TL;DR
This paper investigates how the writing prompt influences argument mining in student essays. They found that training models on essays from the same prompt significantly improves performance compared to training on essays from different prompts, especially with limited data. This highlights the crucial role of topic-specific context in understanding student arguments.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Argument mining, the task of automatically identifying and classifying argumentative components (like claims, evidence, and conclusions) within text, is crucial for developing automated essay scoring and feedback systems. While existing work has explored argument mining across various domains (legal, political), it's unclear how much these models rely on general argumentative structures versus topic-specific language. Specifically, this paper asks: to what extent is argument mining "prompt-dependent," and how does training data from the same prompt versus different prompts affect performance? This is particularly relevant in educational settings where students write essays in response to diverse prompts.
Methods
The authors used a recently released dataset of student essays from the Kaggle "Feedback Prize" competition. They first employed topic modeling (Top2Vec) to cluster essays into underlying prompts, identifying 15 distinct topics. Their core methodology involved training and evaluating argument identification models under various conditions:
- Prompt-specific training: Models trained and tested on essays from the same prompt.
- Cross-prompt training: Models trained on essays from different prompts.
- Combined training: Models trained on all available prompts.
They also conducted experiments to disentangle the influence of topical words versus structural information by modifying the training and testing data (e.g., replacing topic words with "dummy" tokens or using part-of-speech tags). Their base model used a Longformer architecture, chosen for its ability to handle long sequences common in essays.
Datasets
The primary dataset used is the Kaggle "Feedback Prize - Evaluating Student Writing" dataset. This dataset contains 15,594 argumentative essays written by U.S. students in grades 6-12, with gold-standard annotations for argumentative elements. The authors also performed topic modeling on this dataset to infer underlying writing prompts, resulting in 15 identified clusters.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Prompt Matters (A Lot): The most significant finding is that training argument mining models on essays from the same prompt yields substantially better results than training on essays from different prompts, especially when the amount of training data is limited. This suggests that current argument mining models are not purely learning universal argumentative structures but are heavily influenced by the specific topic and language of the prompt.
- "Lead" and "Conclusion" are Easier: Argumentative elements like "lead" (introduction) and "concluding statement" are more reliably identified across different settings. This is attributed to their relatively fixed positional information within an essay.
- Topic vs. Structure Trade-off: When disentangling topical words from structural information, they found that argument mining benefits from both. However, within-prompt classification seems to lean more on topical information, while cross-prompt classification relies more on structural cues.
- Data Size Can Mitigate Prompt Specificity: While prompt-specific training is beneficial with limited data, the advantage can be overcome by using a very large amount of cross-prompt data. This implies that with enough diverse data, models can generalize better.
- Claims are Tricky: Surprisingly, "claim" and "evidence" (frequent labels) were not identified as precisely as "lead" and "conclusion." The authors hypothesize this is because claims lack consistent positional cues and are not always marked by clear discourse markers, unlike counterclaims and rebuttals which, despite being infrequent, showed better performance due to stronger discourse marker associations.
Key Results
- Prompt-Specific Training Advantage: With a fixed amount of training data (833 essays), prompt-specific training achieved an F1 score of .53, while training on other prompts (small) yielded .49.
- Large Cross-Prompt Data: Using a much larger cross-prompt dataset (9983 essays) resulted in an F1 score of .52, showing that sheer volume can compensate for lack of prompt specificity, though it didn't surpass the small prompt-specific set.
- All Prompts Performance: Training on all prompts (12481 essays) achieved the highest F1 score of .55, indicating that prompt-specific data can be slightly improved by adding generic cross-prompt data.
- Label Performance Variance: F1 scores varied significantly by label. "Lead" and "Concluding Statement" performed best, while "Rebuttal" performed worst. "Claim" also showed relatively poor performance.
- Modified Data Experiments: Models trained on modified data (e.g., structure-only or topic-only) performed significantly worse than models trained on original data, reinforcing the idea that both topical and structural information are vital.
Limitations and Future Work
- Topic Clustering Imperfections: The authors acknowledge that their topic clustering approach, while effective, might have introduced "artifacts" due to impure clusters, particularly for the "Extracurricular Activities" cluster.
- Practicality of Prompt-Specific Training: While beneficial, obtaining prompt-specific training data for every new essay prompt can be impractical and expensive in real-world educational settings.
- Future Research Directions:
- Learning Curve Studies: Investigating the optimal trade-off between topic-specific and generic training data.
- Formative Feedback Generation: Utilizing identified argumentative elements to provide targeted feedback to students, such as highlighting different components.
- Argument Quality Analysis: Analyzing discourse relations between argument components to offer feedback on essay coherence and cohesion.
Summary updated