Dopamine Increases a Value-Independent Gambling Propensity

Francesco Rigoli, Robb B. Rutledge, Benjamin Chew, Olga Therese Ousdal, Peter Dayan, Raymond J. DolanNeuropsychopharmacology 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that boosting dopamine levels specifically increases a person's inherent tendency to gamble, independent of the potential rewards or context. This suggests dopamine plays a direct role in modulating the "attractiveness" of risky choices, with implications for understanding addiction and other reward-related disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dopamine is known to be crucial for reward learning, but its precise role in ongoing behavior, particularly risk-taking, is less understood. While dopaminergic drugs are known to increase risk-taking, the underlying mechanisms are unclear. Researchers have proposed several possibilities: dopamine might increase a general propensity for risk (a "value-independent" effect), it might alter how we subjectively value different rewards, it could improve decision-making consistency (choice precision), or it might influence how we adapt to different reward distributions (value normalization). This paper aims to disentangle these possibilities by investigating how L-DOPA, a dopamine precursor, affects specific components of risk-taking behavior in a controlled experimental setting.

Methods

The researchers employed a double-blind, within-subjects design where healthy participants performed a gambling task on three separate occasions. In two of these sessions, participants received either L-DOPA or a placebo. The gambling task was specifically designed to allow for the disentanglement of several components of risk preference:

  • Baseline gambling propensity: An inherent tendency to gamble.
  • Value-dependent preference: A preference for gambling that scales with the amount or variance of potential rewards.
  • Value normalization: How participants adjust their choices based on the overall reward distribution in a given context.
  • Choice precision: The consistency of choices.

A computational model was used to characterize participants' choice behavior by estimating parameters related to these components. This model allowed for the quantitative assessment of how L-DOPA affected each aspect of risk-taking.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used data collected from human participants performing a gambling task.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dopamine's direct influence on "gamble-seeking": The most striking finding is that L-DOPA specifically boosted a baseline propensity to gamble, irrespective of the potential gains or losses. This suggests dopamine directly enhances the appeal of taking a risk itself, rather than just influencing how we evaluate the outcomes.
  • Independence of risk components: The study clearly demonstrated that the baseline gambling propensity is distinct from how individuals value different reward magnitudes or how they normalize choices based on context. This separation is crucial for understanding the nuanced role of dopamine.
  • Body weight as a mediator: The effect of L-DOPA on increased gambling was more pronounced in lower-weight participants. This highlights the importance of considering individual physiological factors when administering dopaminergic drugs, as it likely relates to drug dosage and brain concentration.
  • Stable individual risk preferences: The study found that individual risk preferences (gambling percentage, gambling slope, and contextual differences) were stable across sessions, suggesting they represent underlying traits rather than transient states.

Key Results

  • L-DOPA administration significantly increased the average gambling percentage in low-weight participants compared to placebo. This effect was not observed in high-weight participants.
  • This increase in average gambling was uncorrelated with the participants' gambling slope (preference for gambling based on EV) or their contextual differences (value normalization). This confirms that dopamine's effect was on the baseline propensity, not on how value or context influenced choices.
  • The gambling slope and contextual differences were stable across sessions and showed no significant drug-induced changes, indicating that L-DOPA did not alter these value-dependent aspects of risk-taking.
  • Choice precision measures also remained unaffected by L-DOPA.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small monetary amounts: The study used relatively small monetary incentives, and it's unclear if the observed effects would generalize to larger, more real-world stakes.
  • Incentive type: The study focused on monetary rewards. Future research could explore whether similar effects are observed with other incentives like food or drugs.
  • Dopamine dosage: The study used a single dose of L-DOPA. Given the known inverted U-shaped relationship between dopamine levels and cognitive function, future work could investigate multiple dosages to explore non-linear effects.
  • Phasic vs. Tonic Dopamine: It remains unclear whether L-DOPA's effects are primarily on phasic (burst) or tonic (baseline) dopamine activity. Techniques combining pharmacology with neuroimaging or electrophysiology could help address this.

Future work could also explore the implications of these findings for clinical populations with altered dopaminergic systems, such as those with addiction or Parkinson's disease, and investigate potential genetic biomarkers for risk-taking behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although the impact of dopamine on reward learning is well documented, its influence on other aspects of behavior remains the subject of much ongoing work. Dopaminergic drugs are known to increase risk-taking behavior, but the underlying mechanisms for this effect are not clear. We probed dopamine's role by examining the effect of its precursor L-DOPA on the choices of healthy human participants in an experimental paradigm that allowed particular components of risk to be distinguished. We show that choice behavior depended on a baseline (ie, value-independent) gambling propensity, a gambling preference scaling with the amount/variance, and a value normalization factor. Boosting dopamine levels specifically increased just the value-independent baseline gambling propensity, leaving the other components unaffected. Our results indicate that the influence of dopamine on choice behavior involves a specific modulation of the attractiveness of risky options-a finding with implications for understanding a range of reward-related psychopathologies including addiction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rigoli2016dopamine,
  author = {Francesco Rigoli and Robb B. Rutledge and Benjamin Chew and Olga Therese Ousdal and Peter Dayan and Raymond J. Dolan},
  title = {{Dopamine Increases a Value-Independent Gambling Propensity}},
  booktitle = {Neuropsychopharmacology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1038/npp.2016.68},
}
Figure