Dose rate correction for the novel 2D diode array MapCHECK 3

Mengyang Li, Yuan Tian, Linyi Shen, Guiyuan Li, Liang Zhao, Xinyuan Chen, Shouping Xu, Minghui Li, Peng Huang, Jianrong DaiJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the dose rate dependence of the new MapCHECK 3 (MC3) 2D diode array, finding it more pronounced than its predecessor, MapCHECK 2 (MC2). The authors developed and validated a dose rate correction method that significantly improves measurement accuracy, especially for challenging clinical scenarios like wedge fields.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate dose verification is critical in radiation oncology to ensure patient safety and treatment efficacy. 2D detector arrays, like the MapCHECK series, are widely used for this purpose. However, these detectors can exhibit dose rate dependence, meaning their output signal can vary with the rate at which radiation is delivered. This dependence can lead to measurement inaccuracies, particularly when the dose rate during measurement differs from the dose rate used during calibration. The MapCHECK 3, with its new SunPoint 2 diodes, was suspected to have a more significant dose rate dependence than the older MapCHECK 2. This paper aims to quantify this dependence for MC3, compare it to MC2, and develop and evaluate a correction method to mitigate its impact on measurement accuracy.

Methods

The researchers employed a systematic approach to characterize and correct for dose rate dependence. They compared measurements from both MapCHECK 2 (MC2) and MapCHECK 3 (MC3) against a reference ion chamber. Key methodologies included:

  • Average Dose Rate (ADR) Dependence: Investigated by varying the LINAC output dose rate (MU/min) while keeping other parameters constant.
  • Instantaneous Dose Rate (IDR) Dependence (Dose Per Pulse): Studied by varying the source-to-detector distance (SDD) to alter the pulse repetition frequency.
  • Field Size and Depth Dependence: Assessed how dose rate effects manifest across different field dimensions and depths.
  • Wedge Field Measurements: Examined the impact of dose rate dependence in the presence of beam modifiers (wedges), which are known to influence dose distribution.
  • Dose Rate Correction Model: Exponential functions were fitted to the observed dose rate dependencies (both ADR and IDR) for MC3. These fitted functions were then used to correct the raw diode readings.
  • Accuracy Evaluation: The accuracy of measurements with and without the proposed dose rate correction was evaluated by comparing them to ion chamber measurements and assessing gamma pass rates (a common metric for agreement between planned and measured dose distributions).

Datasets

The study utilized measurements performed on an Elekta Axesse LINAC (6MV x-ray beam). The reference dataset was acquired using a PTW 31021 ion chamber calibrated according to IAEA TRS-398 standards. The MapCHECK 2 and MapCHECK 3 arrays were used for experimental measurements. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing clinical scenarios and standard measurement techniques were employed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MC3's Pronounced Dose Rate Dependence: The new SunPoint 2 diodes in MapCHECK 3 exhibit a significantly larger dose rate dependence (up to 2.5% sensitivity change) compared to the SunPoint 1 diodes in MC2 (less than 1.0% change). This necessitates careful consideration for accurate measurements.
  • Impact of Calibration Conditions: The study highlights that performing dose calibration under conditions significantly different from the actual measurement (e.g., different field sizes, depths, or dose rates) can lead to substantial errors, especially with MC3.
  • Effectiveness of Exponential Correction: The developed exponential fitting functions for both ADR and IDR dependence proved effective in correcting MC3's dose rate-induced errors.
  • Wedge Fields are Particularly Sensitive: Measurements involving wedges showed the most significant improvements after dose rate correction, with pass rates increasing and dose deviations decreasing substantially. This is crucial for clinical QA.
  • Convenience vs. Accuracy: While calibrating under identical conditions to measurement is ideal for accuracy, it's often impractical. The developed correction method offers a more convenient alternative for achieving high accuracy.

Key Results

  • ADR Dependence: MC3 showed a maximum sensitivity change greater than 2.5% over the tested dose rate range, while MC2's change was less than 1.0%.
  • IDR Dependence: MC3 also exhibited a more pronounced IDR dependence compared to MC2, with a maximum difference from the ion chamber exceeding 2.5%.
  • Correction Impact (Depth Dose): Applying ADR correction reduced the average CAX dose deviation for depth dose from 1.0% to 0.5% and improved the gamma pass rate (2%/2mm) from 98.3% to 100%. IDR correction further improved the pass rate to 100.0%.
  • Correction Impact (Field Size): For field size measurements, ADR correction resulted in a CAX dose deviation of 0.8% ± 0.9%, and IDR correction yielded 1.9% ± 8.1%. Gamma pass rates were high for both corrected scenarios (98.4% and 98.8%).
  • Wedge Field Correction: For small wedge fields (e.g., 2x2 cm²), the CAX dose deviation without correction was -5.4% ± 0.1%, with a pass rate of 93.8%. After IDR correction, this improved to -2.5% ± 0.1% and a pass rate of 100.0%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focused on a 6MV x-ray beam; results might differ for other beam energies.
  • The IDR correction fit showed a larger deviation for output dose measurements (1.9% with a large standard deviation), potentially due to the limited dpp range used for fitting.
  • While the correction method is effective, the paper notes that for many standard measurements where dose rate differences are not significant, the improvement might not be "remarkable."
  • Future Work: The authors suggest advancing their investigation into the impact of dose rate dependence and correction efforts on patient QA, particularly for complex scenarios like Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy (VMAT). They also propose exploring the application of this correction method to other diode-based arrays.

Summary updated

Abstract

Compared with MapCHECK2 (SunPoint1 diodes), the more pronounced dose rate dependence of MapCHECK3 (SunPoint2 diodes) should be carefully considered. To ensure highly accurate measurement, it is suggested to perform the dose calibration at the same condition where measurement will be performed. Otherwise, the dose rate correction should be applied.
BibTeX
@article{li2024dose,
  author = {Mengyang Li and Yuan Tian and Linyi Shen and Guiyuan Li and Liang Zhao and Xinyuan Chen and Shouping Xu and Minghui Li and Peng Huang and Jianrong Dai},
  title = {{Dose rate correction for the novel 2D diode array MapCHECK 3}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/acm2.14471},
}
Figure