Do gravitational wave observations in the lower mass gap favor a hierarchical triple origin?

V. Gayathri, I. Bartos, S. Rosswog, M. Coleman Miller, Doğa Veske, Wen Lu, Szabolcs MárkaarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: Observations of compact objects in Galactic binaries have provided tentative evidence of a dearth of masses in the so-called lower mass gap $\sim2.2-5$ M$_\odot$. Nevertheless, two such objects have been discovered in gravitational-wave data from LIGO and Virgo. Remarkably, the estimated masses of both secondaries in the coalescences GW190814 ($m_2=2.59^{+0.08}_{-0.09}$M$_\odot$) and GW200210_092254 ($m_2=2.83^{+0.47}_{-0.42}$M$_\odot$) fall near the total mass of $\sim 2.6$ M$_\odot$ of observed Galactic binary neutron star systems. The more massive components of the two binaries also have similar masses. Here we show that a neutron star merger origin of the lighter components in GW190814 and GW200210_092254 is favored over $M^{-2.3}$ (Bayes factor $\mathcal{B}\sim 5$) and uniform ($\mathcal{B}\sim 14$) mass distributions in the lower mass gap. We also examine the statistical significance of the similarity between the heavier component masses of GW190814 and GW200210_092254, and find that a model in which the mass of GW200210_092254 is drawn from the mass posterior of GW190814 is preferred ($\mathcal{B}\sim 18$) to a model in which its mass is drawn from the overall mass distribution of black holes detected in gravitational wave events. This hints at a common origin of the primary masses, as well as the secondary masses, in GW190814 and GW200210_092254.

Introduction

The landscape of compact objects—neutron stars and black holes—has long featured a puzzling "lower mass gap." Observations of Galactic binaries have historically shown a dearth of objects with masses between approximately 2.2 and 5 $M_\odot$. This gap separates the most massive known neutron stars from the lightest black holes. However, recent gravitational-wave (GW) detections by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaboration have challenged this paradigm. Specifically, two events, GW190814 and GW200210_092254, involved secondary components with masses of $2.59 M_\odot$ and $2.83 M_\odot$, respectively. These masses fall squarely within the lower mass gap, raising fundamental questions about their origin.

Formation Channels for Mass-Gap Objects

Explaining the presence of objects in the mass gap requires looking beyond standard stellar evolution. Several astrophysical scenarios have been proposed to account for these "impossible" objects:

  1. Binary Neutron Star (BNS) Remnants: The object is the product of a previous merger between two neutron stars. The resulting remnant's mass would naturally fall into the 2.5–3 $M_\odot$ range.
  2. AGN Disk Accretion: In the dense, gas-rich environment of an Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN) disk, a neutron star can grow by accreting surrounding material until it enters the mass gap.
  3. Dynamical Capture: In dense stellar clusters, random gravitational encounters can lead to the formation of binaries involving mass-gap objects formed through various exotic processes.
Conceptual diagrams of formation channels for compact object binaries: (a) isolated binary evolution, (b) accretion within an AGN disk, and (c) dynamical interactions in a dense stellar cluster.

A key challenge for the BNS remnant hypothesis is retention. In typical environments, the "kick" from gravitational waves during a merger often ejects the remnant from its host system. The authors suggest that a hierarchical triple system—where a binary is orbited by a more massive third body—could provide the necessary gravitational binding energy to retain the remnant, allowing it to eventually merge with the third body and produce the observed GW signals.

Statistical Methodology

To distinguish between these possibilities, the researchers employed Bayesian model comparison. They tested the observed secondary masses against four distinct population models:

  • Galactic BNS Model: Based on the total mass distribution of known binary neutron stars in the Milky Way ($∼ 2.65 \pm 0.12 M_\odot$).
  • AGN Accretion Model: A model accounting for mass growth in gas-rich disks.
  • Uniform Distribution: A null hypothesis where all masses in the gap are equally likely.
  • Power-law Distribution: A model following a $m^{-2.3}$ distribution, consistent with the stellar initial mass function.

Additionally, they analyzed the primary masses of the two events. Both primaries are remarkably similar, weighing in at approximately 23–24 $M_\odot$. The study compared a model where these primaries share a common origin against one where they are drawn randomly from the broader black hole population.

Key Results and Evidence

The analysis reveals a strong statistical preference for the BNS merger remnant origin. The Galactic BNS model is favored over the power-law model by a Bayes factor of $\mathcal{B} \sim 5$ and over the uniform model by $\mathcal{B} \sim 14$. This suggests that the secondary masses are not random but are instead clustered around the expected mass of a BNS merger product.

Posterior mass distributions for the primary ($m_1$) and secondary ($m_2$) components of GW190814 and GW200210_092254, compared against various astrophysical models.

Furthermore, the similarity between the primary masses of GW190814 and GW200210_092254 is highly significant. A model assuming a common origin for these primaries is preferred by a Bayes factor of $\mathcal{B} \sim 18$ over a random-draw model. This "double coincidence" of both primary and secondary masses being nearly identical across two separate events strongly hints at a repeatable, specific formation channel like hierarchical triples.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the current evidence is compelling, it is based on a small sample size of two events. The study also assumes that BNS systems across the universe follow the mass distribution observed in our own Galaxy, which may not account for cosmic evolution or environmental differences.

As the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA network continues its fourth observing run (O4), the detection of more objects in the lower mass gap will be critical. If the hierarchical triple hypothesis holds, we should expect to see more events with secondary masses clustered around 2.6 $M_\odot$ and primary masses that follow specific, non-random patterns. These observations will ultimately determine if the "mass gap" is truly empty or if it is populated by the remnants of previous cosmic collisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Observations of compact objects in Galactic binaries have provided tentative evidence of a dearth of masses in the so-called lower mass gap $\sim2.2-5$ M$_\odot$. Nevertheless, two such objects have been discovered in gravitational-wave data from LIGO and Virgo. Remarkably, the estimated masses of both secondaries in the coalescences GW190814 ($m_2=2.59^{+0.08}_{-0.09}$M$_\odot$) and GW200210_092254 ($m_2=2.83^{+0.47}_{-0.42}$M$_\odot$) fall near the total mass of $\sim 2.6$ M$_\odot$ of observed Galactic binary neutron star systems. The more massive components of the two binaries also have similar masses. Here we show that a neutron star merger origin of the lighter components in GW190814 and GW200210_092254 is favored over $M^{-2.3}$ (Bayes factor $\mathcal{B}\sim 5$) and uniform ($\mathcal{B}\sim 14$) mass distributions in the lower mass gap. We also examine the statistical significance of the similarity between the heavier component masses of GW190814 and GW200210_092254, and find that a model in which the mass of GW200210_092254 is drawn from the mass posterior of GW190814 is preferred ($\mathcal{B}\sim 18$) to a model in which its mass is drawn from the overall mass distribution of black holes detected in gravitational wave events. This hints at a common origin of the primary masses, as well as the secondary masses, in GW190814 and GW200210_092254.
BibTeX
@misc{gayathri2023do,
  author = {V. Gayathri and I. Bartos and S. Rosswog and M. Coleman Miller and Doğa Veske and Wen Lu and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Do gravitational wave observations in the lower mass gap favor a hierarchical triple origin?}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2307.09097},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09097},
}
Figure