Does Sacral Slanting Affect Distal Adding-on in Lenke Type 1A Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis?

Yoon Suk Joo, Chang Ju Hwang, Jae Hwan Cho, Jong-Min Baik, Nam Ik Cho, Dong‐Ho Lee, Mi Young Lee, So Jung Yoon, Choon Sung LeeSpine 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether sacral slanting, a common finding in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS), contributes to "distal adding-on," a postoperative complication where the spine continues to curve below the fused segment. The research found that while the overall size of the lumbar curve is a primary risk factor, sacral slanting, particularly in the L4-R curve type, can influence the choice of fusion level, potentially leading to this complication.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) is a complex spinal deformity that often requires surgical correction. A common surgical approach involves fusing a portion of the spine to correct the curvature. However, a known complication is "distal adding-on," where the spine continues to curve and deform below the fused segment after surgery. This is particularly problematic in Lenke type 1A curves, which are characterized by a single thoracic curve with compensatory lumbar curves. The challenge lies in determining the optimal distal fusion level to prevent this postoperative progression while preserving as much spinal mobility as possible. While various factors are known to influence distal adding-on, the specific role of "sacral slanting" – an abnormal tilt of the sacrum – in this context remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by examining the correlation between sacral slanting and distal adding-on in Lenke type 1A AIS.

Methods

This was a retrospective clinical study involving 126 consecutive patients diagnosed with Lenke type 1A adolescent idiopathic scoliosis who underwent posterior correction and fusion surgery. The researchers categorized patients into two main groups: those who developed distal adding-on postoperatively and those who did not. They further subcategorized the Lenke type 1A curves based on the direction of the L4 vertebral tilt: L4-left (L4-L) and L4-right (L4-R).

Key clinical and radiological parameters were meticulously collected and analyzed. These included:

  • Sacral Slanting: Measured as the angle between the upper endplate of the sacrum and the horizontal line on standing anteroposterior radiographs. A threshold of 3 degrees or more was used to define sacral slanting.
  • Distal Adding-on: Defined by a progressive increase in the number of vertebrae involved in the primary curve distally, coupled with either a significant increase in the deviation of the first vertebra below the instrumentation from the center sacral vertical line (CSVL) or an increase in angulation of the first disc below the instrumentation.
  • Fusion Levels: Parameters like the last touching vertebra (LTV), neutral vertebra (NV), stable vertebra (SV), end vertebra (EV), and lowest instrumented vertebra (LIV) were identified.
  • Other Radiographic Measures: Lumbar and thoracic Cobb angles, deviations from the CSVL (C7-CSVL, LIV-CSVL, LIV+1-CSVL), disc wedging, shoulder height difference, and clavicle angle were also assessed.

Statistical analyses, including the Mann-Whitney U test and chi-square test, were employed to compare demographic and radiological parameters between the adding-on and non-adding-on groups. Logistic regression analysis was used to identify independent risk factors for adding-on. Subgroup analyses were performed for the L4-L and L4-R groups to understand differential effects.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective data from 126 patients diagnosed with Lenke type 1A adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. These data were collected from patients' medical records and the Picture Archiving and Communication System at a single institute. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sacral Slanting is Directional: The study confirmed that sacral slanting is not random. It typically occurs to the left in L4-L type curves and to the right in L4-R type curves, aligning with previous observations linking these to King type 3 and King type 4 curves, respectively.
  • Lumbar Curve Size is a Primary Driver: The preoperative lumbar Cobb angle emerged as a significant independent risk factor for distal adding-on, underscoring the importance of the overall magnitude of the compensatory curve.
  • Age Matters: Younger patients were found to have a higher probability of developing distal adding-on, suggesting that skeletal immaturity plays a role.
  • Sacral Slanting's Indirect Role in L4-R: While not a direct cause, right-sided sacral slanting in L4-R type curves appears to influence the selection of the distal fusion level. This can lead to a shorter fusion segment to preserve motion, which in turn increases the risk of adding-on. This is a crucial distinction – sacral slanting doesn't directly cause the adding-on but influences surgical decisions that can lead to it.
  • L4-L vs. L4-R Differences: The study highlighted that despite both being Lenke type 1A, L4-L and L4-R curves behave differently regarding adding-on and the influence of sacral slanting.

Key Results

  • Prevalence of Sacral Slanting: 28.6% of the 126 patients exhibited sacral slanting.
  • Adding-on Group Characteristics: The group with distal adding-on (n=13) was significantly younger than the group without adding-on (n=113).
  • Independent Risk Factor: The preoperative lumbar Cobb angle was identified as an independent risk factor for adding-on.
  • L4-R Subgroup Findings: In the L4-R subgroup, sacral slanting was associated with significant differences in preoperative slanting angle, LIV-CSVL, and LIV+1-CSVL. Furthermore, the LTV level and LIV-LTV were significant variables, indicating that adding-on patients tended to have a lower LTV and shorter fusion levels.
  • Sacral Slanting Direction: 19 out of 20 L4-L patients with sacral slanting had left-sided slanting, and 12 out of 16 L4-R patients had right-sided slanting.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Short Follow-up Time: The study's follow-up period of at least 2 years might not be sufficient to capture long-term outcomes. They suggest that longer follow-ups, potentially until patients reach their twenties, are needed.
  • Measurement Inaccuracies: Blurring of the sacral surface or changes in pelvic position could have introduced errors in measurements.
  • Confounding Factors: Sacral/pelvic rotation and leg length discrepancy could contribute to sacral slanting, and standardization of radiographs is recommended for precise evaluation.
  • Small L4-R Subgroup: The small sample size in the L4-R subgroup limited the ability to perform logistic regression analysis for this specific group.

Future work should focus on longer-term prospective studies with larger sample sizes to confirm these findings and to better understand the optimal surgical strategies for preventing distal adding-on, especially in the context of sacral slanting in L4-R type curves. Determining the balance between preventing adding-on and preserving motion segments remains a critical challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

4.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{joo2018does,
  author = {Yoon Suk Joo and Chang Ju Hwang and Jae Hwan Cho and Jong-Min Baik and Nam Ik Cho and Dong‐Ho Lee and Mi Young Lee and So Jung Yoon and Choon Sung Lee},
  title = {{Does Sacral Slanting Affect Distal Adding-on in Lenke Type 1A Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis?}},
  booktitle = {Spine},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1097/brs.0000000000002722},
}
Figure