Does Person–Organization Value Fit Affect Job Performance of Post-90s Employees in China? A Moderated Mediation Model Based on Self-Determination Theory

Yanzhi Liu, Yi He, Rong CaoSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores how aligning an employee's values with their organization's values (PO value fit) impacts job performance, particularly for China's post-90s generation. It reveals that this fit boosts performance through increased happiness, but this effect is weakened in employees with a high "love of money" (LOM).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The post-90s generation in China presents a unique challenge for management. While often seen as innovative and self-aware, they are also characterized by lower work motivation and a weaker sense of collective consciousness, making it difficult to enhance their job performance. Existing research on Person-Organization (PO) value fit shows a positive link to performance, but it doesn't fully explain the psychological drivers behind this for this specific demographic. This paper aims to bridge that gap by investigating the mediating role of happiness and the moderating role of "love of money" (LOM) in the PO value fit-job performance relationship, grounded in Self-Determination Theory (SDT).

Methods

The study employed a quantitative approach using survey data. Key statistical methods included:

  • Linear Regression Analysis: Used to test the direct and indirect effects of PO value fit on job performance, with happiness as a mediator.
  • Bootstrapping Approach: A resampling technique used to estimate the significance and confidence intervals of indirect effects, crucial for mediation analysis.
  • Hierarchical Regression Analysis: Employed to test the moderating effect of LOM on the relationship between happiness and job performance.
  • Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA): Conducted to ensure the measurement model fit the data well and to establish the validity of the constructs.
  • Item-Parceling Technique: Used to reduce the number of items in the measurement model for CFA, improving model fit.
  • Grand-Mean Centering: Applied to interaction terms to mitigate multicollinearity issues in regression analysis.
  • Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) Test: Used to check for multicollinearity among variables.
  • PROCESS Program: A statistical tool used for moderated mediation analysis, providing robust estimates of conditional indirect effects.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 919 post-90s employees in China from various industries. The data was gathered through online questionnaires distributed via Sojump and the snowball method. Participants' anonymity and confidentiality were assured.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Happiness as a Bridge: The study highlights that PO value fit doesn't directly translate to job performance for post-90s employees; it's happiness that acts as the crucial intermediary. When employees feel their values align with their organization's, they experience greater happiness, which in turn fuels better job performance.
  • The Double-Edged Sword of "Love of Money": While money is a significant motivator, a high "love of money" (LOM) can actually undermine the positive impact of happiness on job performance. For individuals with high LOM, even if they are happy, their happiness has a less pronounced effect on their work output.
  • SDT as a Framework: Self-Determination Theory provides a robust lens to understand these dynamics, emphasizing the importance of autonomy, competence, and relatedness for employee motivation and well-being. PO value fit supports these needs, leading to happiness and better performance.

Key Results

  • PO Value Fit and Job Performance: A positive and significant relationship was found between PO value fit and job performance.
  • Mediating Role of Happiness: Happiness was found to partially mediate the relationship between PO value fit and job performance. Employees with better PO value fit reported higher happiness, leading to improved job performance.
  • Moderating Role of LOM: Love of Money (LOM) significantly moderated the indirect effect of PO value fit on job performance through happiness. Specifically, the positive impact of happiness on job performance was weaker for employees with higher levels of LOM.
  • The indirect effect of PO value fit on job performance via happiness was weaker for high LOM employees compared to low LOM employees.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Causality: The correlational nature of the study means causality cannot be definitively established. Future research could employ experimental designs or longitudinal data.
  • Self-Report Bias: All data was collected via self-report, which can be subjective. Future studies could incorporate supervisor ratings for job performance.
  • Objective Pay Ignored: The study focused on subjective LOM. Future research could explore the impact of objective pay levels on these relationships.
  • Global vs. Job Happiness: The study used global happiness. Future work could investigate the role of job-specific happiness.
  • Post-90s Focus: The study was limited to post-90s employees. Future research should include other generations to examine the effects of age and tenure more broadly.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nowadays, post-90s employees are becoming the main cohort within organizations in China. They are considered to have strong self-awareness, weak collective consciousness, and low work motivation, making it difficult for managers to improve their job performance. After reviewing the relevant literature, we found that person–organization (PO) value fit is positively related to job performance, but there is a limitation in explaining the psychological characteristics of post-90s employees. This study aims to explore the mechanism that how PO value fit impacts the job performance of post-90s employees in China. From the view of self-determination theory (SDT), we selected happiness as a mediating variable and love of money (LOM) as a moderating variable. Based on valid data collected from 919 employees from all walks of life in China, we utilized both linear regression analysis and a bootstrapping approach to verify our propositions. The results revealed a positive relationship between PO value fit and job performance through happiness. The moderated mediation analysis further indicated that the mediated path bonding happiness with job performance was weaker for post-90s employees with higher levels of LOM. The present study offers a nuanced interpretation of how PO value fit affects the job performance of post-90s employees in China and contributes to providing suggestions for improving the sustainability of organizations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023does,
  author = {Yanzhi Liu and Yi He and Rong Cao},
  title = {{Does Person–Organization Value Fit Affect Job Performance of Post-90s Employees in China? A Moderated Mediation Model Based on Self-Determination Theory}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15031931},
}
Figure