Does or Did the Supernova Remnant Cassiopeia A Operate as a PeVatron?

Z. Cao, F. Aharonian, Q. An, Axikegu, Y.x Bai, Yiwang Bao, D. Bastieri, Xiao-Jun Bi, Y.j Bi, J. T. Cai, Qing Cao, W.y Cao, J. Chang, A.m Chen, E. S. Chen, Liang Chen, Lin Chen, Long Chen, M.j Chen, M.l Chen, Qin Chen, Shaw H. Chen, T. L. Chen, Yang Chen, Ning Cheng, Y.d Cheng, Maxwell Cui, S. W. Cui, X.h Cui, Yongde Cui, B. Z. Dai, H. L. Dai, Z. G. Dai, Danzengluobu Danzengluobu, D. della Volpe, X.q Dong, K. K. Duan, Junhui Fan, Yi-Zhong Fan, Jun Fang, Kun Fang, C.f Feng, Li Feng, F. Shi, X.t Feng, Yulong Feng, S. Gabici, Bo Gao, Chuyue Gao, L. Q. Gao, Qi Gao, Wei Gao, M.m Ge, Li‐Sheng Geng, Gwenael Giacinti, G. Gong, Q. B. Gou, M. H. Gu, Fulai Guo, Xu Guo, Yi-Qing Guo, Yong Guo, Y.a Han, H.h He, Hongbin He, Jiangbiao He, Xiao-Rong He, Y. He, Matthieu Heller, Y. K. Hor, Bowen Hou, C. Hou, X. T. Hou, H.b Hu, Qiang Hu, S. C. Hu, D.h Huang, T.q Huang, Weidong Huang, X. T. Huang, Yumin Huang, Zhongjie Huang, X. L. Ji, H.y Jia, Ke Jia, K. Jiang, Xiaojun Jiang, Z.j Jiang, Mingzhou Jin, M. M. Kang, T. Ke, D. Kuleshov, K. Kurinov, Bing Li, Cheng LiThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2024 · DOI

Abstract

For decades, supernova remnants (SNRs) have been considered the prime sources of Galactic cosmic rays (CRs). But whether SNRs can accelerate CR protons to PeV energies and thus dominate CR flux up to the "knee" is currently under intensive theoretical and phenomenological debate. The direct test of the ability of SNRs to operate as CR PeVatrons can be provided by ultrahigh-energy (UHE; $E_\gamma \geq 100$ TeV) $\gamma$-rays. In this context, the historical SNR Cassiopeia A (Cas A) is considered one of the most promising targets for UHE observations. This paper presents the observation of Cas A and its vicinity by the LHAASO KM2A detector. The exceptional sensitivity of LHAASO KM2A in the UHE band, combined with the young age of Cas A, enabled us to derive stringent model-independent limits on the energy budget of UHE protons and nuclei accelerated by Cas A at any epoch after the explosion. The results challenge the prevailing paradigm that Cas A–type SNRs are major suppliers of PeV CRs in the Milky Way.

Introduction: The Search for Galactic PeVatrons

The origin of Galactic cosmic rays (CRs) remains one of the most enduring mysteries in high-energy astrophysics. The CR spectrum observed on Earth exhibits a distinct "knee" at approximately 3–4 PeV ($10^{15}$ eV), suggesting that the Milky Way must contain accelerators—dubbed "PeVatrons"—capable of reaching these extreme energies. For decades, the standard model has pointed to supernova remnants (SNRs) as the primary candidates.

Cassiopeia A (Cas A), a young (340-year-old) SNR located 3.4 kpc away, is a prime test case. It possesses the powerful shocks and intense magnetic fields theoretically required for PeV acceleration. However, previous observations in the TeV range showed a steep spectrum, hinting that acceleration might stall before reaching the PeV regime. To settle this, the LHAASO collaboration utilized the KM2A detector to search for the "smoking gun" of PeVatrons: ultra-high-energy (UHE) gamma rays produced when PeV protons collide with local gas.

Observations and Methods

The study employed the LHAASO KM2A (Kilometer Square Array), a massive ground-based observatory in China. KM2A is uniquely sensitive to gamma rays exceeding 100 TeV. The team analyzed data collected over 932 days (December 2019 to September 2022).

To interpret potential gamma-ray signals, researchers also mapped the surrounding environment using $^{12}$CO survey data from the Purple Mountain Observatory. This allowed them to determine the density of molecular gas, which acts as the target material for cosmic-ray interactions.

Figure 4: Test Statistic (TS) map of the Cas A region (left) and the molecular gas column density map (right) used to constrain cosmic ray energy budgets.

Key Results: The Silence of Cas A

Despite the high sensitivity of LHAASO KM2A, the search yielded no significant gamma-ray excess above 25 TeV or 100 TeV at the location of Cas A. This lack of detection allowed the team to set stringent, model-independent upper limits on the energy budget of high-energy protons accelerated by the SNR.

