Does Help-Seeking Message Content Impact Online Charitable Behavior? A Qualitative Comparative Analysis Based on 40 Waterdrop Projects

Yanzhi Liu, Rong Cao, Zheng WangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) to explore how different combinations of elements in online help-seeking messages influence charitable donations. It finds that moral and rational appeals are consistently necessary, while specific combinations of emotional and economic content create different pathways to successful fundraising.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Online charitable giving has exploded, but many projects still fail to meet their fundraising goals. Traditional research often treats message components independently, assuming a simple cause-and-effect. However, help-seeking messages are complex, with elements interacting in non-linear ways. This paper addresses the challenge of understanding these complex interactions and how different combinations of message content can lead to successful online charitable behavior, moving beyond a simple "more is better" approach.

Methods

The researchers employed Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), a method that treats cases as configurations of conditions rather than isolated variables. They used both crisp-set QCA (for binary presence/absence) and fuzzy-set QCA (for partial membership) to analyze their data. The core of their method involved:

  1. Identifying Condition Variables: Based on literature review and qualitative analysis of messages, they identified five key content elements: rational appeals, positive emotions, negative emotions, moral appeals, and economic condition.
  2. Necessity Analysis: This step determined if any single condition was always present when online charitable behavior occurred.
  3. Sufficiency Analysis: This step identified specific combinations (configurations) of conditions that were sufficient to lead to online charitable behavior. They focused on an intermediate solution, distinguishing between "core" and "peripheral" conditions within these configurations.
  4. Robustness Testing: They adjusted parameters to ensure the findings were stable.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 40 Waterdrop projects. Waterdrop is a prominent online fundraising platform in China. The researchers selected these 40 cases from a larger dataset of 480 projects, carefully choosing them for similarity, comparability, and diversity to ensure representative configurations. The outcome variable (online charitable behavior) was measured by the fundraising rate (donated amount / target amount).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Simple Causality: The most significant insight is that online charitable behavior isn't driven by single factors in isolation. Instead, it's the combination of elements that matters, highlighting the power of equifinality (multiple pathways to the same outcome).
  • Moral & Rational Appeals are Foundational: These two elements consistently emerged as necessary conditions. This suggests that without a basis of trust (rational appeals) and a call to ethical duty (moral appeals), other message components are unlikely to be effective on their own.
  • Emotional & Economic Content are Configurational: While not necessary on their own, positive and negative emotions, and the way economic hardship is presented, play crucial roles in specific configurations that lead to donations. Their impact is highly dependent on what other elements are present.
  • Negative Content Can Be Tricky: While negative emotions can sometimes drive donations (negative state release model), the study suggests that in certain configurations, the absence of negative emotional language is more conducive to success, possibly by avoiding triggering fear and information avoidance.

Key Results

  • Necessity:
    • Moral appeals were found to be a necessary condition for online charitable behavior (consistency > 0.9).
  • Rational appeals were also identified as a necessary condition (consistency ≈ 0.9).
  • Positive emotions, negative emotions, and economic condition were not necessary on their own.
  • Sufficiency: Three distinct configurations of message content were found to be sufficient for driving online charitable behavior, explaining 63.49% of the cases:
  • Configuration 1: Core conditions: Moral appeals (present), Negative emotions (absent), Economic condition (absent). Peripheral condition: Rational appeals (present). This configuration emphasizes moral duty and avoids negative framing and explicit financial hardship.
  • Configuration 2: Core conditions: Positive emotions (present), Moral appeals (present). Peripheral conditions: Rational appeals (present), Economic condition (absent). This configuration combines positive framing with moral appeals and avoids highlighting economic distress.
  • Configuration 3: Core conditions: Positive emotions (present), Moral appeals (present). Peripheral condition: Rational appeals (present), Negative emotions (absent). This configuration also leverages positive emotions and moral appeals, while avoiding negative emotional language.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study used only 40 Waterdrop projects, which may limit the external validity of the findings. Future work should expand the sample size and include data from other platforms.
  • Fuzzy Set Calibration Subjectivity: While efforts were made to reduce bias, the calibration of qualitative data into fuzzy sets can still involve a degree of subjectivity. Future research could explore combining QCA with other methods to refine these calibrations.
  • Static Context: The analysis considered message content in a static context. Future research could employ Temporal Qualitative Comparative Analysis (TQCA) to explore the dynamic relationships of message content over time.
  • Beyond Text: The study focused on textual content. Other factors like images, videos, and fundraising dynamics were not included but could also influence charitable behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

A help-seeking message is composed of abundant types of content; therefore, it is unsuitable for analysis by the traditional methods that assume that variables are independent of one another. To address this problem, we introduced qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) to explore the synergistic effects of help-seeking message content on online charitable behavior. Crisp-set QCA and fuzzy-set QCA were both used to analyze qualitative and quantitative data from 40 Waterdrop projects. To analyze the qualitative data, three members of our research team intensively and separately read a large number of help-seeking messages, analyzed and summarized the main content referring to previous studies on charitable donation, extracted rational appeals, positive emotions, negative emotions, moral appeals, and the economic condition as condition variables, and finally determined the coding rules collaboratively. The necessity analysis results show that moral appeals and rational appeals are necessary conditions for online charitable behavior. The sufficiency analysis results show that there are three configurations impacting online charitable behavior. This study can help inspire future studies shifting from a traditional perspective to a configuration perspective and help seekers obtain more charitable donations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023does,
  author = {Yanzhi Liu and Rong Cao and Zheng Wang},
  title = {{Does Help-Seeking Message Content Impact Online Charitable Behavior? A Qualitative Comparative Analysis Based on 40 Waterdrop Projects}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15021094},
}
Figure