Does Environmental Interpretation Impact Public Ecological Flow Experience and Responsible Behavior? A Case Study of Potatso National Park, China

Tiantian Tang, Minyan Zhao, Dan Wang, Xiangyu Chen, Wuqiang Chen, Chunwen Xie, Yan DingInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how environmental interpretation in national parks influences visitor motivation, ecological experience, attitudes, and ultimately, responsible behavior. Using a case study of Potatso National Park in China and structural equation modeling, the research found that while visitor motivation directly enhances ecological flow experience, it's the subsequent development of environmental attitudes, mediated by this experience, that truly drives responsible behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

National parks are crucial for nature preservation and educating the public. However, there's a need to understand how environmental interpretation—the communication of natural and cultural information—effectively translates into tangible outcomes like enhanced visitor experiences and actual environmentally responsible actions. While previous research has touched on visitor satisfaction and interpretation methods, there's a gap in quantitatively analyzing the complex interplay between visitor motivation, their "ecological flow experience" (a state of deep engagement), their environmental attitudes, and their subsequent behavior. This paper aims to fill this gap by proposing and testing a model that clarifies these relationships within the context of a real-world national park.

Methods

The study employed a quantitative approach using structural equation modeling (SEM), specifically with Amos software, to analyze data collected from visitor questionnaires. The researchers developed a conceptual model based on Flow Theory, which posits that optimal experiences occur when challenges match skills, leading to deep engagement and positive outcomes. This model included four key variables: visit motivation, ecological flow experience, environmental attitude, and responsible behavior, with environmental interpretation acting as the overarching context. They tested seven hypotheses regarding direct and mediating effects between these variables.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 568 valid questionnaires collected from visitors at Potatso National Park, Shangri-La, Yunnan Province, China, between June and September 2019. The questionnaire included items measuring visit motivation, ecological flow experience, environmental attitude, and responsible behavior, with many items adapted from existing literature. Demographic and visit characteristic data were also collected. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flow Theory is a useful lens: The study successfully applies Flow Theory to understand how visitors become deeply engaged with the natural environment, moving beyond passive observation.
  • Motivation is the spark, not the whole fire: While visitor motivation is crucial for initiating an ecological flow experience, it doesn't directly lead to responsible behavior. This highlights the need for intermediate steps.
  • Environmental attitudes are the bridge: The research strongly suggests that environmental interpretation's primary role is to foster positive environmental attitudes, which then act as the critical link to encouraging responsible behavior.
  • Interpretation needs to be experiential: The findings underscore the importance of making environmental interpretation engaging and experiential to enrich the "ecological flow experience."

Key Results

  • Hypothesis 1 (H1) Supported: Visit motivation significantly and positively impacts ecological flow experience (path coefficient = 0.473).
  • Hypothesis 2 (H2) Not Supported: Visit motivation does not directly impact responsible behavior (p = 0.147).
  • Hypothesis 3 (H3) Not Supported: Ecological flow experience does not directly impact responsible behavior (p = 0.88).
  • Hypothesis 4 (H4) Supported: Ecological flow experience significantly and positively impacts environmental attitude (path coefficient = 0.773).
  • Hypothesis 5 (H5) Supported: Environmental attitude significantly and positively impacts responsible behavior (path coefficient = 0.635).
  • Hypothesis 6 (H6) Not Supported: Ecological flow experience does not mediate the influence of visit motivation on responsible behavior (p = 0.903).
  • Hypothesis 7 (H7) Supported: Ecological flow experience mediates the influence of visit motivation on environmental attitudes and, consequently, responsible behavior (p = 0.000).

The overall model fit indices (GFI=0.919, AGFI=0.898, NFI=0.885, TLI=0.921, CFI=0.932) indicated an acceptable to ideal fit for the structural model.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Temporal Scope: The survey was conducted over a single year, and a multi-year study could provide a more comprehensive understanding of visitor motivations and experiences.
  • Park Conditions: Potatso National Park was undergoing pilot reform and affected by COVID-19, leading to reduced accessibility and closed interpretive points, which may have limited the ecological experience opportunities.
  • Generalizability: The study was a case study of one park. Future research should explore environmental interpretation in other national parks and analyze how different classification variables might moderate the relationship between interpretation and visitor outcomes.

Future work could focus on refining interpretation strategies, integrating technology (like APPs), and developing multi-dimensional interpretation across themes, spaces, and time to better cater to diverse visitor motivations and enhance ecological experiences.

Summary updated

Abstract

Being responsible for ensuring nature preservation, environmental interpretation raises people's awareness of nature preservation as a form of public service, and enhance their environmentally responsible behavior. Based on the flow theory, this study proposes a conceptual model of environmental interpretation impacts on visit motivation, ecological experience, environmental attitudes, and environmental behaviors. Selecting the users (visitors) of environmental interpretation at Potatso National Park in Shangri-La, Yunnan Province, China, we obtained 568 valid questionnaires and used Amos software to analyze a structural equation model to verify the model. The results indicate that the environmental interpretation plays a significant role in enriching the public's ecological experience, which is an intermediary variable in which visiting motivation influences environmental attitudes and guides environmentally responsible behavior. The research suggests that national parks should strengthen the environmental interpretation facilities experiential and available, and adjust the configuration of the existing interpretation media in the three-dimensional structure of theme, space, and time, considering the motivation of the public visits, enriching ecological experience, and inspiring service details.
BibTeX
@article{tang2022does,
  author = {Tiantian Tang and Minyan Zhao and Dan Wang and Xiangyu Chen and Wuqiang Chen and Chunwen Xie and Yan Ding},
  title = {{Does Environmental Interpretation Impact Public Ecological Flow Experience and Responsible Behavior? A Case Study of Potatso National Park, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19159630},
}
Figure