airflow patterns were investigated for allometrically scaled inhalation rates corresponding to resting breathing. The spatial distribution of uptake at the airway walls was predicted to be nonuniform, with most of the gas being absorbed in the anterior portion of the nasal passages. Under the conditions of these simulations, interhuman variability in dose to the whole nose (mass per time per nasal surface area) due to differences in anatomy and ventilation was predicted to be 1.6-fold among the 7 individuals studied. Children and adults displayed very similar patterns of nasal gas uptake; no significant differences were noted between the two age groups.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{garcia2009dosimetry,
  author = {Guilherme J. M. Garcia and Jeffry D. Schroeter and Rebecca Segal and John Stanek and Gary L. Foureman and Julia S. Kimbell},
  title = {{Dosimetry of nasal uptake of water-soluble and reactive gases: A first study of interhuman variability}},
  booktitle = {Inhalation},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1080/08958370802320186},
}
Figure