Abstract
Exoskeletons are wearable devices closely coupled to the human, which can interact with the musculoskeletal system, e.g., to augment physical and functional capabilities. A main prerequisite for the development and application of exoskeletons is to investigate the human-exoskeleton interaction, particularly in terms of potential inferences with human motor control. Therefore, the purpose of the present study was to investigate whether a passive unilateral lower limb exoskeleton has an impact on static and dynamic reactive balance control. Eleven healthy subjects (22.9 ± 2.5 yrs, 5 females) volunteered for this study and performed three different balance tasks: bipedal standing, single-leg standing, and platform perturbations in single-leg standing. All the balance tasks were conducted with and without a passive unilateral lower limb exoskeleton, while force plates and a motion capture system were used to capture the center of pressure mean sway velocity and the time to stabilization, respectively. Dependent t-tests were separately run for both static balance tests, and a repeated-measure analysis of variance with factors exoskeleton and direction of perturbation was calculated for the dynamic reactive balance task. The exoskeleton did not significantly influence postural sway in bipedal stance. However, in single-leg stance, the mediolateral mean sway velocity of the center of pressure was significantly shorter for the exoskeleton condition. For the dynamic reactive balance task, the participants tended to regain stability less quickly with the exoskeleton, as indicated by a large effect size and longer time to stabilization for all directions of perturbation. In summary, the study showed that the exoskeleton provided some assistive support under static conditions, which however may disappear when sufficient stability is available (bipedal stance). Besides, the exoskeleton tended to impair dynamic reactive balance, potentially by impeding adequate compensatory adjustments. These are important findings with strong implications for the future design and application of exoskeletons, emphasizing the significance of taking into account the mechanisms of human motor control.
Introduction
As exoskeletons transition from laboratory prototypes to industrial and clinical tools, understanding their impact on human motor control is paramount. While much research focuses on metabolic efficiency and gait assistance, the fundamental requirement of balance is often overlooked. For an exoskeleton to be truly functional, it must be kinematically compatible—meaning it should not hinder the user's natural ability to maintain or regain stability. This study, published in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, investigates how a passive unilateral lower limb exoskeleton affects both static stability and dynamic reactive balance.
Methodology
Participants and Device Design
The study recruited 11 healthy participants (mean age 22.9 years). Due to the rigid, non-adjustable nature of the exoskeleton frame, the sample was limited to individuals fitting specific physical dimensions (shank length 40–42 cm). The custom-built passive exoskeleton was worn on the left leg, featuring aluminum frames and single-degree-of-freedom (DoF) joints at the knee and ankle, which restricted movement to the sagittal plane.
Experimental Tasks
Participants were tested under two conditions—with and without the exoskeleton—across three tasks:
- Bipedal Static Balance: Standing still on two legs on a force plate.
- Single-Leg Static Balance: Standing on the exoskeleton-equipped leg.
- Dynamic Reactive Balance: Standing on one leg on a Posturomed platform, which was subjected to sudden displacements in four directions (anterior, posterior, medial, and lateral).
Stability was quantified using Center of Pressure (CoP) sway velocity for static tasks and Time to Stabilization (TTS) for dynamic tasks.
Results and Discussion
The Bracing Effect in Static Balance
In the single-leg static stance, the exoskeleton provided a measurable benefit. The mediolateral CoP sway velocity was significantly lower with the device (21.80 mm/s) than without it (26.10 mm/s), yielding a large effect size ($d = 1.13$). This suggests a "bracing effect" where the rigid aluminum frame mechanically stabilized the ankle against side-to-side movement, despite the joints being designed for forward/backward motion. Interestingly, this benefit vanished during bipedal standing, likely because the body's inherent stability in that posture rendered the mechanical assistance redundant.
Dynamic Interference and Stability Thresholds
When faced with sudden perturbations, the exoskeleton became a hindrance. Participants took longer to stabilize in every direction when wearing the device. For example, anterior stabilization time rose from 1.29s to 1.67s. While the statistical significance ($p = 0.154$) was marginal, the large effect size ($n_p^2 = 0.19$) indicates a substantial practical impact on the body's ability to regain equilibrium.
This interference is likely due to the device's weight and mechanical constraints "muffling" the high-frequency, multi-joint adjustments required to recover from a trip or push. The study also noted that recovering from medial (inward) pushes remained the most challenging task, a difficulty exacerbated by the exoskeleton.
Conclusion
This research identifies a critical trade-off in exoskeleton design: a device that provides beneficial bracing during static tasks may simultaneously impair dynamic safety. These findings suggest that future designs should prioritize higher degrees of freedom at the joints to minimize interference with reactive motor control. Furthermore, long-term studies are needed to determine if users can eventually adapt their motor strategies to overcome these dynamic limitations.
Summary updated