Dorsomedial and ventromedial prefrontal cortex lesions differentially impact social influence and temporal impulsivity

Zhilin Su, Mona M. Garvert, Lei Zhang, Todd A Vogel, Jo Cutler, Masud Husain, Sanjay Manohar, Patricia LockwoodPsyArXiv 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) has long been associated with economic and social decision-making in neuroimaging studies. Several debates question whether different ventromedial PFC (vmPFC) and dorsomedial PFC (dmPFC) regions have specific functions or whether there is a gradient supporting social and non-social cognition. Here, we tested an unusually large sample of rare participants with focal damage to mPFC (N = 33), individuals with lesions elsewhere (N = 17), and healthy controls (N = 71) (total N = 121). Participants completed a temporal discounting task to estimate their baseline discounting preferences before learning the preferences of two other people, one who was more temporally impulsive and one more patient. We used Bayesian computational models to estimate baseline discounting and susceptibility to social influence after learning others’ economic preferences. mPFC damage increased susceptibility to impulsive social influence compared to healthy controls and increased overall susceptibility to social influence compared to those with lesions elsewhere. Importantly, voxel-based lesion-symptom mapping (VLSM) of computational parameters showed that this heightened susceptibility to social influence was attributed specifically to damage to the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC, area 9). In contrast, lesions in the vmPFC (areas 13 and 25) and ventral striatum were associated with a preference for seeking more immediate rewards. We show that the dmPFC is causally implicated in susceptibility to social influence, with distinct ventral portions of mPFC involved in temporal discounting.

Introduction

The medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) is often described as the "Swiss Army Knife" of the social brain. Neuroimaging studies frequently show activation in this region during tasks ranging from simple economic valuation to complex social perspective-taking. However, a fundamental question remains: is the mPFC a functionally uniform region, or do its sub-regions—specifically the dorsomedial (dmPFC) and ventromedial (vmPFC) areas—serve distinct roles in social and non-social cognition? While fMRI identifies correlations, lesion studies are necessary to establish whether these regions are causally required for specific behaviors.

Methods and Patient Cohort

This study employed a "computational neurology" framework to investigate the functional organization of the mPFC. The researchers recruited a unique cohort of 121 participants, including 33 patients with focal mPFC lesions, 17 lesion controls (damage outside the mPFC), and 71 healthy controls.

Lesion overlap maps for the mPFC group (a) and lesion control group (b).

Participants performed a temporal discounting task, choosing between smaller-sooner rewards (e.g., £10 today) and larger-later rewards (e.g., £18 in 6 weeks). After establishing baseline preferences, participants observed the choices of two simulated social models—one impulsive and one patient—before repeating the task. To analyze the data, the team used a Bayesian hyperbolic preference-uncertainty (KU) model to separate core impulsivity from choice uncertainty. Finally, Voxel-based Lesion-Symptom Mapping (VLSM) was used to correlate specific voxels of brain damage with behavioral changes.

Results: A Functional Double Dissociation

The findings revealed a clear functional dissociation within the mPFC:

1. dmPFC and Social Susceptibility

Damage to the dmPFC (specifically Area 9) did not alter baseline impulsivity. Instead, it significantly increased susceptibility to social influence. These patients were more likely to shift their preferences toward the impulsive social model compared to controls ($p = 0.007$). This suggests the dmPFC acts as a "self-other" buffer; without it, individuals may struggle to maintain their own internal value compass when faced with external social information.

2. vmPFC and Baseline Impulsivity

In contrast, damage to the vmPFC (Areas 13 and 25) and the ventral striatum was associated with increased baseline temporal impulsivity—a steeper preference for immediate rewards ($p < 0.05$, exploratory). This supports the role of the ventral mPFC in "episodic future thinking," or the ability to mentally simulate and value future outcomes.

Importantly, all groups were equally capable of learning the social models' preferences. The increased susceptibility in dmPFC patients was not due to a failure to understand others, but rather an increased tendency to be swayed by them.

Discussion and Limitations

This research provides rare causal evidence that social influence and economic impulsivity are mediated by distinct anatomical regions within the mPFC. The dmPFC appears specialized for managing social information and maintaining self-other distinction, while the vmPFC is critical for the valuation of future rewards.

While the mPFC sample size is exceptionally large for this type of study, the number of patients with ventral striatum damage was smaller, making those specific findings more exploratory. Future research should investigate whether the dmPFC's role extends to other domains of social influence, such as moral or political decision-making.

Summary updated

Abstract

The medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) has long been associated with economic and social decision-making in neuroimaging studies. Several debates question whether different ventromedial PFC (vmPFC) and dorsomedial PFC (dmPFC) regions have specific functions or whether there is a gradient supporting social and non-social cognition. Here, we tested an unusually large sample of rare participants with focal damage to mPFC (N = 33), individuals with lesions elsewhere (N = 17), and healthy controls (N = 71) (total N = 121). Participants completed a temporal discounting task to estimate their baseline discounting preferences before learning the preferences of two other people, one who was more temporally impulsive and one more patient. We used Bayesian computational models to estimate baseline discounting and susceptibility to social influence after learning others’ economic preferences. mPFC damage increased susceptibility to impulsive social influence compared to healthy controls and increased overall susceptibility to social influence compared to those with lesions elsewhere. Importantly, voxel-based lesion-symptom mapping (VLSM) of computational parameters showed that this heightened susceptibility to social influence was attributed specifically to damage to the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC, area 9). In contrast, lesions in the vmPFC (areas 13 and 25) and ventral striatum were associated with a preference for seeking more immediate rewards. We show that the dmPFC is causally implicated in susceptibility to social influence, with distinct ventral portions of mPFC involved in temporal discounting.
BibTeX
@misc{su2024dorsomedial,
  author = {Zhilin Su and Mona M. Garvert and Lei Zhang and Todd A Vogel and Jo Cutler and Masud Husain and Sanjay Manohar and Patricia Lockwood},
  title = {{Dorsomedial and ventromedial prefrontal cortex lesions differentially impact social influence and temporal impulsivity}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.31234/osf.io/7dy9f},
  howpublished = {PsyArXiv},
}
Figure