Does the Nation Innovation System in China Support the Sustainability of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) Innovation?

Caiyan Jia, Shirley Tang, Zhehan KanSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether China's National Innovation System (NIS) effectively supports the sustainable innovation of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs). It finds that while SMEs significantly contribute to China's GDP growth, the NIS largely overlooks their specific needs, primarily due to a narrow definition of innovation and a top-down R&D system favoring large state-owned firms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, like many nations, aims for sustainable economic growth through innovation. A key component of this strategy is the National Innovation System (NIS), which aims to foster innovation across the economy. However, the role and support for Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) within this system are often unclear. SMEs are recognized as crucial drivers of economic growth and innovation, yet they face unique challenges compared to larger corporations. This paper addresses the critical question of whether China's NIS, as implemented through its policies, adequately supports the sustainability of innovation within its vast SME sector. The authors highlight a potential disconnect between the stated goals of the NIS and the actual policy landscape affecting SMEs, questioning if the system is truly designed to nurture long-term innovation in this vital segment of the economy.

Methods

The researchers employed a qualitative text analysis approach to examine Chinese SME innovation policies. They collected national government policy texts related to SMEs from 1994 to 2017, including SME yearbooks and government notices. These texts were then analyzed within the framework of China's NIS, considering the country's unique transition characteristics. The study also involved a comparative analysis with the innovation systems of other countries to contextualize China's approach. The analysis focused on identifying the components and characteristics of China's innovation policy as it pertains to SMEs and assessing how these policies align with the principles of sustainable innovation.

Datasets

The primary "dataset" for this study consists of national government policy texts related to SMEs in China, collected from 1994 to 2017. This includes:

  • Yearbooks of Chinese SMEs (1999-2017)
  • Government notices (1994-2017)

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather analyzes existing policy documents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SMEs are economic powerhouses, but policy is misaligned: Despite SMEs contributing significantly to China's GDP, tax revenue, and employment, the national innovation policies do not adequately reflect their specific needs or foster their sustainable innovation.
  • NIS definition is too narrow: The current understanding and implementation of China's NIS tend to focus narrowly on R&D and high-tech industries, neglecting the broader innovation activities, learning-by-doing, and diffusion processes that are critical for SMEs.
  • Top-down system favors large firms: China's R&D system is heavily influenced by a top-down, government-oriented approach that prioritizes large state-owned enterprises, leaving little room or tailored support for SME innovation.
  • Policy fragmentation and lack of legal backing: SME innovation policies are scattered across various opinions and notices, lacking a specialized legal framework. This fragmentation hinders effective coordination and implementation.
  • Financial policies dominate, but social capital is overlooked: While financial policies constitute a large portion of SME-related policies, they often rely on traditional credit guarantees and government funds, neglecting the crucial role of social capital inflow and financial service innovation.
  • Human resource policies focus on employment, not development: Policies related to human resources for SMEs primarily aim to increase employment rather than investing in professional training and development, which are essential for sustainable innovation.

Key Results

The study's findings indicate that China's NIS pays insufficient attention to the sustainability of SME innovation activities. This is attributed to two main reasons:

  1. Narrow Scope of NIS: The NIS is defined too narrowly, focusing on R&D and high-tech sectors, thereby marginalizing SMEs and their innovation models.
  2. Government-Oriented R&D System: The dominant top-down, government-driven R&D system, which favors large state-owned firms, leaves limited space for policies specifically designed for SMEs.

The analysis of policy texts revealed that financial policies are the most prevalent (43%), followed by business innovation support (15%). However, the specific focus within financial policies is on loan and credit guarantees (35%), tax (17%), and financial development (14%), with less emphasis on venture capital or listing. Human resource policies are notably scarce, with only four policy texts identified, suggesting a focus on employment rather than skill development. Legal policies are also limited, with only five laws directly applicable to SMEs, representing a mere 2% of all policy texts.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that China's innovation policy system is still in a transitional phase, exhibiting features of a transition period. They note that innovation activities in SMEs are often situated between economic and technological policies, rather than constituting an independent system. The formulation of SME innovation policies often reflects an "inertia logic" of copying national policies without fully adapting them to SME-specific needs.

Future work should focus on developing independent innovation policies for SMEs under the NIS framework to foster an innovative nation. This includes:

  • Establishing basic laws and specific regulations tailored to SMEs.
  • Improving the Sci-Tech innovation board (STAR Market) system to facilitate SMEs' access to capital markets and optimize their financing environment.
  • Ensuring the authority and independence of policymaking bodies and developing effective government management and support systems.
  • Encouraging practical innovation modes for SMEs and paying attention to detailed finance, commercial services, and human resource development measures.
  • Guiding public R&D investment to build a public knowledge database.

The paper also suggests that the evolution of China's technology policy objectives needs to adapt to the requirements of economic development, focusing on independent innovation and considering the diffusion and sustainability of R&D, not just its creation.

Summary updated

Abstract

To maintain sustainable economic growth, China has created a national innovation system (NIS) and strengthened the central status of firms. Our data show that the effect of turnover growth in small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) on China’s aggregate Gross Domestic Product (GDP)growth is significant, but the status of SMEs in the NIS and related policies is not significant. To determine whether there is a correspondence between the sustainability of innovation in SMEs and the support of China’s NIS, we developed a framework for China’s innovation policy under the NIS framework, taking into account its transition characteristics, to examine the texts of SME innovation policies and reveal the sustainability of SMEs’ innovation. The relevant national government policy texts were collected from the yearbooks of Chinese SMEs between 1999 and 2017 and government notices between 1994 and 2017. On this basis, we also compared with some other countries’ innovation systems. The findings indicate that China’s NIS pays little attention to the sustainability of SMEs’ innovation activities for two reasons. First, the scope of the NIS is very narrowly defined. Second, the top-down, government-oriented Research and Development (R&D) system that focuses on large state-owned firms leaves little room for innovation policies in SMEs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jia2020does,
  author = {Caiyan Jia and Shirley Tang and Zhehan Kan},
  title = {{Does the Nation Innovation System in China Support the Sustainability of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) Innovation?}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12062562},
}
Figure