Key findings include:

  • Energy Budget Constraints: For a standard $E^{-2}$ proton injection spectrum, the upper limit on the energy budget for protons between 100–1000 TeV is $3.6 \times 10^{47}$ erg (assuming a gas density of $10 \text{ cm}^{-3}$).
  • Injection Rate: The total CR injection rate required to maintain the Galactic CR population is estimated at $1–3 \times 10^{41} \text{ erg/s}$. Cas A’s contribution is calculated to be less than 1% of the rate required if it were a major contributor to the CR flux near the knee.
  • Spectral Implications: The results rule out theoretical models suggesting the spectrum might flatten at higher energies. If Cas A contributes to PeV cosmic rays at all, its injection spectrum must be very "soft" (index $\Gamma > 2.4$), contradicting standard Diffusive Shock Acceleration (DSA) theory for young SNRs.

Discussion and Conclusion

The LHAASO results provide a significant challenge to the paradigm that Cas A-type SNRs are the primary sources of PeV Galactic cosmic rays. The derived upper limits are nearly two orders of magnitude lower than what standard models require.

While uncertainties remain regarding the exact gas density in the immediate vicinity of the SNR, the CO observations suggest a dense environment that reinforces these stringent limits. As LHAASO continues to accumulate data over the next decade, it will either provide a definitive detection or potentially force a complete abandonment of the SNR-PeVatron hypothesis for Cas A. For now, the search for the true engines of the Galactic "knee" may need to shift toward other candidates, such as massive star-forming regions or the Galactic Center.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract For decades, supernova remnants (SNRs) have been considered the prime sources of Galactic cosmic rays (CRs). But whether SNRs can accelerate CR protons to PeV energies and thus dominate CR flux up to the knee is currently under intensive theoretical and phenomenological debate. The direct test of the ability of SNRs to operate as CR PeVatrons can be provided by ultrahigh-energy (UHE; E γ ≥ 100 TeV) γ -rays. In this context, the historical SNR Cassiopeia A (Cas A) is considered one of the most promising targets for UHE observations. This paper presents the observation of Cas A and its vicinity by the LHAASO KM2A detector. The exceptional sensitivity of LHAASO KM2A in the UHE band, combined with the young age of Cas A, enabled us to derive stringent model-independent limits on the energy budget of UHE protons and nuclei accelerated by Cas A at any epoch after the explosion. The results challenge the prevailing paradigm that Cas A–type SNRs are major suppliers of PeV CRs in the Milky Way.
BibTeX
@article{cao2024does,
  author = {Z. Cao and F. Aharonian and Q. An and Axikegu and Y.X Bai and Yiwang Bao and D. Bastieri and Xiao-Jun Bi and Y.J Bi and J. T. Cai and Qing Cao and W.Y Cao and Zhe Cao and J. Chang and J. F. Chang and A.M Chen and E. S. Chen and Liang Chen and Lin Chen and Long Chen and M.J Chen and M.L Chen and Qin Chen and Shaw H. Chen and S. Z. Chen and T. L. Chen and Yang Chen and Ning Cheng and Y.D Cheng and Maxwell Cui and S. W. Cui and X.H Cui and Yongde Cui and B. Z. Dai and H. L. Dai and Z. G. Dai and Danzengluobu Danzengluobu and D. della Volpe and X.Q Dong and K. K. Duan and Junhui Fan and Yi-Zhong Fan and Jun Fang and Kun Fang and C.F Feng and Li Feng and F. Shi and X.T Feng and Yulong Feng and S. Gabici and Bo Gao and Chuyue Gao and L. Q. Gao and Qi Gao and Wei Gao and Wei Gao and M.M Ge and Li‐Sheng Geng and Gwenael Giacinti and G. Gong and Q. B. Gou and M. H. Gu and Fulai Guo and Xu Guo and Yi-Qing Guo and Yong Guo and Y.A Han and H.H He and Hongbin He and Jiangbiao He and Xiao-Rong He and Y. He and Matthieu Heller and Y. K. Hor and Bowen Hou and C. Hou and X. T. Hou and H.B Hu and Qiang Hu and S. C. Hu and D.H Huang and T.Q Huang and Weidong Huang and X. T. Huang and X.Y Huang and Yumin Huang and Zhongjie Huang and X. L. Ji and H.Y Jia and Ke Jia and K. Jiang and Xiaojun Jiang and Z.J Jiang and Mingzhou Jin and M. M. Kang and T. Ke and D. Kuleshov and K. Kurinov and Bing Li and Cheng Li},
  title = {{Does or Did the Supernova Remnant Cassiopeia A Operate as a PeVatron?}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/ad1d62},
}
Figure