Does domestication trade-off stress tolerance for leaf growth? A search for evidence across eight Pooideae grass species

Jie Yun, Chenyang Yuan, Katherine Irelan, Mj Kabongo, Eldar Urkumbayev, David L. Des MaraisbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Plant domestication is thought to create trade-offs between high yield and stress tolerance, raising concerns about yield stability in future climates. Previous studies have found limited direct evidence for such trade-offs, often focusing on weakened defenses associated with higher growth rates. However, trade-offs can also occur when traits (such as yield in agriculture) optimized for favorable conditions perform less efficiently in stressful conditions. Deciphering the mechanisms driving these trade-offs is crucial for maintaining yield in changing environments. We examine leaf growth, a key trait influencing carbon assimilation, in eight species of grasses. We use a machine learning pipeline to automatically extract cell dimensions and positions from leaf microscope images to study cell kinematics, finding that domesticated plants generally have longer leaves, larger division zones and higher cell production rates. We found no clear evidence of trade-off between domestication and drought response in final leaf length. However, a trade-off is observed in development as wild species exhibited a smaller decrease in elongation zone size under drought than their domesticated counterparts. These nuanced trade-offs associated with domestication highlight the importance of examining physiological traits and mechanisms in greater detail, possibly informing breeding strategies to enhance crop resilience in the face of climate change.

Introduction

For decades, biologists have debated the "domestication trade-off" hypothesis: the idea that breeding crops for maximum yield under ideal conditions has inadvertently compromised their natural stress-response mechanisms. As climate change increases the frequency of drought, understanding this trade-off is critical for future food security. While most studies focus on broad traits like total biomass, this research investigates the kinematics of leaf growth—the cellular-level mechanics of development—to determine if the growth machinery of domesticated grasses responds differently to water scarcity than their wild ancestors.

Experimental Design and Dataset

The study examined eight species within the Pooideae subfamily, focusing on four pairs of domesticated crops and their wild relatives: wheat, oat, and barley, along with the model organism Brachypodium distachyon.

Table 1: Species and accessions used in the study, including wheat varieties and their domestication status.
Table 2: Continuation of species list including oat, barley, and purple false brome accessions.

Methods

The researchers developed a high-throughput phenotyping pipeline to bridge the gap between whole-plant growth and cellular mechanics:

  1. Macro-Growth Tracking: Raspberry Pi cameras photographed leaves every four hours, with data fitted to a Beta-sigmoid model to calculate elongation rates.
  2. Micro-Growth Analysis: Microscopy imprints of leaf surfaces were used to observe cellular structures.
  3. Machine Learning Pipeline: The team used Cellpose 3.0, a deep-learning tool, to automatically segment and measure over 530,000 cells across nearly 6,000 images.
  4. Kinematic Modeling: By combining cell size and position data, they calculated "cell flux" (production rate) and the size of the division and elongation zones.

Key Results and Insights

The study found that domesticated plants possess "bigger engines": they have significantly larger division zones and higher cell production rates (cell flux) than wild species, which accounts for their longer leaves.

Interestingly, the trade-off for this high performance is developmental rather than final. While drought reduced leaf length across all species (p = 6.4E-45), domesticated plants did not "collapse" more than wild ones in terms of final leaf length; they still produced longer leaves than their wild counterparts under stress.

The true trade-off was revealed in the elongation zone. Under drought, domesticated plants showed a much sharper decrease in elongation zone size compared to wild relatives (p = 8.4E-06). Wild species exhibited higher developmental stability, maintaining more consistent growth machinery even if their baseline growth was slower. This suggests that the massive growth gains achieved through domestication are primarily realized under optimal conditions; when stress hits, these high-performance traits are the first to be throttled back.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research highlights that domestication has optimized plants for high performance in favorable environments at the cost of developmental plasticity under stress. While leaf elongation is only one aspect of plant resilience, these findings suggest that future breeding could aim to combine the "big engine" of domesticated crops with the "sturdy chassis" or developmental stability found in wild relatives. Future work applying this ML pipeline across the entire plant life cycle or integrating genomic data could help identify the specific genes responsible for this stability, informing strategies for climate-resilient agriculture.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Plant domestication is thought to create trade-offs between high yield and stress tolerance, raising concerns about yield stability in future climates. Previous studies have found limited direct evidence for such trade-offs, often focusing on weakened defenses associated with higher growth rates. However, trade-offs can also occur when traits (such as yield in agriculture) optimized for favorable conditions perform less efficiently in stressful conditions. Deciphering the mechanisms driving these trade-offs is crucial for maintaining yield in changing environments. We examine leaf growth, a key trait influencing carbon assimilation, in eight species of grasses. We use a machine learning pipeline to automatically extract cell dimensions and positions from leaf microscope images to study cell kinematics, finding that domesticated plants generally have longer leaves, larger division zones and higher cell production rates. We found no clear evidence of trade-off between domestication and drought response in final leaf length. However, a trade-off is observed in development as wild species exhibited a smaller decrease in elongation zone size under drought than their domesticated counterparts. These nuanced trade-offs associated with domestication highlight the importance of examining physiological traits and mechanisms in greater detail, possibly informing breeding strategies to enhance crop resilience in the face of climate change. Highlight This study uses a high throughput pipeline to characterize leaf elongation responding to drought stress across eight species including barley, wheat, oat and wild relatives.
BibTeX
@misc{yun2024does,
  author = {Jie Yun and Chenyang Yuan and Katherine Irelan and MJ Kabongo and Eldar Urkumbayev and David L. Des Marais},
  title = {{Does domestication trade-off stress tolerance for leaf growth? A search for evidence across eight Pooideae grass species}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.11.30.626197},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure