TL;DR
This paper investigates whether Large Language Models (LLMs) can truly understand and generate domain-specific conceptual knowledge, moving beyond mere memorization. They introduce a novel method combining "Neighbor Semantic Structure" (NSS) and "Chain-of-Thought" (CoT) prompting to generate concept sememe trees, demonstrating that LLMs can indeed capture and represent this deeper knowledge.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
While LLMs have shown impressive capabilities in various NLP tasks and are known to encode a vast amount of factual and lexical knowledge, there's a significant gap in understanding their grasp of domain conceptual knowledge. This type of knowledge refers to the intricate web of core concepts, terms, and their relationships within a specific field, which is crucial for true understanding and application. Existing research has largely focused on factual recall or definition generation, neglecting the deeper, hierarchical semantic structures that define specialized domains. This paper aims to bridge this gap by evaluating LLMs' ability to generate concept sememe trees, a structured representation of this domain knowledge.
Methods
The authors propose a systematic approach to evaluate LLMs' domain conceptual knowledge through concept sememe tree generation. Their method involves several key stages:
- Neighbor Semantic Structure (NSS): This technique leverages terminological metaphor theory to identify terms that share similar semantic structures and conceptual connotations, even across different domains. These "neighboring" terms are then used as examples to guide the LLM.
- Chain-of-Thought (CoT) Prompting: This method guides the LLM through a structured thinking process, breaking down the task of sememe tree generation into steps: identifying the core sememe, generating related sememes, establishing relationships between them, and finally forming the complete tree.
- Prompt Engineering: A carefully designed prompt incorporates task instructions, output format rules (KDML, List, JSON, Quintuple), CoT guidance, and NSS examples to elicit accurate sememe tree generation.
- Post-processing: To ensure adherence to the required output format and semantic consistency, a post-processing step is applied to reformat and correct any generated sememe trees.
Datasets
The experimental dataset is derived from four authoritative terminology manuals covering:
- Atmospheric Science
- Mechanical Engineering
- Computer Science and Technology
- Electric Power Engineering
A bilingual dataset in Chinese and English was created, with 800 terms evenly extracted from these four sources (200 per domain). This dataset was split into a test set and a retrieval set in a 1:1 ratio.
Key Insights and Ideas
- LLMs can grasp deeper conceptual knowledge: The results strongly suggest that LLMs are not just memorizing terms but can actually understand and represent the underlying conceptual structures of specialized domains.
- NSS is crucial for context and relationships: The Neighbor Semantic Structure, by providing semantically related examples, significantly helps LLMs understand the hierarchical relationships between terms and their conceptual underpinnings.
- CoT unlocks systematic reasoning: The Chain-of-Thought prompting method enables LLMs to break down the complex task of sememe tree generation into manageable steps, leading to more accurate and structured outputs.
- Quintuple format is most effective: Among the tested output formats, the quintuple format yielded the highest performance, likely due to its straightforward structure and clear delimiters, which LLMs can more easily process.
Key Results
The experimental results indicate that LLMs, particularly GPT-4o and DeepSeek-V3, exhibit a measurable ability to generate semantic concepts associated with terms. When NSS examples were integrated with the CoT process, LLMs were able to explore domain conceptual knowledge more profoundly, leading to highly accurate concept sememe trees.
For instance, in the mixed Chinese-English dataset, DeepSeek-V3 achieved an F1 score of 56.00% for the "First Sememe" metric, and GPT-4o achieved 50.00%. Ablation studies showed that removing NSS or CoT significantly degraded performance, with the absence of NSS causing metrics to drop to near zero, highlighting their critical role. The quintuple output format consistently outperformed other formats across all metrics.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that LLMs' understanding and reasoning about term semantics are still imperfect, and they face challenges when processing terms over extended periods. This suggests that their understanding of term concepts remains limited. Future work should focus on enhancing LLMs' ability to grasp term concept semantics more deeply. The study also highlights the importance of structured prompting and providing relevant examples (like NSS) for improving LLM performance on complex knowledge-intensive tasks.
Summary updated