Does the “Belt and Road Initiative” Promote the Economic Growth of Participating Countries?

Qipeng Sun, Xiaodong Zhang, Xiaoqing Eleanor Xu, Qi Yang, Sijie WangSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the economic impact of China's "Belt and Road Initiative" (BRI) on participating countries. Using a sophisticated econometric approach (PSM-DID), the study finds that the BRI has significantly boosted the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of these nations, but has not shown a statistically significant impact on per capita GDP growth. This suggests the BRI is effective at increasing overall economic output, but the benefits are not yet translating into widespread individual prosperity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In an era of slowing global economic growth, stimulating economies is a critical challenge. China's "Belt and Road Initiative" (BRI), a massive global infrastructure and economic development strategy, has emerged as a potential solution. However, despite its widespread adoption and significant investment, there's been a need for rigorous, objective evaluation of its actual economic impact on participating countries. This paper aims to fill that gap by quantifying whether the BRI truly promotes economic growth, identifying which aspects are most effective, and highlighting areas for improvement.

Methods

The study employs a Propensity Score Matching-Difference-in-Differences (PSM-DID) methodology. This is a robust approach for evaluating policy interventions, especially when a perfect control group is hard to establish.

  1. Difference-in-Differences (DID): This standard technique compares the change in outcomes (economic growth) for a "treatment group" (BRI participating countries) before and after the intervention, against the change in outcomes for a "control group" (non-participating countries) over the same period. This helps isolate the policy's effect from general economic trends.
  2. Propensity Score Matching (PSM): A key challenge with DID is the "common trend" assumption – that both groups would have followed similar growth trajectories without the intervention. PSM addresses this by creating a more comparable control group. It uses observable characteristics to estimate the probability (propensity score) of a country participating in the BRI. Countries with similar propensity scores are then matched, creating a control group that more closely resembles the treatment group in terms of pre-intervention characteristics.
  3. Lagged Effects and Robustness Tests: The study also incorporates a hysteresis effect test to examine the delayed impact of the BRI and conducts robustness tests to ensure the findings are consistent across different model specifications.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from 110 countries spanning the years 2011 to 2016. The primary data sources are:

  • World Bank database: For economic indicators like GDP and per capita GDP.
  • United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO): For educational data.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GDP Growth Driver: The BRI appears to be a significant catalyst for increasing the overall economic output (GDP) of participating nations. This suggests that the large-scale infrastructure investments and trade facilitation efforts are effectively boosting national economies.
  • Per Capita GDP Stagnation: Despite overall GDP growth, the impact on per capita GDP is not statistically significant. This is a crucial finding, indicating that while the economic pie is getting larger, the slices for individuals are not necessarily growing proportionally. This could be due to factors like population growth, uneven distribution of wealth, or the nature of the economic activities being promoted.
  • Infrastructure Focus: The study highlights that most BRI projects involve infrastructure construction. While this can quickly boost GDP, it takes time for these investments to translate into tangible improvements in individual living standards.
  • "Crowding Out" Effect: The paper suggests that the BRI might be causing a "crowding out" effect, where focus on infrastructure and short-term gains might overshadow investments in human capital, education, and technological innovation, which are crucial for long-term, sustainable per capita growth.
  • Policy Environment Matters: The effectiveness of the BRI is influenced by the broader policy environment, including legal frameworks and institutional support. Differences in national laws and regulations can hinder smooth implementation.

Key Results

  • The "Belt and Road" Initiative has effectively promoted the rapid growth of the GDP of participating countries.
  • The improvement of per capita GDP growth is not significant.
  • Control variables like industrialization, foreign direct investment, and tertiary industry development were found to be positively correlated with economic growth, while import/export volume and education level showed a negative correlation in some analyses.
  • The study found that while the BRI positively affects trade import and export, its effect on other economic factors is either not visible or has an "extrusion effect" (meaning it might suppress other positive effects).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Short Implementation Time: The BRI is a relatively new initiative, and the data collection period (up to 2016) is short. Longer-term data is needed for a more comprehensive evaluation of its final effects.
  • Selected Variables: The analysis is based on a specific set of variables, and other factors, particularly political aspects, which are difficult to quantify, could influence the results.
  • Data Limitations: The authors note that the effect of the policy is also affected by political aspects, which cannot be quantified, thus impacting the analysis.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest that future research should aim to develop more data and indicators to provide a more nuanced evaluation of the BRI's policy effects. They also emphasize the need to address the "crowding out" effect and foster a more comprehensive approach that includes human capital development and a supportive policy environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the slowdown of global economic growth, how to stimulate economic growth has become a hot topic in recent years. The “Belt and Road (B&R) Initiative,” as a newly proposed global economic stimulus plan, has attracted widespread attention from scholars. In this study, the research used the propensity score matching difference in difference (PSM-DID) method to evaluate whether the “B&R” Initiative has promoted the economic growth of the countries along the route. Objectively assessing the effect of its implementation is not only important for its completion and improvement in the future but also to verify whether the “B&R” Initiative promotes economic growth in participating countries. A logistic regression is constructed using the statistical data obtained by the World Bank on 110 countries from 2011 to 2016. The results show that the “B&R” Initiative has effectively promoted the rapid growth of the GDP of participating countries but the improvement of per capita GDP growth is not significant. Through the analysis of the selected variables, corresponding policy recommendations are proposed. Moreover, objective proofs are provided to encourage all the countries in the world to participate in the “B&R” Initiative.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2019does,
  author = {Qipeng Sun and Xiaodong Zhang and Xiaoqing Eleanor Xu and Qi Yang and Sijie Wang},
  title = {{Does the “Belt and Road Initiative” Promote the Economic Growth of Participating Countries?}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11195240},
}
Figure