Documenting the Unwritten Curriculum of Student Research

Shomir WilsonACL 2024

TL;DR

This paper introduces a set of publicly available online guides designed to demystify the "hidden curriculum" of academic research for graduate and undergraduate students. By documenting unwritten norms, strategies, and common obstacles, these guides aim to improve advising efficiency, fairness, and student success.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Academic research, especially at the graduate level, involves more than just technical skills and methodological knowledge. There's a significant "hidden curriculum" – an unwritten set of customs, strategies, and experiential knowledge that students must learn to navigate successfully. This includes understanding research work strategies, common pitfalls, collaboration dynamics, conference etiquette, and scholarly writing conventions. Mentors often don't explicitly teach these aspects, leaving students to figure them out through trial and error, which can be inefficient and frustrating. This paper addresses the gap in formalizing and disseminating this crucial, yet often unspoken, knowledge to support student researchers.

Methods

The author's "method" is the creation and dissemination of a set of online guides. These guides are not based on empirical studies or novel algorithms but rather on the author's personal experience as a professor and advisor. The approach is described as a "flipped classroom" in a one-on-one context, where students are expected to read the guides before discussing them with their advisor. The guides are designed to be accessible, approachable, and available on demand, supplementing direct advising.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Hidden Curriculum" is Real and Impactful: The paper highlights that much of what makes a student successful in research isn't taught in classes but learned through experience. This includes practical advice on productivity, dealing with setbacks, and understanding academic norms.
  • Proactive Documentation Improves Advising: By creating and sharing these guides, the author aims to make advising more efficient and equitable. Students can access information independently, freeing up one-on-one time for more personalized discussions.
  • Accessibility is Key: Making these guides publicly available online (as webpages) ensures they can be easily found and used by a broad audience, not just the author's direct advisees.
  • A Positive Tone is More Effective: The author suggests that a "citation positive" tone, focusing on the value of citations, is more engaging than a punitive approach to plagiarism.
  • Guides Serve Multiple Purposes: Beyond direct advising, these materials can be used in classroom settings, as a recruiting tool for prospective students, and even contribute to broader public awareness of student research challenges.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results from experiments. Instead, it focuses on the qualitative impact and utility of the guides. The author notes that the guides have "received strong positive feedback from the research community" anecdotally. The key "result" is the creation of a structured, accessible resource that addresses a recognized gap in research training.

Limitations and Future Work

The author acknowledges that some of the information in the guides is specific to academic norms at research universities in the United States. However, they believe most of the content is applicable to an international audience of student researchers, particularly in computing and NLP. The paper doesn't explicitly detail future work on the guides themselves but implicitly suggests that other faculty could benefit from creating similar resources. The author also mentions that faculty might consider creating such materials as part of their service duties.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wilson2024documenting,
  author = {Shomir Wilson},
  title = {{Documenting the Unwritten Curriculum of Student Research}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure