Does Robot Assisted Laparoscopy (RAL) Have an Advantage in Preservation of Ovarian Reserve in Endometriosis Surgery? Comparison of Single-Port Access (SPA) RAL and SPA Laparoscopy

Jun-Hyeok Kang, Chi‐Son Chang, Joseph J. Noh, Tae‐Joong KimJournal of Clinical Medicine 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether robot-assisted laparoscopy (RAL) offers better ovarian reserve preservation than single-port access (SPA) laparoscopy for endometriosis surgery. While both methods showed similar overall ovarian function decline, RAL demonstrated an advantage in preserving ovarian reserve for patients with mild endometriosis and those undergoing less complex procedures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Endometriosis, a common gynecological condition, can negatively impact ovarian reserve, leading to fertility issues and reduced quality of life for reproductive-aged women. Surgical intervention is often necessary to remove lesions and restore pelvic anatomy. Minimally invasive techniques like single-port access (SPA) laparoscopy are favored for their cosmetic benefits and reduced recovery time. However, SPA laparoscopy can be technically challenging, potentially leading to rougher surgical actions that might compromise ovarian function. Robot-assisted laparoscopy (RAL), with its enhanced precision and visualization, is emerging as an alternative. This paper aims to determine if SPA RAL, a more advanced technique, offers superior preservation of ovarian reserve compared to standard SPA laparoscopy in endometriosis surgery, and to identify factors influencing ovarian function decline post-surgery.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective review of 165 patients diagnosed with endometriosis who underwent either SPA laparoscopy (n=87) or SPA robot-assisted laparoscopy (RAL) (n=78) between January 2016 and December 2021. They collected baseline patient characteristics, including endometriosis severity (using the AAGL classification), and surgical outcomes such as operative time, estimated blood loss, and surgical complexity (categorized as non-complex or complex).

To assess ovarian reserve preservation, serum anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) levels were measured before surgery, at two weeks post-surgery, and at three months post-surgery. AMH is a key biomarker for ovarian reserve. The rate of AMH reduction was calculated to quantify the decline in ovarian function. Statistical analyses, including univariate and multivariate linear regression, were used to identify factors associated with AMH reduction and to compare the outcomes between the two surgical approaches.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective clinical data from 165 patients treated at Samsung Medical Center. The primary dataset comprised patient demographics, endometriosis severity, surgical details, and serial AMH measurements. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RAL shows promise for specific patient groups: While not universally superior, RAL demonstrated a statistically significant advantage in preserving ovarian reserve for patients with mild endometriosis (AAGL stages I/II) and those undergoing non-complex surgeries. This suggests that the enhanced precision of robotic surgery may be particularly beneficial when extensive adhesiolysis or complex dissection is not required.
  • Ovarian function decline is multifactorial: The study reinforces that ovarian reserve is influenced by several factors beyond the surgical approach. Age, ovarian cyst size, cyst location, the severity of endometriosis, and surgical complexity all independently contributed to a greater reduction in AMH levels post-surgery.
  • SPA laparoscopy's technical challenges might impact ovarian reserve: The paper speculates that the instrument conflicts and less ergonomic positioning inherent in SPA laparoscopy could lead to rougher surgical actions, potentially contributing to ovarian function decline, as suggested by previous research.
  • RAL's complexity and cost are considerations: Despite potential benefits, the study acknowledges that RAL is generally more expensive and can involve longer operative times, especially in complex cases, which are important factors for clinical decision-making.

Key Results

  • No overall difference in AMH reduction: Across all patients, there was no statistically significant difference in the rate of AMH reduction at 2 weeks or 3 months post-surgery between SPA laparoscopy and SPA RAL.
  • RAL beneficial for mild endometriosis: Patients with mild endometriosis (stage I/II) undergoing RAL showed a significantly lower AMH reduction rate at 3 months (23.58% ± 14.98%) compared to those undergoing SPA laparoscopy (33.51% ± 19.98%, p=0.04).
  • RAL beneficial for non-complex surgery: Similarly, patients undergoing non-complex surgery with RAL experienced less AMH reduction (22.37% ± 17.49%) compared to SPA laparoscopy (37.89% ± 22.37%, p=0.022).
  • Operative time longer with RAL: The mean operative time was significantly longer for the RAL group (167.9 ± 63.5 min) compared to the SPA laparoscopy group (93.7 ± 27.5 min, p < 0.001).
  • Complex surgery more frequent in RAL: The RAL group had a higher proportion of complex surgeries (83.3%) compared to the SPA laparoscopy group (50.6%, p=0.045).
  • Risk factors for AMH decline: Age, ovarian cyst size, cyst location, surgical complexity, and severity of endometriosis were all significantly associated with a greater decrease in AMH levels.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective design: The study was retrospective, not a prospective randomized controlled trial, which limits definitive causal conclusions.
  • Small sample size and short follow-up: The relatively small number of patients and a short follow-up period (3 months) mean that long-term outcomes like pregnancy rates or menopause age could not be assessed.
  • Cost and accessibility: The study did not consider the cost-effectiveness or accessibility of RAL, which are crucial for widespread adoption.
  • Trocar usage in RAL: While SPA RAL was the primary approach, additional robotic trocars were used in complex cases, meaning a strict comparison of single-port versus single-port might not always hold true for the RAL group.

Future work should focus on prospective, randomized controlled trials to further validate these findings. More research is needed to understand the exact role of RAL in severe endometriosis cases and to comprehensively evaluate its benefits, considering factors like cost and long-term patient outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to compare single-port access (SPA) laparoscopy and SPA robot assisted laparoscopy (RAL) for endometriosis with respect to ovarian reserve preservation and surgical outcomes. Clinical factors affecting any reduction in ovarian function after surgery were also evaluated. Patients with endometriosis who underwent SPA laparoscopy (n = 87) or RAL (n = 78) were retrospectively reviewed. Patients' baseline characteristics, including the severity of endometriosis and surgical outcomes including surgical complexity, were collected. To assess the preservation of ovarian reserve after surgery, serum anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) levels before surgery, at two weeks, and at three months after surgery were collected. Age, ovarian cyst size, location of cyst, complexity of surgery, and the severity of endometriosis were associated with the reduction in AMH levels after surgery. The severity of endometriosis was higher in the RAL group than in the SPA group. There were no significant differences in other clinical baseline characteristics, including preoperative AMH levels. For surgical outcomes, radical surgery was more frequently performed in the RAL group. In univariate and multivariate linear regression analyses, age, ovarian cyst size, location of cyst, complexity of surgery, and the severity of endometriosis were associated with the reduction in AMH levels after surgery. Incorporating surgical approaches and risk factors for postoperative ovarian function decrease, RAL was more beneficial than SPA laparoscopy for the preservation of ovarian reserve in patients with mild endometriosis (stage I/II) (postoperative 3 month AMH reduction rate (%), SPA laparoscopy vs. RAL, 33.51 ± 19.98 vs. 23.58 ± 14.98, <i>p</i> = 0.04) and in patients who underwent non-complex surgery (postoperative 3 month AMH reduction rate (%), SPA laparoscopy vs. RAL, 37.89 ± 22.37 vs. 22.37 ± 17.49, <i>p</i> = 0.022). SPA RAL may have advantages over SPA laparoscopy in ovarian function preservation, especially in patients with mild endometriosis and patients who have undergone a non-complex surgery.
BibTeX
@article{kang2023does,
  author = {Jun-Hyeok Kang and Chi‐Son Chang and Joseph J. Noh and Tae‐Joong Kim},
  title = {{Does Robot Assisted Laparoscopy (RAL) Have an Advantage in Preservation of Ovarian Reserve in Endometriosis Surgery? Comparison of Single-Port Access (SPA) RAL and SPA Laparoscopy}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm12144673},
}
Figure