Does Information Undermine Brand? Information Intermediary Use and Preference for Branded Web Retailers

Joel Waldfogel, Lu Chen2003 · DOI

Abstract

Investments in brand provide a method for vendors to signal reliability and quality to potential customers. Alternatively, third-party information regarding a retailer's existence and performance can serve a similar function, potentially undermining traditional brand equity. Using a 13-month panel dataset of 1998-99 Internet shopping behavior across 30,000 households, this study examines whether the use of information intermediaries (IIs) reduces preference for branded retailers. We find that users of price comparison sites reduce shopping at branded retailers by approximately 10%. Notably, sites providing reliability information (like BizRate) reduce Amazon shopping by 20%, suggesting that third-party information acts as a powerful substitute for brand-based trust.

Introduction: Brand as a Signal of Reliability

In the early landscape of e-commerce, a "brand" was more than just a logo; it served as a critical commitment device. When consumers faced uncertainty about whether a vendor would fulfill an order, protect their data, or handle returns, they gravitated toward established names like Amazon or major offline chains. These branded firms had significant reputations to protect, which served as a de facto guarantee of quality.

However, the rise of information intermediaries (IIs)—such as BizRate, DealTime, and mySimon—introduced a new variable. These platforms provided third-party verification of price and, crucially, vendor reliability. This paper investigates whether such information acts as a substitute for brand equity, effectively leveling the playing field for lesser-known, "unbranded" retailers.

Methodology and Data

The study utilizes a Media Metrix (MM) panel dataset covering December 1998 to December 1999, tracking the clickstream data of over 30,000 households and 22 million retail page visits.

To isolate the effect of information from individual consumer preferences (e.g., the possibility that "bargain hunters" naturally prefer unbranded sites), the researchers employed a fixed-effects regression model. This approach focuses on within-household variation, comparing a specific household's behavior before and after they began using an information intermediary.

A key challenge was "bundle intent"—the possibility that users visit comparison sites only when looking for specific product categories (like electronics) where brands might matter less. To address this, the authors defined a "choice set" for each intermediary based on the specific retail sites users visited immediately after leaving the II, ensuring the comparison was between relevant alternatives.

Key Findings: The Erosion of Brand Pull

The analysis reveals a significant shift in consumer behavior following the adoption of information tools:

  • General Brand Erosion: Households using any of the studied intermediaries reduced their visits to "known" branded retailers (including Amazon, catalog retailers, and offline chains) by roughly 10%.
  • The Reliability Premium: The impact was most pronounced for intermediaries that provided more than just price data. Users of BizRate, which included survey-based vendor reliability scores, reduced their Amazon shopping by 20% and visits to major offline chain storefronts by 18%.
  • Price vs. Trust: In contrast, users of pure price-comparison sites like DealTime and mySimon reduced their Amazon use by only 10%. This suggests that Amazon’s primary competitive advantage at the time was its reputation for reliability rather than its pricing.

Discussion and Implications

The results suggest that information intermediaries can indeed undermine the market power of established brands by reducing the "trust premium" those brands command. If third-party information can verify the reliability of a low-cost, unbranded vendor, the incentive to pay a premium for a "known" brand diminishes.

While these findings point toward a more competitive and less concentrated retail landscape, the modern internet presents a paradox: market concentration has increased despite the proliferation of information. This suggests that while information erodes the "reliability" aspect of brand, other factors—such as logistics (Prime), ecosystem lock-in, and data-driven personalization—may have created new forms of brand equity that are more resistant to the democratizing effects of information intermediaries.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that information is a powerful substitute for brand equity. By providing a "commitment device" for unbranded retailers, intermediaries allow consumers to venture beyond established names. For firm strategy, this implies that brands must provide value beyond mere reliability to maintain market share in an information-rich environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Investments in brand provide one method for vendors to become known and convince potential customers that vendors will deliver as promised.Alternatively, third-party information on retailers' existence, as well as whether they tend to keep their commitments can serve a similar function and may undermine investments in brand.This study uses a 13-month panel dataset on 1998-99 Internet shopping behavior and use of information intermediaries by over 30,000 households to examine whether information use undermines brand.We find that individuals who take up using price comparison sites reduce their shopping at a broad group of branded retailers by about a tenth.Users of pure price comparison sites, such as DealTime and mySimon, also reduce their Amazon use by about a tenth, while individuals using BizRate, which provides both price comparison and vendor reliability information, reduce their Amazon shopping by a fifth.The results have possible implications for both firm strategy and the evolution of market structure.If information weakens the pull of brand, then Internet retailing may grow less concentrated over time.
BibTeX
@misc{waldfogel2003does,
  author = {Joel Waldfogel and Lu Chen},
  title = {{Does Information Undermine Brand? Information Intermediary Use and Preference for Branded Web Retailers}},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.3386/w9942},
}
Figure