Does implementation of a paediatric asthma clinical practice guideline worksheet change clinical practice?

Johann Gildenhuys, Mark Lee, Geoffrey K. IsbisterInternational Journal of Emergency Medicine 2008 · DOI

Abstract

The study demonstrates that implementation of an asthma clinical practice guideline (CPG) worksheet in a tertiary paediatric emergency department (ED) resulted in modest changes in clinical practice, mainly by increasing clinician adherence to the guidelines.

Introduction

Despite the existence of robust, evidence-based guidelines for treating pediatric asthma, a significant "know-do" gap often persists in clinical settings. Clinicians frequently rely on "mindlines"—internalized personal habits and experiences—rather than consulting formal protocols. Modern evidence suggests that using metered-dose inhalers with spacers is often as effective as nebulizers, and that certain drugs like ipratropium should be used sparingly. This study investigates whether a low-tech intervention—a standardized worksheet integrated directly into the patient's chart—could bridge this gap in a tertiary pediatric emergency department.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective before-and-after study at John Hunter Children’s Hospital in Australia. They compared clinical data from two five-month periods: "Before" (2003) and "After" (2005) the worksheet's implementation. Data was extracted from the hospital's Patient Information Management System (PIMS) for children aged 2–16 years with an ICD-9 diagnosis of asthma.

Study population flow and inclusion criteria for the 2003 (pre-intervention) and 2005 (post-intervention) cohorts.

The Intervention

The core of the study was the development and implementation of a one-page "Paediatric Asthma Management" worksheet. This tool required clinicians to categorize asthma severity (Mild, Moderate, or Severe/Life-Threatening) based on specific physiological markers and then provided a corresponding, color-coded treatment pathway. Crucially, the worksheet was automatically printed and placed in the child's medical record upon a provisional diagnosis, making the guideline the "path of least resistance" for the attending physician.

The treatment pathway section of the clinical practice guideline worksheet, detailing medication and management by severity.

Key Results

The implementation of the worksheet led to several statistically significant shifts in clinical practice:

  • Improved Medication Choices: Spacer use for salbutamol increased from 17% to 26% ($p=0.015$), while the use of ipratropium (often overused in mild cases) dropped from 58% to 44% ($p=0.0029$).
  • Reduced Over-Testing: The ordering of chest X-rays—which are rarely indicated for simple asthma—fell from 48% to 31% ($p=0.0001$).
  • Enhanced Patient Disposition: The number of children provided with an ED asthma action plan doubled from 11% to 23% ($p=0.0003$).
  • Hospital Efficiency: Most strikingly, the hospital admission rate saw a substantial decrease from 55% to 37% ($p<0.0001$), potentially freeing up significant bed capacity.

Discussion and Limitations

The study highlights the power of "defaults" and "nudges" in clinical workflows. By making documentation a catalyst for assessment, the worksheet likely forced more rigorous clinical evaluation. However, even with the intervention, only about 50% of charts showed documented use of the guidelines, suggesting that "mindlines" remain resistant to change.

Limitations include the retrospective design, which cannot definitively prove causation, and the potential for a Hawthorne effect due to the presence of a project officer. Future research should investigate moving these worksheets into Electronic Medical Record (EMR) systems while maintaining the "nudge" factor, alongside formal economic analyses to evaluate cost-savings from reduced testing and admissions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study demonstrates that implementation of an asthma CPG worksheet in a tertiary paediatric ED resulted in modest changes in clinical practice, mainly by increasing clinician adherence to the guidelines.
BibTeX
@article{gildenhuys2008does,
  author = {Johann Gildenhuys and Mark Lee and Geoffrey K. Isbister},
  title = {{Does implementation of a paediatric asthma clinical practice guideline worksheet change clinical practice?}},
  journal = {International Journal of Emergency Medicine},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1007/s12245-008-0063-x},
}
Figure