Does Information Pattern Affect Risk Perception of Food Safety? A National Survey in China

Guanghua Han, Yihong LiuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different information sources and demographic factors influence Chinese citizens' perceptions of food safety risks. It reveals that reliance on modern media and higher education levels are associated with greater perceived risk, while traditional media and face-to-face communication lead to lower risk perception.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Food safety has become a major concern in China, with a significant portion of the population expressing anxiety about potential risks. Understanding how people perceive these risks is crucial for developing effective communication strategies and policies. However, there's a need to explore how the patterns of information consumption, beyond just access, and demographic characteristics shape these perceptions. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the relationship between information source preferences, demographic factors, and perceived food safety risks in China.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using data from the 4th wave of the Asia Barometer Survey (4th ABSs), a large-scale, cross-sectional survey conducted in mainland China. They utilized multiple regression analysis, specifically ordinal logistic regression, to analyze the data. The study modeled perceived food safety risk as the dependent variable, with information source preferences and demographic factors (age, gender, education, location, family status, economic status) as independent variables. They built four models, progressively adding variable sets to assess their cumulative influence.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the 4th wave of the Asia Barometer Survey (4th ABSs), conducted in mainland China from July 2015 to March 2016. The survey included 6013 eligible samples, with 4068 completed, valid interviews from Chinese rural and urban residents aged 18 and above.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modern Media Amplifies Risk Perception: A significant finding is that individuals who rely on modern information sources like the internet, microblogs (Weibo), and WeChat tend to perceive higher food safety risks. This is attributed to the faster spread of negative information and rumors through these channels, which are less regulated than traditional media.
  • Face-to-Face Communication Dampens Risk Perception: Conversely, those who primarily engage in face-to-face communication for information perceive lower food safety risks. This is linked to the demographic profile of these individuals (often older, rural, and less educated) who may have different life experiences and concerns.
  • Education is a Double-Edged Sword: Higher levels of education are associated with a greater perception of food safety risks. This is likely due to increased awareness of food safety issues and a more scientific understanding of potential hazards.
  • Demographics Matter, But Not Always as Expected: While age and education significantly influence risk perception, gender and family income did not show a significant correlation in this study, contrary to some initial hypotheses. This suggests that in the Chinese context, these factors might be less influential than information consumption patterns and educational attainment.
  • Urban Dwellers Perceive Higher Risk: Residents from large-scale cities tend to have more negative attitudes towards food safety compared to those in rural areas, possibly due to greater exposure to information and a higher focus on food quality over price.

Key Results

  • Information Source Impact:
    • Reliance on Internet/Text/Weibo/WeChat was associated with a significantly lower probability of perceiving food as safe (higher risk).
  • Reliance on Face-to-Face communication was associated with a significantly higher probability of perceiving food as safe (lower risk).
  • Traditional media (TV, radio, newspapers, magazines) did not show a significant difference in risk perception compared to each other, but were generally associated with lower risk perception than modern media.
  • Demographic Impact:
    • Age: Older respondents were more likely to perceive food as safe (lower risk).
  • Education: Higher education levels (college and above) were associated with a lower probability of perceiving food as safe (higher risk).
  • Location: Residents in larger cities (Central City >1 Million, Regional City 0.1 Million to 1 Million) perceived higher risks compared to those in rural areas.
  • Gender, Family Income, and Underage Children: These factors did not show a statistically significant influence on food safety risk perception in the study's models.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge two main limitations:

  • Omitted Variables: The study did not account for all potential influencing factors, such as source credibility, message content, and the amount/quantity of information. They suggest future research should incorporate these psychometric paradigms (perceived benefit, trust, negative image, knowledge) to provide a more comprehensive explanation of food safety perceptions.
  • Perception vs. Behavior: While the study explores perceptions, it doesn't directly link them to actual food safety behaviors. Future work could investigate how these perceptions influence attitudes towards government, political participation, and social trust, offering a valuable avenue for research.

They also recommend that governing authorities strengthen their communication capacities by leveraging modern media while also utilizing traditional and face-to-face communication channels for regulations and public engagement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Examining the variances in the assessments of risk, as perceived by residents, facilitates the development of appropriate risk information communication strategies. This paper aims to identify the effects of information source patterns on perceived food safety risks based on demographic factors. A national survey was conducted to examine, by means of multiple regression analysis, the relationship between the public's perceived risks, demographic factors and information access. The study finds that residents' preferences for information sources have been empirically proven to significantly affect their perceptions of food safety. We also find that more educated young urban dwellers, as well as those without cohabitation experience, tend to perceive a higher level of risk with respect to food safety. In contrast to our expectations, gender, family income and family size are not significantly correlated with the perception of food safety risk. The findings help to explain residents' attitudes toward food safety administration and reactions to food hazards in the Chinese context. It is recommended that the governing authorities strengthen their communication capacities using modern communication media and make full use of traditional and face-to-face communications with respect to regulations.
BibTeX
@article{han2018does,
  author = {Guanghua Han and Yihong Liu},
  title = {{Does Information Pattern Affect Risk Perception of Food Safety? A National Survey in China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph15091935},
}
Figure